Start them mostly in offensive zone then.
Tlusty - Staal - Semin works fine even tho its an very offensive balanced line.
First of all that line doesn't have a really small guy out there. 2ndly they play a different and more puck carrying kind of hockey. Dumping the puck in often means giving the oposition the puck and at times they will gain our zone, leaving three of our worst defensive players out there. Even if you get McD and Girardi out with that line, they're bound to struggle. If MZA is going to be effective in the top six, he'll need a power forward on the other wing. Maybe MZA-Richards-Callahan would work .
Hags - Stepan - Nash
MZA - Richards - Callahan
Kreider - Miller - Gaborik
Newbury -Boyle - Asham