2025 NHL Playoffs | Page 32 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

2025 NHL Playoffs

Taking a step back from which team I like and don’t like, there is a big difference between over the line hits and taking out the opposing goalie. Goalies can make or break a cup run.

If Kronwall takes Giguere out in the first game of the 2007 series, do we get the Selanne winning goal. And if we do, is it just a great game winning goal in a losing series and not iconic. Ducks fans would be irate, especially with no punishment.

Granted Stolarz is not Giguere and Bryzgalov did step up against the Wild. But there is also a good chance we have no banner.

I hate dirty play, but if I've learned anything from decades of playoff hockey, it's that the cheapshot-er generally comes out of it way better than the cheapshot-ee.

When Maltby hacked Selanne in the leg in '97 and slowed him down for the series, no one outside of Anaheim gave it a 2nd thought. When Draper got his face rearranged by Lemieux, no one discredited the Avs win when they were skating around with the Cup.

Sad to say, but if taking out Stolarz ends up killing off the Leafs they'll whine about it for decades, but if the Panthers go on to win the Cup you think anyone but Leafs fans will really care? There's no asterisks engraved on the Cup.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 70sSanO
I know it’s not the same, unfortunately, but I think with true Cup contenders you see some of that old school physicality and toughness. Not every player willing to go, but when you look at teams like the Panthers, youve got your mix of Perry types, Pronger types and your Selannes.Ratana

Thats why these cheap shots and stuff dont phase me. Its playoff hockey. When we were at our best, we pulled the same stuff.

I understand and that is what makes playoff hockey key great.

My issues is with taking out goalies.

Same with Stars and Jets, well keeping Hellebuyck in might be better for the Stars.

I don’t think anyone is going to stop the Stars, especially if they get healthy. But if Ottenger gets injured intentionally, it will even things up for the remaining teams.

John
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad