Pre-Game Talk: 2025 NHL Draft Thread

  • Lakovic - I don't like him, has size but doesn't use it
  • Mrtka - Too High, Just raw potential at this point
  • Hensler - Too Low, Potentially lower ceiling then Mrtka but safer IMO.
  • Spence - Not a Top20 guy IMO.
  • Carbonneau - Plays too much of an individual game for my liking.
  • Fiddler - Too High
  • Bear - Too low. I really like Bear's game. He plays with intensity and pace.
Appreciate the feedback. I get where you are coming from, but this was my thinking:
  • I don't love Lakovic, but I don't love annyone after him either. He is big and skilled though, so that is good foundation.
  • Mrtka even if he doesn't fully realize potential, he has legit chance at becoming Tyler Myers-type player, which is I think better outcome than pretty much all of the D below him.
  • Hensler I liked much better a year ago. I don't love his progression and question how much more growth we will see.
  • Spence looks like good middle 6 winger to me. Reminds me in some ways of slightly bigger Jake Neighbours.,
  • Your Carbonneau critique sounds like a young David Perron. A better skating Perron would be nice mid-1st pick.
  • Fiddler is admittedly super raw. He is RHD with size and skating and can excel in transition, but there admittedly is risk there. I watch him and think maybe he should be higher.. and then he fumbles puck and it's in the back of his net.
  • Bear plays with intensity and pace, but I don't see the offensive sense or creativity I would want from an average size winger closer to top 10.
EDIT: Forgot to address Martone and O'Brien.
  • Martone I don't love his feet or pace. He can be dominant in juniors but I question his ultimate upside. His talent is obvious, but I have reservations. which caused me to put him below 3 guys I think can each be a 1C.
  • O'Brien I think will continue to rise in leadup to draft. Highly productive, nice size for a center, not super fast but has good feet, like the skill and motor. I see echoes of Robert Thomas in him.
 
Last edited:

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad