Pre-Game Talk: 2025 NHL Draft Thread

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
I'd go into the draft expecting Smith to be gone before us, just because he's a defenseman. Schaefer will go #1, and I bet a needy team will probably take Smith before us. I'd love for us to get at least a top 8 pick this year, then I'd feel more comfortable getting the guy we want, as opposed to whatever is left.

I'll also be curious which player gets over-drafted, could easily see Mrtka being drafted ahead of where many have him ranked because he'd RHD, size, and raw potential.
 
I'd go into the draft expecting Smith to be gone before us, just because he's a defenseman. Schaefer will go #1, and I bet a needy team will probably take Smith before us. I'd love for us to get at least a top 8 pick this year, then I'd feel more comfortable getting the guy we want, as opposed to whatever is left.

I'll also be curious which player gets over-drafted, could easily see Mrtka being drafted ahead of where many have him ranked because he'd RHD, size, and raw potential.
I would say Smith is more of a raw potential pick than Mrtka. I definitely expect Mrtka to go top 10. I think everything is already there for him to be a good NHL defender and good on breakouts. He seems to have great awareness of where everyone is on the ice and is able to use his decent hands and size to often draw in 2 defenders and get the puck to a teammate or into space where a teammate can skate into it. Smith has rare tools, but is a little more chaotic at this point. Definitely would expect his play selection to improve over time though obviously.
 
I would say Smith is more of a raw potential pick than Mrtka. I definitely expect Mrtka to go top 10. I think everything is already there for him to be a good NHL defender and good on breakouts. He seems to have great awareness of where everyone is on the ice and is able to use his decent hands and size to often draw in 2 defenders and get the puck to a teammate or into space where a teammate can skate into it. Smith has rare tools, but is a little more chaotic at this point. Definitely would expect his play selection to improve over time though obviously.
I like smith, but I don’t see that he is significantly better than Lukas Fischer.
 
More I think about it, the more I'm warming up to the idea of McQueen, Desnoyers, Frondell, or O'Brien, if we don't win the lottery and stay in this range (if we do, I gotta say, Misa is my choice for #1). If we dealt Schenn, maybe even Binnington, we could possibly get two firsts (albeit from playoff teams in a weak draft), but I'm warming up to Bill Zonnon or Ivan Ryabkin with extra firsts. Ottawa makes sense, but I wonder if another team would do something for Binnington. I think Ellis/Zherenko deserve a chance at the NHL level.
 
Preferably I'd like to take a center with our 1st. I'm hoping we are able to snag another 1st or 2nd this year to get another defenseman to shore up things a bit. I think we have a glut of great 2nd and 3rd pairing defenseman, but none that are remotely a lock for the first pair. Parayko is getting older and there's no one right now that is close to taking over his spot or minutes.

Burns, Lindstein, and Fischer all seem to be progressing well and can take spots in the top 4. To a lesser extent, I think Loof and Kessel could potentially slot on the 3rd pair (I'd like to see Loof get some reps). Let Jiricek marinate for a good long while before bringing him up if he can stay healthy. Mayich is surprisingly playing good points wise and McIsaac is putting up roughly half a point a game (thought he was one of the only standout defenseman at the prospect tourney/exhibition). Unless Ralph has a huge step in progression, I think he's going to need at least 2 more years. Would be nice though if he could slot in on the 2nd pair like Parayko did in 2026 or 2027.

I think the reality is we desperately have to trade for prospects who are ready to take the next step. Unfortunately, all of our forwards who seem to be part of the core moving forward are our only trade chips to get someone like that, and I always hate trading away our own developed players. I think it would be a huge mistake to trade anyone of Bolduc, Snuggerud, Dvorsky, Stenberg, and Kaskimaki.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PerryTurnbullfan
Is there something you’ve seen to make you say he has a great shot? 2 goals this year isn’t exactly inspiring. Overall though he is definitely a player I like a lot.
Granted he doesn't shoot alot but when he does he picks a corner. He's given to pass more often than shoot. His skating and passing are top notch but i think his shot is underrated because he doesn't choose to shoot often.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LGB

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad