HF Habs: 2025 NHL Draft: Part II

Agree to disagree on Cootes vs. Martin.

I think Cootes has quite a bit more upside than Martin; more skills, higher-end skating, slightly better reads whilst playing with admittedly less edge and intensity.

And I personally have Reschny 22th in my draft ranking, so there are quite a few other players that I would personally take before Reschny if we were to indeed draft at 16.

Here would be my list for reference's sake. Many egregious mistakes there on this ranking, but it is mine and I stand by it.

1- Schaefer17- Reid
2- Misa18- Cootes
3- Hagens19- Hensler
4- Martone20- Martin
5- Frondell21- Kindel
6- Desnoyers22- Reschny
7- Smith23- Spence
8- Eklund24- Potter
9- O'Brien25- Fiddler
10- Mrtka26- Nesbitt
11- Schmidt27- Zonnon
12- Lakovic28- McKinney
13- McQueen29- Gastrin
14- Aitcheson30- Ravensbergen
15- Carbonneau31- Murtagh
16- Bear32- Nobert
W not that strong a league. Doubt Cootes is anymore than 3rd line center.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MarkovsKnee
McQueen injured again. I have him as do not draft. Learned our lesson with Dach. Great size and skill but soft and injury prone. Not worth spending a good first pick on. Too many red flags for Chronic injuries
If he falls to 10, I want Hughes to trade up for McQueen.

Teams might be reluctant to draft him after the Lindstrom fiasco, but as much as a was WAY AGAINST drafting Lindstrom in the top 10 last year, I am all in for McQueen around #10 OA.

First, spondylosis and herniated discs are way different and have a different prognosis. I think the odds of McQueen being 100% next year are very high and those of recurrence, very low.

Also, last year the top 10 was stacked and you still had talents like Dickinson, Buium, etc. around there.

There won't be that this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bleuetbio
If he falls to 10, I want Hughes to trade up for McQueen.

Teams might be reluctant to draft him after the Lindstrom fiasco, but as much as a was WAY AGAINST drafting Lindstrom in the top 10 last year, I am all in for McQueen around #10 OA.

First, spondylosis and herniated discs are way different and have a different prognosis. I think the odds of McQueen being 100% next year are very high and those of recurrence, very low.

Also, last year the top 10 was stacked and you still had talents like Dickinson, Buium, etc. around there.

There won't be that this year.
If we keep both our draft picks and one of McQueen or Bear slides to us because of injuries, I definitely take a chance on them.
 
Its still pretty soon but for now McQueen (slider) and OBrien (would need a move up) are probably the two center with 2nd line upside that we could have a shot too. McQueen so much back problem makes him a risky pick in the top 10 but when the need is here and you have a 6"5 righthanded center a la Staal with some speed and skills, it must be the pick.
 
Last edited:

Ad

Ad