Prospect Info: - 2025 DRAFT Thread | Page 23 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Prospect Info: 2025 DRAFT Thread

I wouldn't bother with any proposals/ideas that have us moving top half of the lineup players for draft picks. I'm not saying it is or isn't good value in the generic sense, but it's certainly not where this club is at. We have to win this coming year.
Oh, I agree. I just made the suggestion by going along with if they are truly intent on moving up for Martone and Boston is the only realistic partner for such a move. Then they are going to have to move roster players, since Boston don't want to rebuild as long as they have McAvoy and Pastrnak.

With that said, I expect Waddell to move one or both picks for immediate help next season. If I had to wager a guess, I'd say that he will push hard to acquire Rasmus Andersson.
 
Last edited:
I have to believe Chicago is looking for size and a C. They are very small and I just wonder if Bedard doesn't end up on the wing. Their center depth hurts, they are still a ways from competing and they need some size in that lineup.
 

Carbonneau and Boumedienne. Martone falls to 8 but that’s highly unlikely in this exercise as stated by Peters.


So, Corey, we’ll start with you this time: What makes you prefer Aitcheson to Mrtka?

**Pronman**: Aitcheson is a nearly 6-foot-2 defenseman who skates well, scored 26 goals in the OHL this season, 39 points the previous season, and offense isn’t his calling card. He’s a super physical and competitive player who provides a unique role. I think he, Mrtka and Jackson Smith project as second pair defensemen on good teams. Mrtka reminds me a lot of Simon Edvinsson and Dmitri Simashev. He’s an excellent all-around player, but the special part of his game is his frame. I would rather bet on the player whose special trait is his compete in Aitcheson.

Bultman: Scott, what elevates Mrtka for you?

**Wheeler**: I would rather bet on the high-end skating right-shot D in a nearly 6-foot-6 profile, and would argue that the special part of his game is the mobility as much as the size. He’s one of the better-skating D in the class for me, and the league is trending toward his profile. Despite Aitcheson’s high goal totals, I also have questions about just how much offense he’s going to have at the next level.

If they’re both top-four five-on-five guys, penalty killers and PP2 quarterbacks, I expect that Mrtka will have a higher impact in those kinds of minutes. I think he’s got a chance to develop into more than that, too. Mrtka is also a June ’07, whereas Aitcheson is a September ’06, and I think Aitcheson’s closer to maxing out in some areas than Mrtka is in terms of development.

**Pronman**: I don’t think Scott and I have seen Mrtka’s skating similarly in our conversations this season. He’s graded him as a premier skater. I think it’s good, but not elite feet — maybe it is for his size, but not overall.

On Prokhorov (I know he was mentioned recently)

I understand why teams covet the player type. I just wouldn’t use a first-rounder on a Toropchenko.

**Pronman**: My point was that I think he could at least be that. He reminds me more of Lawson Crouse than Toropchenko. When he played up age groups, for example, with Russia’s U20 team toward the end of the year, he looked like he had more than sufficient skill for the NHL. How much different is his profile from Charlie Stramel’s (Stramel a center, Toropchenko bigger)?

**Wheeler**: I think there are some similarities there as well. I didn’t have Stramel rated in the first round either, though.
 
I don’t know how legit this individual is but Mark Scheig retweeted him and Im not sure he’d retweet a bunch of randoms he doesn’t know about.



This ranking is the result of numerous discussions I've had over the past two weeks with several NHL scouts, with whom I regularly exchange insights. Additionally, I've been working behind the scenes, using my phone to gauge the market with several of my contacts across the league to find out what's brewing.

So, here's the result of all my work, my picks, and the inside scoop on what could happen at next Friday's draft.



The Inside Scoop on the Draft

Players whose stock is rising one week before the draft:



* Jackson Smith

* Brady Martin

* Kashawn Aitcheson

* Victor Eklund

* Logan Hensler

* Lynden Lakovic

* Braeden Cootes

* Jack Nesbitt



Players whose stock is falling one week before the draft:



* Anton Frondell

* Roger McQueen

* Justin Carbonneau



What I'm Hearing About the Top Prospects:

* Anton Frondell could fall out of the Top 5.

* Kashawn Aitcheson shouldn't go past the 12th pick to the New York Rangers.

* Roger McQueen shouldn't go past the 13th pick to Detroit.

* Jackson Smith could sneak into the Top 10 and even challenge Radim Mrtka as the second defenseman chosen after Matthew Schaefer.



Buzz from the Montreal Canadiens and Other League Teams:



Teams looking to make a "splash" by trading for a high pick (Top 10) if possible:



* NY Islanders

* Chicago

* Utah

* Boston

* Buffalo



Teams actively looking to add a high-caliber player on draft day:



* Montreal

* Utah

* Boston

* Buffalo

* Detroit

* Columbus

* Los Angeles



Regarding the Montreal Canadiens:



* If the Canadiens only draft once, expect to see Carter Bear or Lynden Lakovic.



* If the Canadiens draft twice, Justin Carbonneau will undoubtedly become a Montreal Canadien.



* If the Canadiens can move up 4 to 6 spots, it will be to draft in order of priority:



1 Roger McQueen

2 Radim Mrtka

3 Kashawn Aitcheson



* If the Canadiens move up to positions 4 or 5, it's solely for Caleb Desnoyers.



Regarding Transactions:



Don't rule out the possibility of Trevor Zegras joining a potential Top 6 in Montreal, but it's not the Canadiens' priority. The team continues to explore the market for a true number 2 center.



My Final Top 17 for the 2025 NHL Draft, after compiling all the information received, here is my final ranking:



1 New York Islanders: Matthew Schaefer

2 San Jose: Michael Misa

3 Chicago: Porter Martone

4 Utah: Caleb Desnoyers

5 Nashville: Brady Martin

6 Philadelphia: James Hagens

7 Boston: Jake O'Brien

8 Seattle: Radim Mrtka

9 Buffalo: Anton Frondell

10 Anaheim: Jackson Smith

11 Pittsburgh: Viktor Eklund

12 New York Rangers: Kashawn Aitcheson

13 Detroit: Roger McQueen

14 Columbus: Logan Hensler

15 Vancouver: Carter Bear

16 Montreal: Lynden Lakovic

17 Montreal: Justin Carbonneau



Enjoy draft day, everyone!
 
I don’t know how legit this individual is but Mark Scheig retweeted him and Im not sure he’d retweet a bunch of randoms he doesn’t know about.



This ranking is the result of numerous discussions I've had over the past two weeks with several NHL scouts, with whom I regularly exchange insights. Additionally, I've been working behind the scenes, using my phone to gauge the market with several of my contacts across the league to find out what's brewing.

So, here's the result of all my work, my picks, and the inside scoop on what could happen at next Friday's draft.



The Inside Scoop on the Draft

Players whose stock is rising one week before the draft:



* Jackson Smith

* Brady Martin

* Kashawn Aitcheson

* Victor Eklund

* Logan Hensler

* Lynden Lakovic

* Braeden Cootes

* Jack Nesbitt



Players whose stock is falling one week before the draft:



* Anton Frondell

* Roger McQueen

* Justin Carbonneau



What I'm Hearing About the Top Prospects:

* Anton Frondell could fall out of the Top 5.

* Kashawn Aitcheson shouldn't go past the 12th pick to the New York Rangers.

* Roger McQueen shouldn't go past the 13th pick to Detroit.

* Jackson Smith could sneak into the Top 10 and even challenge Radim Mrtka as the second defenseman chosen after Matthew Schaefer.



Buzz from the Montreal Canadiens and Other League Teams:



Teams looking to make a "splash" by trading for a high pick (Top 10) if possible:



* NY Islanders

* Chicago

* Utah

* Boston

* Buffalo



Teams actively looking to add a high-caliber player on draft day:



* Montreal

* Utah

* Boston

* Buffalo

* Detroit

* Columbus

* Los Angeles



Regarding the Montreal Canadiens:



* If the Canadiens only draft once, expect to see Carter Bear or Lynden Lakovic.



* If the Canadiens draft twice, Justin Carbonneau will undoubtedly become a Montreal Canadien.



* If the Canadiens can move up 4 to 6 spots, it will be to draft in order of priority:



1 Roger McQueen

2 Radim Mrtka

3 Kashawn Aitcheson



* If the Canadiens move up to positions 4 or 5, it's solely for Caleb Desnoyers.



Regarding Transactions:



Don't rule out the possibility of Trevor Zegras joining a potential Top 6 in Montreal, but it's not the Canadiens' priority. The team continues to explore the market for a true number 2 center.



My Final Top 17 for the 2025 NHL Draft, after compiling all the information received, here is my final ranking:



1 New York Islanders: Matthew Schaefer

2 San Jose: Michael Misa

3 Chicago: Porter Martone

4 Utah: Caleb Desnoyers

5 Nashville: Brady Martin

6 Philadelphia: James Hagens

7 Boston: Jake O'Brien

8 Seattle: Radim Mrtka

9 Buffalo: Anton Frondell

10 Anaheim: Jackson Smith

11 Pittsburgh: Viktor Eklund

12 New York Rangers: Kashawn Aitcheson

13 Detroit: Roger McQueen

14 Columbus: Logan Hensler

15 Vancouver: Carter Bear

16 Montreal: Lynden Lakovic

17 Montreal: Justin Carbonneau



Enjoy draft day, everyone!


You can use the quote feature to more easily separate your words from who you're quoting. Your call, I appreciate the posts.
 
  • Love
Reactions: AnonCommentary

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad