GDT: 2025 Draft Lottery: We Got Hosed, Billy

Actually, if you are going to tank do it right. Bring up AHL players, trade off your good to decent players and do it for at least three years in a row. Don’t throw up your hands and stop if you drop one year. Double down.

If you finish with a terrible record (bottom three), your odds of drafting top five are guaranteed. Chicago is doing it that way and has been rewarded with three years of top three picks. How crazy would it be to see them win the cup before Detroit?

If you are going to tank, tank hard and do it right.
Look at the 20-21 Wings, Adam Erne was tied for most goals, they still were only 5th worst. They didn't quit, the guys they picked started to show up and make a impact. The next year Raymond and Seider joined.

They finished dead last in one year, 4th worst, 5th worst twice and 6th worst. Best they got was a 4th overall, five years.
 
Look at the 20-21 Wings, Adam Erne was tied for most goals, they still were only 5th worst. They didn't quit, the guys they picked started to show up and make a impact. The next year Raymond and Seider joined.

They finished dead last in one year, 4th worst, 5th worst twice and 6th worst. Best they got was a 4th overall, five years.

Not sure was it that year, or some other, but they promoted AHL players to make the team worse, and those AHL guys were so motivated for short-term NHL possibility, that they did win many games.

Just says how easy it is to TANK.

You just have to build full crap roster, throughout the lineup, for full season, like Chicago was, to complete 2nd worst season positions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SantosHalper
Actually, if you are going to tank do it right. Bring up AHL players, trade off your good to decent players and do it for at least three years in a row. Don’t throw up your hands and stop if you drop one year. Double down.

If you finish with a terrible record (bottom three), your odds of drafting top five are guaranteed. Chicago is doing it that way and has been rewarded with three years of top three picks. How crazy would it be to see them win the cup before Detroit?

If you are going to tank, tank hard and do it right.
Edmonton did that and that's why they came up with this gimmick draft lottery. Detroit got absolutely f**ked and dropped 5 years in a row, then the dumbass league updated the odds for their dumb gimmick draft and we stopped dropping until this most recent draft where we dropped again so Utah in their second season could move up 10 spots. Who the f**k would willingly sign up for this idiocy?

There are simply too many variables, you have to suck for a long time, have a generational talent pop up and then win that one lottery. Not many fanbases are going to fill arenas for that garbage you put out on the ice until you hopefully get that one talent that shows up every 10 or so years. And if you miss? Oh well, time to suck for another decade or so. That's the NHL in a nutshell I guess. I mean the league is already a total joke, you are going to have a bunch of teams put a s**t product on the ice for the chance to draft McKenna. And those who miss out will just continue sucking in the hope they will eventually get a generational talent. Who the f**k is going to watch that s**t, much less pay for tickets? You know TV ratings for this s**t product continue to nosedive, yeah?

The days of Pittsburgh and Edmonton sucking for so very long they get multiple #1 and #2 picks are pretty much over and you're just as likely to end up being Buffalo where you have a bunch of good young talent but no track record of success.

F**k the NHL, f**k Gary Bettman, f**k the cheap ass owners and f**k their lottery gimmick.
 
I feel better about Augustine than Cossa at this point and I'm glad he's staying in college instead of playing in the AHL next season. I'm sure there are players who benefit from 3 or more years in the AHL which is how Cossa is trending, but I'm definitely not a fan of that development path.
What is the reason you don't like the AHL vs do like College?

I can understand as a possibility to have a greater build of the mental/confidence game vs a possible AHL system where you have plenty of good forwards but a lack of good defense, but I don't think that if you are wanting to get to the NHL quickly, playing against lower quality opponents is g going to stimulate growth. Additionally, in the AHL there is much better goaltending coaching and professional development coaching. Couple that with the modern AHL where most teams have become geographically closer you have more access to the NHL-level staff.
 
What is the reason you don't like the AHL vs do like College?

I can understand as a possibility to have a greater build of the mental/confidence game vs a possible AHL system where you have plenty of good forwards but a lack of good defense, but I don't think that if you are wanting to get to the NHL quickly, playing against lower quality opponents is g going to stimulate growth. Additionally, in the AHL there is much better goaltending coaching and professional development coaching. Couple that with the modern AHL where most teams have become geographically closer you have more access to the NHL-level staff.
College hockey has some programs that go the AHL route and fill their rosters with overagers who are in their mid 20s. They generally are low skill, very defensively responsible, and can outmuscle 19 and 20 year olds. I just find that boring.

Generally speaking, for many college hockey programs, the sport is closer to U21 tournaments where most players are similar in age and physical development, which allows skill to shine more than the AHL which is a men's league for guys in their mid to late 20s who don't have NHL talent.
 
Look at the 20-21 Wings, Adam Erne was tied for most goals, they still were only 5th worst. They didn't quit, the guys they picked started to show up and make a impact. The next year Raymond and Seider joined.

They finished dead last in one year, 4th worst, 5th worst twice and 6th worst. Best they got was a 4th overall, five years.
True. But 5th worst isn’t a lotto pick. Need to be top three. But I agree with you, the Wings were in a rough spot. Raymond and Seider are likely the two best players they will get via draft.
Edmonton did that and that's why they came up with this gimmick draft lottery. Detroit got absolutely f**ked and dropped 5 years in a row, then the dumbass league updated the odds for their dumb gimmick draft and we stopped dropping until this most recent draft where we dropped again so Utah in their second season could move up 10 spots. Who the f**k would willingly sign up for this idiocy?

There are simply too many variables, you have to suck for a long time, have a generational talent pop up and then win that one lottery. Not many fanbases are going to fill arenas for that garbage you put out on the ice until you hopefully get that one talent that shows up every 10 or so years. And if you miss? Oh well, time to suck for another decade or so. That's the NHL in a nutshell I guess. I mean the league is already a total joke, you are going to have a bunch of teams put a s**t product on the ice for the chance to draft McKenna. And those who miss out will just continue sucking in the hope they will eventually get a generational talent. Who the f**k is going to watch that s**t, much less pay for tickets? You know TV ratings for this s**t product continue to nosedive, yeah?

The days of Pittsburgh and Edmonton sucking for so very long they get multiple #1 and #2 picks are pretty much over and you're just as likely to end up being Buffalo where you have a bunch of good young talent but no track record of success.

F**k the NHL, f**k Gary Bettman, f**k the cheap ass owners and f**k their lottery gimmick.
I agree with your frustration. I am not a fan of the lottery. I will say though that fans will come back. And some never leave (Detroit lions fans). So it would depend on the team.

The more upsetting thing to me is, the Wings are going to have a very hard time winning the cup with what they’ve drafted and going up against those teams who’ve gotten ‘lucky’ to get a superstar player.
 
The only team who moved down in 2021 was Anaheim who moved down from 2 to 3, as Seattle jumped up from 3 to 2. Detroit finished 5th last in the league and picked 6th because Seattle came into the league starting with that draft (& expansion draft) & were given the 3rd slot in the Draft Lottery. So the Wings did not move down.
I counted expansion teams as moving down because they did, in fact, move Detroit down. Having multiple expansions during a rebuilding window is just icing on the turd cake that was served to the Wings.
 
That's is not what we are discussing here. Your point was that '19 team was assembled by Holland with intention to compete, and the point is wrong. Everybody understands that Holland needed to go. But '19 team was a product of a (correct) Yzerman decision to tank, not of Hollands' decision to compete. I don't know why it is necessary to villify Holland beyond any reality and attribute only positive things to Yzerman.
Because Holland ran the team into the ground in a way that it took 10 years to comeback from and he also didn't do it in a very competent way at that.
 
If SJ takes Misa #2 I wonder if they would be interested in taking #13 and something else for Will Smith? Like #13, Wallinder and or Mazur/Lombardi?
 
Oh man, what's the overall move up/move down count now? This is getting pretty old.

And the team moving up to #1 this draft is getting their franchise 5th #1 overall pick. That's the gravy on top. And how great for Utah! You love to see it.

I'm so done with this lottery system. Tear it down. Go back to real tanking and let the owners deal with the mess of them competing for the bottom.
 
Holland had told everyone it would take ten years and per Devellano told the Ilitch family the window was closed after the Boston series loss.
It was over before then but I do think Illich holds more of the fault for the dumpster fire by holding course for so long, his prerogative as owner and cutting him some slack for it being like bucket list item. But for us doesn't change the consequence. A team declining so bad that one of the best players in franchise history breaks his contract to get out of dodge I think is about all that needs to be said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Poppa Puck
It was over before then but I do think Illich holds more of the fault for the dumpster fire by holding course for so long, his prerogative as owner and cutting him some slack for it being like bucket list item. But for us doesn't change the consequence. A team declining so bad that one of the best players in franchise history breaks his contract to get out of dodge I think is about all that needs to be said.
They talked to Pavel about going on one year deals, like they had done with most of their 35+ vets. He and his agent insisted on three. Then he complained about it three months later at training camp in year one of the deal.

I will excoriate the continued behavior on Fedorov. He should be brought back into the family and his jersey hung in the rafters. Pavel made his bed along with other things I won’t defend. I get that people were happy he showed up last year for a little bit, I would cut ties if I was the Ilitch family.

I am a known Datsyuk detractor though in terms of the board, I honestly have tried to avoid the topic now for the last few years. But I would never retire him if I was the family. Amazing talent and hockey player to be clear, probably my third favorite Red Wing to watch behind prime Fedorov and young Yzerman. Lidstrom is my favorite player, but the entertainment value on those three guys was through the roof.
 
Last edited:
It was over before then but I do think Illich holds more of the fault for the dumpster fire by holding course for so long, his prerogative as owner and cutting him some slack for it being like bucket list item. But for us doesn't change the consequence. A team declining so bad that one of the best players in franchise history breaks his contract to get out of dodge I think is about all that needs to be said.
Ilitch was totally responsible for our shitty drafting and development. If you want to retool on the fly you can't suck as badly as we did drafting out of North America with our best draft capital. Terrible owner.
 
It was over before then but I do think Illich holds more of the fault for the dumpster fire by holding course for so long, his prerogative as owner and cutting him some slack for it being like bucket list item. But for us doesn't change the consequence. A team declining so bad that one of the best players in franchise history breaks his contract to get out of dodge I think is about all that needs to be said.

I blame Holland for a lot of things, but Datsyuk breaking his contract and leaving the Wings is not one of them.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad