Truthfully I don’t think there should really be a debate. Todays hockey is all about opportunity and the Canadian kids are choosing the NTDP because of the development and exposure it offers, not because they want to play for the USA.
Maybe that’s a hot take but the program has proven to churn out pro player after pro player and if you’re Barch or Thibodeau, under the new NCAA rules, why not take the opportunity to play with some of the best 09s in the world for two years rather than playing 3rd or 4th line minutes on an OHL team.