At the time, I bet a lot of those people hadn't properly followed a hockey team since the dawn of the butterfly era.
Good point.
In 2011, Pavelec had just turned 24. He also tended to have good stats, when it came to the first 30 games of the season. In fact, in the last season of the Thrashers, he led the NHL at point point, and was named player of the week or month in November 2010, if I am not mistaken. When Pavelec was due for a contract extension, my main concern was we had no legitimate replacement, and Pavs would bounce back and become the goalie that he was, when he played lights-out for the first half of the 2010-11 Thrashers season.
For myself, the turning point was that 2 game series against Washington in late March 2013. Pavs was atrocious, and the Jets got blown out in both games. We were within 2 points of the Division lead, and ended up not even qualifying for the playoffs. The next season, I was actually rooting for the Jets to play Montoya, as he was playing far above the level Pavelec was in 2013-14.
Hellebuyck, of course would be turning heads from 2012-15, and had a good rookie year. I was one of his few defenders in 2016-17, when he had his only mediocre season. I knew we had something special in Helle, and he did not let me down. He is arguably the Jets only untouchable asset.