Speculation: 2024-25 Roster Thread

That's the impressive part about Mac is he's playing 3rd line minutes and usually given castaways who didn't pan out playing with Carlsson-Killorn. Z and Mac have looked dangerous together recently, but it also comes at the expense of leaving out Colangelo. The crazy part is that Mac adapts to the players that are put with him. It's a heavy line with Cutter-Mac-Colangelo that cycles and keeps possession in the Ozone. It's a fancy line with Z-Mac-Colangelo, but fancy only between Z and Mac. It's a grinding role with Fabbri-Mac-Leason. How in the hell can he produce offensively often without offensively talent around him?! Mac is succeeding offensively despite the org kicking him to the third line or 2LW. Hell, even his promotion to 2LW helped revive the Carlsson-Killorn line.

Imagine if Leo didn’t have Leason or Lundy on his line for all those games Zegras was out?
 
Maybe Mac really is a third liner. Not in the grinder/shutdown sense but in the auxiliary scorer sense, a guy with offensive skills who's not great defensively and you'd prefer didn't get the tough defensive matchups. That'd make sense with Zegras on his wing, too.

Yeah, but I don't wanna hear that s***. :D

Cronin's comments about Gauthier also seemed on point regarding his awareness.
 
Lundestrom has to go in the offseason. Him and Strome as the 3C and 4C will never work

We need a gritty veteran 4C who wins draws and kills penalties. Lundestrom is not going to be that guy here.

Not sure who’s out there but this is a pretty obvious area where Verbeek to upgrade.

And I know people are going to say “just call up Gaucher”, but I’m personally against that for next season. I want someone who’s proven they can do the job at the NHL level for next year and we can give Gaucher a cup of coffee
 
Lundestrom has to go in the offseason. Him and Strome as the 3C and 4C will never work

We need a gritty veteran 4C who wins draws and kills penalties. Lundestrom is not going to be that guy here.

Not sure who’s out there but this is a pretty obvious area where Verbeek to upgrade.

And I know people are going to say “just call up Gaucher”, but I’m personally against that for next season. I want someone who’s proven they can do the job at the NHL level for next year and we can give Gaucher a cup of coffee
i've been a lundy defender for awhile, but i agree with you. he is what he is, an average 4th line center with no offensive talent at all. that's something we don't need right now. the 4th line most night is just a non-option yet cronin is in love with using it as a shutdown line and it just doesn't work. Pat needs to completely revamp that 4th line if Cronin is so insistent on using it as a shutdown line.
 
Lundestrom has to go in the offseason. Him and Strome as the 3C and 4C will never work

We need a gritty veteran 4C who wins draws and kills penalties. Lundestrom is not going to be that guy here.

Not sure who’s out there but this is a pretty obvious area where Verbeek to upgrade.

And I know people are going to say “just call up Gaucher”, but I’m personally against that for next season. I want someone who’s proven they can do the job at the NHL level for next year and we can give Gaucher a cup of coffee

I agree with Lundestrom. However, I don't think 4C is the focus. Strome should be the 4C and then Gaucher after he recovers from his injury. Terry needs a center. I think they need to get a high-end 3C or low-end 2C to play with Terry.

Gauthier-Carlssson-xxx
Zegras-McTavish-Colangelo
Vatrano-xxx-Terry
Killorn-Strome-Nesterenko
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kalv
I agree with Lundestrom. However, I don't think 4C is the focus. Strome should be the 4C and then Gaucher after he recovers from his injury. Terry needs a center. I think they need to get a high-end 3C or low-end 2C to play with Terry.

Gauthier-Carlssson-xxx
Zegras-McTavish-Colangelo
Vatrano-xxx-Terry
Killorn-Strome-Nesterenko
I think you're more likely to see Z at center than Killorn and Strome on the 4th line.
 
I agree with Lundestrom. However, I don't think 4C is the focus. Strome should be the 4C and then Gaucher after he recovers from his injury. Terry needs a center. I think they need to get a high-end 3C or low-end 2C to play with Terry.

Gauthier-Carlssson-xxx
Zegras-McTavish-Colangelo
Vatrano-xxx-Terry
Killorn-Strome-Nesterenko
Sam Bennett
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kalv
Sam Bennett

I like the player, but he's going to get a huge contract from someone, and I'm not sure it should be the Ducks. Personally, I would offer sheet Mavrik Bourque in Dallas. They only have 5 mil in cap space next season and have to re-sign a number of players including Benn, Granlund, & Duchene. At 4.5 mil, it would be very challenging for Dallas to match and would only cost the Ducks a 2nd round pick next year. If it works, that would be incredible value for a talented player who's only 23.
 
I agree with Lundestrom. However, I don't think 4C is the focus. Strome should be the 4C and then Gaucher after he recovers from his injury. Terry needs a center. I think they need to get a high-end 3C or low-end 2C to play with Terry.

Gauthier-Carlssson-xxx
Zegras-McTavish-Colangelo
Vatrano-xxx-Terry
Killorn-Strome-Nesterenko
As much as that 4th line would be great to have, I don't think either one of Killorn or Strome will be put there unless the wheels just completely fall off. Hopefully, they do go with 3 kids down the middle, though. Try something like:
Cutter-Carlsson-Colangelo (Carlsson has had chemistry with both so far)
Killorn-McTavish-Terry (With Killorn and Terry as the wings, they can even be solid defensively/2 way)
Vatrano-Zegras-Strome (Ideally upgrade Strome)

Killorn and Z have had chemistry too, so you could swap Killorn and Vatrano, but that leaves that 3rd line with a lot less offense. If you can move Strome and add a top 6 forward, you have options at that point.

Then revamp the 4th line. Maybe bring back Lundy or Leason as the 13th forward, but get some faceoff ability and grit. Nesterenko can stay there as some skill.
 
As much as that 4th line would be great to have, I don't think either one of Killorn or Strome will be put there unless the wheels just completely fall off. Hopefully, they do go with 3 kids down the middle, though. Try something like:
Cutter-Carlsson-Colangelo (Carlsson has had chemistry with both so far)
Killorn-McTavish-Terry (With Killorn and Terry as the wings, they can even be solid defensively/2 way)
Vatrano-Zegras-Strome (Ideally upgrade Strome)

Killorn and Z have had chemistry too, so you could swap Killorn and Vatrano, but that leaves that 3rd line with a lot less offense. If you can move Strome and add a top 6 forward, you have options at that point.

Then revamp the 4th line. Maybe bring back Lundy or Leason as the 13th forward, but get some faceoff ability and grit. Nesterenko can stay there as some skill.

I have also wanted Zegras at center, but the clear direction from the team seems to be they want him as a winger. If his chemistry with McTavish continues, it seems difficult for me to see a path as the 3rd line center. Additionally, Terry has not shown strong, consistent chemistry with with Carlsson, McTavish, or Zegras. This is why I think finding another center makes more sense given the current circumstances.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lwvs84
Is is me or, did the Moore signing fly right under the radar? I found out he was in San Diego on a game broadcast. Does anyone know how he's looking?
 
Maybe it's time we start developing chemistry with Terry and one of our younger centers (MacT or Carlsson). I think that would provide us with a more dynamic top like than Strome with Terry.

Cutter, leo, troy? Sound aight to me. I can't remember the last time we had a good look at Terry outside of the Strome and Vatrano line. It's been almost 20 games or so since that line looked decent.
 
Lundestrom has to go in the offseason. Him and Strome as the 3C and 4C will never work

We need a gritty veteran 4C who wins draws and kills penalties. Lundestrom is not going to be that guy here.

Not sure who’s out there but this is a pretty obvious area where Verbeek to upgrade.

And I know people are going to say “just call up Gaucher”, but I’m personally against that for next season. I want someone who’s proven they can do the job at the NHL level for next year and we can give Gaucher a cup of coffee
Assuming Gaucher fully recovers from his injury, I think we're far more likely to see Gaucher become an NHL regular then just getting a cup of coffee next season imo.

I'm not sure how much he'll be getting out of a 3rd full AHL season, given he's basically been playing as the Gulls top shutdown centre for two seasons now and has been pretty great in that role.

I do think he starts in the AHL next season due to his injury just so he can get two training camps in and be fully up to speed, but I'd be shocked if he's not a regular on the Ducks forth line by the end of December.

My ideal solution is we acquire a solid 4c and can ease Gaucher in via the wing, potentially taking draws on the PK (and maybe on his strong side if the 4c we acquire is a LHS) and becomes the full time 4c in 2026. Either way, I think he needs to be playing NHL games regularly next season rather then AHL games, unless he looks completely overrawed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robbieboy3686

Ad

Ad