phillipmike
Registered User
- Oct 27, 2009
- 12,959
- 9,128
Cabrera has consistency, but Vladdy's two best seasons are better than any season Cabrera had by 25. Cabrera's offensive peak was 27-33.
25 is still very young for a baseball player.
And i think consistency is key here, if Vlad had that, the Jays would have had better offers on the table early on. Because he went from ok, overweight player with no position to MVP candidate to very good player to ok and to great again. Hardly a player you want to commit close to half a billion dollars to.
Another key difference is Miggy contributed to a WS in his first 6 years and got MVP votes in every one of those years. In addition, he was 3B/OF in his rookie year followed by 2 seasons as an OF and then 2 full seasons as a 3B before moving back and forth between 3B and 1B before becoming an exclusive 1B in his 30s.
Only thing Vlad has over him is the gold glove.