2024-25 General Dallas Stars Talk

[Bjornar Moxnes]

With the Stars tight cap space, what would you realistically expect for Marchment in the offseason? Like a 2nd and a 3rd?

 

[eartotheground]

With the Stars tight cap space, what would you realistically expect for Marchment in the offseason? Like a 2nd and a 3rd?

only the 2nd but you have to take dumba, too. no taksiebacksies

 

[LT]

I'd be alright moving Marchment + Dumba combined for next to nothing

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

only the 2nd but you have to take dumba, too. no taksiebacksies

Eh, is Dumba an upgrade on Hamonic?

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

I'd be alright moving Marchment + Dumba combined for next to nothing

Honestly, I'd do Marchment and Dumba for like Florida's 3rd, and then pay another team Washington's 3rd to retain half on Dumba. Dumba is probably an upgrade on our bottom pairing RHD, and Marchment gives us another middle 6 winger.

 

[TangoMcBride]

Marchment, at the very least, has enough value to recoup some of the picks that we've recently sent out. I don't know why some of you are just trying to give him away. If Gourde and Bjorkstrand can net the Kraken multiple firsts, a full season of Marchment should easily be worth a 1st. I'd also be fine with a good prospect or two.

 

[LT]

Marchment, at the very least, has enough value to recoup some of the picks that we've recently sent out. I don't know why some of you are just trying to give him away. If Gourde and Bjorkstrand can net the Kraken multiple firsts, a full season of Marchment should easily be worth a 1st. I'd also be fine with a good prospect or two.

I'm only giving him away if it gets Dumba off the team too

But maybe Dumba has a bit of actual value given his veteran status and the scarcity of RHD

 

[Troy McClure]

Eh, is Dumba an upgrade on Hamonic?

Yes. Dumba is amazing. You should petition your team to acquire him.

 

[M88K]

Eh, is Dumba an upgrade on Hamonic?

absolutely. That's a steal, take it and run.

 

[WhoahNow]

I'd imagine Hryckowian, Hyry, Stranges, and Blumel all brought up to be cheap scratches/4th line with Back.

Hryckowian & Hyry are 870k and Stranges & Blumel can't imagine would above 900k.

 

[TangoMcBride]

I'm only giving him away if it gets Dumba off the team too

But maybe Dumba has a bit of actual value given his veteran status and the scarcity of RHD

I think Nill can find a GM to do him a solid. We might have to toss them a prospect and/or a few mid-round picks but I don't think that Marchment would be the cost. There are multiple teams that are hovering around the cap floor that could be willing to absorb Dumba's money.

 

[eojsmada]

I think Nill can find a GM to do him a solid. We might have to toss them a prospect and/or a few mid-round picks but I don't think that Marchment would be the cost. There are multiple teams that are hovering around the cap floor that could be willing to absorb Dumba's money.

Anaheim or SJ could use Marchment for sure. Chicago should look into it as well. And for that matter any team that didn't make the playoffs probably needs a Marchment.

 

[M88K]

Considering what Tampa just paid for Gourde and Bjork,
Marchment probably has a lot of value, even if we stick Dumba with him, we probably could recoup a decent asset out of it

 

[Henderson33]

Matt Dumba for Future Considerations in the offseason.

The consideration is the next time the GM is in town, he gets to look at Jim's 3 GM of the Year awards. No touching though.

 

[MBTendy]

Trading Marchment shouldn't hurt this team too much next season, and acquiring assets will be beneficial. Lord knows we need to start restocking our prospect pool/picks and he should be able to fetch a good return.

 

[ChicagoBlues]

Respectfully, I’ve been analyzing your team since WCF last playoffs. Admittedly, I tried hard to find weaknesses and holes and found some, but Nill continues to find ways to make the team better.

The Dallas Stars have exceeded my expectations, although though those expectations were somewhat misguided.

Much respect!

It’s fun to dive deeply into other teams, but my bias definitely clouded my conclusions/expectations.

Good times!

 

[MrHeiskanen]

The team is soft as butter and the D is weak without Miro. Those are the weaknesses.

 

[ChicagoBlues]

The team is soft as butter and the D is weak without Miro. Those are the weaknesses.

I know. I’ve been following your team. Rest the vets as you approach the playoffs. Especially Duchene.

EDIT: Rest vets and go win the Cup. 11/7 to close out the regular season.

 

[Elysian]

Respectfully, I’ve been analyzing your team since WCF last playoffs. Admittedly, I tried hard to find weaknesses and holes and found some, but Nill continues to find ways to make the team better.

The Dallas Stars have exceeded my expectations, although though those expectations were somewhat misguided.

Much respect!

It’s fun to dive deeply into other teams, but my bias definitely clouded my conclusions/expectations.

Good times!

Nill is trying to threepeat GM of the year. He's a magician.

The team is soft as butter and the D is weak without Miro. Those are the weaknesses.

Don't tell the team that, since that's not how they're playing without Miro

 

[TangoMcBride]

The team is soft as butter and the D is weak without Miro. Those are the weaknesses.

Mathieu Olivier would have been a perfect addition. One of the toughest guys in the league with enough skill to not look out of place playing with skilled players. It's a shame that he re-upped with Columbus.

 

[ChicagoBlues]

Don't tell the team that, since that's not how they're playing without Miro

They’re compensating a little and that’s good.

 

[redbeardtx]

Nill is trying to threepeat GM of the year. He's a magician.

Or is he actually a moron?

We'll never know

 

[redbeardtx]

Mathieu Olivier would have been a perfect addition. One of the toughest guys in the league with enough skill to not look out of place playing with skilled players. It's a shame that he re-upped with Columbus.

Crouse or Greenway (I know he just re-upped but it's Buffalol) might be a decent consolation prize.