You two have been here as long or longer than myself so I really respect the opinions but I do have to ask a few questions....
MacKinnon hasn't looked quite right in awhile either. Still putting up points, because he is who he is. But doesn't look the same.
The team as is, isn't winning anything. They're really looking more and more like 1st round fodder.
I agree. But what's the solution? Trade every player and start the rebuild or get a new coach and voice in the locker-room and see if that can establish a new vision/identity. Or something else? The only real adjustment I've seen Bednar make this year is that the forwards don't leave the dmen pinned in for nearly as long before skating back from the other blueline to help out. The forwards don't seem to be bailing on the dmen as quickly this year. But that doesn't mean they've helped in the breakout. <---- This is about the team in general, not the top five. Bednar treats his top line, Makar and Toews completely differently than he does any other player or line. Feels like if a player doesn't contribute 20+ minutes a night, Bednar really doesn't give a whole lot of shit about them. He'll praise them for their good efforts but blame them when the top unit doesn't produce while owning damn near 50% of the ice time in a game.
As much as the Avs have ALWAYS emphasized speed, transistion, scoring and when possible run and gun play... they are kind of lacking in the defensive metrics. Bednar preaches dedication to defense leading to offense, but this team is doing anything but providing good defense leading to offense. This team is trying to take short cuts at every possible opportunity rather than putting in the work and getting their chances honestly. The problem is all those gambles that don't pay off end up with sustained time in our own zone pretty quickly.
I don't know about that but I do think this whole team is out of sync.
Mack started the year on fire - playing like an MVP but since mid-November has been uneven with his performances.
Makar started the year on fire - playing insanely well but has cooled off of late.
Mittelstadt started the season with 16 points in 15 games only to go into a 2 month slump looking like a shade of his former self.
Toews wasn't great to start the season and finally has looked like himself over the past 3 weeks.
The goaltending was abysmal to start only to become a strength the last month or so.
Throughout all that, we have injury after injury after injury. Just seems like if everyone was back and all trending the same way, we'd be extremely hard to beat. Is that gonna happen, I don't know.
Still, my personal belief that the team as it is made-up is stale and there needs to be an influx of new blood and an outflux of a few guys who don't fit what this team is trying to accomplish.
Here's the thing... through all of the ups and downs over the last many years there have been some constants... MacKinnon, Rantanen, Toews, Makar. There have also been some inconsistent presences: Landeskog, Nuke.
I would pack up Rants' shit, unpack it at the destination and help with the remodel of his new digs if we could trade him in order to get a healthy Landy and/or Nuke back.
Toews...I honestly believe we should be trying to trade his ass. He makes entirely too much money to be an also ran on the top unit. Everytime he's been on the second pair and tasked with anchoring it, it has not ended well. Girard has proven the ability to play up with Makar, but Toews has not shown the ability to play down and be worth 7M.
The Avs got screwed by finding a bunch of complimentary players who together are a beast. It really is like Voltron...except we are paying each individual player as if they were the main character in the story.