Eh, at this point it just feels like a schtick. It's awesome people put themselves out there, even when disagreeable and they put in a good faith effort.
I vehemently disagree with johnjm and Herby about the necessity of the PLD trade. You and Herby disagree with me on various aspects of Byfield. I have gone at it with bland about Kopitar back when we both predominantly posted on LGK. I've given Johnny Utah plenty of shit for his focus on icing enforcers. Heck, it feels like I'm on the same page as RJ and/or Chazz Reinhold 99% of the time, but we still get in snits (usually provoked by me). But you and them always stick up for your convictions, right or wrong. You celebrate times you're right and reevaluate when you're off the mark.
Asking certain posters to take a stance is like asking me to step on the ice and play at the NHL level - you're better off expecting them to be a spectator. You can either spend time asking them to step on the ice, or just accept they'll be a spectator.
And there's really nothing wrong with spectators. Some comment with little conviction and keep it civil, fun and interesting. Some get drunk and throw beer at the players. Those are the ones who "discuss" in bad faith. I'm at that point I'd rather spend time engaging those. Not saying you have to, but maybe you'll enjoy it more.