I think it's a matter of since he's been here, our really good choices have been Stepan, Kreider, and Miller. There are other potential "really good" choices out there, like Chytil, Shesterkin, K'Andre Miller, Lundkvist, etc., but we still don't know how they'll work out. The fact that in his tenure, we haven't drafted and developed an elite-level talent (and no, I'm not talking McDavid or Kucherov or Hedman-level
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ae281/ae2817c7149d2e044d6f2a1aa37b55a7b03ecb12" alt="Roll Eyes :rolleyes: :rolleyes:"
) is somewhat troubling. And you can't just write if off as due to having a dearth of first round picks, as we've whiffed on McIlrath, probably on Andersson, with the jury out on Kravtsov. There are a ton of top players taken outside the top-half of the draft that are elite performers--Pastrnak, Marchand, Carlson, DeBrincat, Guentzel (debatable), Stone, Gaudreau, Kucherov who I can't mention, Boeser, Teravainen, Aho, Point, and on and on. Why haven't we hit a grand slam like any of those guys? It's funny, because the closest we've probably come under Gorton to grabbing a guy that ends up posting elite numbers is JT Miller, who we trade.
Again, this isn't a "hindsight bias" thing with me. It's just
odd that with the league possessing a real wealth of high-end talent, we've really only been able to get any through trades and signings. We haven't been able to snag that guy with our mid/late-first that really explodes, and we haven't grabbed that overlooked guy in the third or fourth that ends up being a star. Some of it is luck, but after 10+ years (and a horrible pick like McIlarth) you start to wonder if the guy has a keen enough eye to spot those players, if his staff sucks, or if it's a combination of both.
The last two drafts could be huge, as there are a lot of guys I really like. And we have some guys out there still that could turn into strong players. But the whole history of Gordie Clark drafts, it seems like we're fine at drafting and developing middle-six guys and second-pair defenders, but we can't really identify the highest of the high-end guys.