After the Foote trade, I was curious, so I looked up every prospect we've traded away under Yzerman/JBB/Al Murray and what the results were. As you might think, they've mostly been positive for us, as in very few have been something you'd regret or have come back and bite us.
2010-2011
8/27/10: Matt Lashoff to Toronto for Alex Berry & Stefano Giliati
10/9/10: Juraj Simek to Boston for Levi Nelson
1/1/11: Ty Wishart to NY Islanders for Dwayne Roloson
2/18/11: Brock Beukeboom & a 3rd rd pick to St. Louis for Eric Brewer
2011-2012
10/2/11: James Wright & Mike Vernace to Florida for Evan Oberg & Mike Kostka
2/19/12: Matt Fornataro to Chicago for Brandon Segal
2/27/12: Carter Ashton to Toronto for Keith Aulie
2012-2013
2/14/13: Dustin Tokarski to Montreal for Cedrick Desjardins
3/11/13: Kyle Wilson to Anaheim for Dan Sexton
4/2/13: Kirill Gotovets to Chicago for Philippe Paradis
4/3/13: Cory Conacher & a 4th rd pick to Ottawa for Ben Bishop
2016-2017
6/25/16: Anthony DeAngelo to Arizona for a 2nd rd pick
3/1/17: Adam Wilcox to Florida for Mike McKenna
5/31/17: Boko Imama to LA for a conditional 7th rd pick
2017-2018
6/21/17: Nikita Gusev, a 4th rd pick & a 2nd rd pick to Vegas for Vegas taking Garrison in the expansion draft
7/1/17: Kristers Gudlevskis to NY Islanders for Carter Verhaeghe
2/26/18: Brett Howden, Libor Hajek, Vlad Namestnikov & a 1st rd & cond. 2nd rd pick to NY Rangers for Ryan McDonagh & J.T. Miller
2018-2019
6/4/18: Connor Ingram to Nashville for a 7th rd pick
2019-2020
11/24/19: Matt Spencer to Buffalo for Devante Stephens
2/16/20: Nolan Foote & a cond. 1st rd pick (Van) to NJ for Blake Coleman
__________
1st rd:
6 (Lashoff, Wishart, Ashton, DeAngelo, Howden, Foote)
2nd rd:
1 (Spencer)
3rd rd:
1 (Beukeboom)
4th rd:
1 (Wright)
5th rd:
2 (Gudlevskis, Tokarski)
6th rd:
3 (Simek, Wilcox, Imama)
7th rd:
3 (Vernace, Gusev, Gotovets)
9th rd:
1 (Wilson)
undrafted:
2 (Conacher, Fornataro)
__________
Dustin Tokarski: Started 22 games over 5 seasons for Montreal, Anaheim, & NY. Started 5 playoff games for Montreal/ 9-9-4 regular season record, 2-3-0 in the playoffs
Anthony DeAngelo: After 1 year with Arizona, traded to NY. Has played a combined 188 NHL games for Arizona & NY / 22 goals, 73 assists = 95pts
Brett Howden: Has played 124 NHL games so far for NY / 13 goals, 24 assists = 37pts
Cory Conacher: Waived by Ottawa, picked up by Buffalo, and then not retained by Buffalo. Signed with NY, then waived by NY and sent to AHL, and then traded to Vancouver but stayed in the AHL. Played a combined 106 NHL games for Buffalo, Ottawa, and NY. / 10 goals, 24 assists = 34pts
Nikita Gusev: Never played for Vegas. Traded to NJ where he's played 56 games so far / 10 goals, 23 assists = 33pts
James Wright: Waived by the Panthers & picked up by Winnipeg. Played 97 NHL games played with Winnipeg / 2 goals, 5 assists = 7pts
Carter Ashton: Played 54 NHL games with Toronto / 0 goals, 3 assists = 3pts
Libor Hajek: Has played 33 NHL games for NY so far / 1 goal, 5 assists, 6pts
Ty Wishart: Played 21 NHL games for NY / 1 goal, 4 assists = 5pts
Unsurprisingly, DeAngelo is having the best career by far. As we know, Yzerman shipping him out had less to do with ability and more so to do with his attitude and maturity. I was thinking of adding young players under the age of 25, who were no longer considered prospects, but still hadn't established themselves because we've traded away our share of them the past decade, but there's not really anything there to look at. Take Adam Erne for example, by the time we traded him, it's fair to say by that point the staff can make a much better assessment on what they're giving away than you could on a prospect with little or no professional experience. So guys like Tyrell, Erne, Gudas, Panik & Barberio (both not traded, but still..), Connolly, Nesterov, Koekkoek, Drouin, Namestnikov - have done for the most part what you would expect.