kilowatt
the vibes are not immaculate
- Jan 1, 2009
- 18,747
- 21,878
If Brown came in to the league today and ran around all of the time--like he used to--without ever fighting, nobody would care because it is a different game. Problem is that he led the league in hits for years and would not drop the gloves when challenged, or at least very rarely. Basically, the other player had to drop his gloves and jump him for Brown to react. Kirk Maltby was one of my most hated players because he would just run around but never drop his gloves. It was worse for Maltby since it was the 90s, not as bad for Brown but still a problem in the 00's and now it doesn't matter.
He used to draw so many penalties. While a lot of them were for falling down easier than he probably should have, a lot of them were also retaliatory type stuff because he would piss the other team off by trying to run everyone into the 5th row. You were supposed to answer for stuff back then and he wouldn't. I'm not trying to argue whether he was smart or not, just saying what was expected back then.
Like I said, not a problem today but he entered the league in a different era when it was not okay. He wasn't just hated by opposing rival fan bases because he hit hard and embellished: he was hated because he would generally never answer the bell. It's funny that we're talking about Avery since he is known as one of the biggest pests of all time when, really, Brown is right up there. It's just that he doesn't talk so maybe you don't want to call him a pest: maybe "troll" is a better description.
That's revisionist history. Brown came into the league when big hits were still commonplace and enforcers were playing 5-10 minutes a game. Big hit? Roll out the fourth line and let the enforcers have a staged fight.
Major penalties aren't a perfect stat for this, but it's the best I have easily available on NHL.com. From 05-06 to 11-12, Brown had 12 major penalties. Clutterbuck had 10. Hell, even Matt Cooke only had 16. Jarko Ruutu had 21, Tuomo Ruutu had 8. Ryan Callahan had 11. Backes had 21. These guys were leading the league in hits, literally hundreds of hits per year, but weren't fighting a ton.