Toggle sidebar

2017 Football Thread III: End of an Eli

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
silverfish said:
Because not caring whether or not someone throws 15 INTs in 5 games and coming into the thread and bashing Eli every Sunday for throwing high or low is, to me, an extremely difficult concept to understand.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure what you don't get since I pretty clearly laid it out. I don't care about stats with evaluating a guy like Webb. In a lost season, they are meaningless. We need to see if he makes the right passes, makes the right reads, and can see where pressure is coming from. Whether his WRs make the catches is meaningless if the passes aren't airmailed or awfully thrown.

We already know what Eli is and we know when his bad plays come. Eli is completely meaningless to this discussion, yet you somehow made it about him for some reason.
 
Hunter Gathers said:
I'm not sure what you don't get since I pretty clearly laid it out. I don't care about stats with evaluating a guy like Webb. In a lost season, they are meaningless. We need to see if he makes the right passes, makes the right reads, and can see where pressure is coming from. Whether his WRs make the catches is meaningless if the passes aren't airmailed or awfully thrown.

We already know what Eli is and we know when his bad plays come. Eli is completely meaningless to this discussion, yet you somehow made it about him for some reason.
Click to expand...
This is a discussion about benching Eli. Of course it's about him.
 
Would guess you guys have to start Geno for a week or two just so Webb can now get real reps in practice. I imagine as 3rd string QB he hasn't taken meaningful practice reps once preseason ended.

Eli should ask for his release, clear waivers, and go start for the Jags. Eli might be done, but Bortles is a disaster.
 
Hunter Gathers said:
Uh, the analysis of the play of Geno and Webb is literally not about Eli Manning.
Click to expand...
I think it's hypocritical to not care if a QB throws 15 INTs in 5 games or less as long as he has this sort of ability to 'read the defense' considering your Manning analysis over the course of the last two or three seasons. And then you brought into the fold tips and dropped balls which explain a solid amount of Eli's INTs. So, I found it hypocritical. If a Manning tipped ball ended up being picked you'd bash Eli for a bad pass. Webb and Geno don't, though?

But like I've said a million times... heavy is the head that wears the crown. Your feelings towards Eli are similar to your feelings towards Hank. And they are valid, but IMO, overblown.
 
McAdoo is a joke. All he’s done his entire time here is throw his players under the bus, Eli the most. I bet McAdoo truly thinks he’s been a great coach in his time here and it’s the players’ fault they suck.

What’s he point in playing Geno we know what he is. Either he sucks and you disrespected a legend and the fans for no reason in a lost season or Geno has a few good games and deludes then into thinking he’s the QB of the future.

Wanna move on from Eli after the season? Fine. Like this it’s just disrespectful.

And how is any of his Eli’s fault. No offensive line, no run game and all the good WR are hurt. Plus he has a coach who thinks he’s gods gift to football and smarter than everyone and overthinking everything. It’s a joke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: belford222 and Melrose Munch
Love Eli, and the 2011 season will always be be one of the greatest NYC sports seasons of all time, but this is the only move that should be made. Eli himself is the one who said he didn't want to start if the plan was to cede time to Webb or Geno, and ceding time is the only strategy that makes actual sense this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Melrose Munch
This was executed with a poor plan in mind and no preparation. Typical McAdoo

Dozens of former players are calling out the organization for handling this so poorly. The best part about this is Eli is handling it with grace and it hopefully puts the nail in Ben & Jerry's coffin. The Mara's & Tisch's can't be happy to see so much negativity being thrown at the organization for this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: belford222
NYGBleedBlueNYR said:
This was executed with a poor plan in mind and no preparation. Typical McAdoo

Dozens of former players are calling out the organization for handling this so poorly. The best part about this is Eli is handling it with grace and it hopefully puts the nail in Ben & Jerry's coffin. The Mara's & Tisch's can't be happy to see so much negativity being thrown at the organization for this.
Click to expand...
Ben & Jerry need to get the Game of Thrones treatment. Heads, spikes, walls.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NYGBleedBlueNYR
Dont mind Eli being traded/benched as long as Reese and McAdoo are gone with him.

Eli can still play but it's time to move on.

Just waive the NTC and dont get hurt.
 
Glen Sathers Cigar said:
McAdoo is a joke. All he’s done his entire time here is throw his players under the bus, Eli the most. I bet McAdoo truly thinks he’s been a great coach in his time here and it’s the players’ fault they suck.

What’s he point in playing Geno we know what he is. Either he sucks and you disrespected a legend and the fans for no reason in a lost season or Geno has a few good games and deludes then into thinking he’s the QB of the future.

Wanna move on from Eli after the season? Fine. Like this it’s just disrespectful.

And how is any of his Eli’s fault. No offensive line, no run game and all the good WR are hurt. Plus he has a coach who thinks he’s gods gift to football and smarter than everyone and overthinking everything. It’s a joke.
Click to expand...

No, no, no, no, no. Sorry. The bold is completely wrong. We HAVE to take a look at what we have. We have to. Period. End of story. The only way we accomplish that is by playing the other QBs that we have.

I see Geno being used to insulate Webb. Webb isn't ready to start yet and certainly isn't ready to start with the insane, irrational hatred coming from some Giants fans. Firstly, thank God the next game is on the road. However, Geno will almost assuredly get booed at home (which is a disgrace). Let Geno bear the brunt of that and let Webb come in to the game. I'd like to see Webb get the lion's share of playing time, but Geno certainly has some uses.

But the idea that we should not give our young guys playing time in a lost season is so ridiculous that I can hardly even address it. It would be the single dumbest thing this franchise could do in a lost season. It would be, dare I say it, TC-esque.
 
17futurecap said:
Would guess you guys have to start Geno for a week or two just so Webb can now get real reps in practice. I imagine as 3rd string QB he hasn't taken meaningful practice reps once preseason ended.

Eli should ask for his release, clear waivers, and go start for the Jags. Eli might be done, but Bortles is a disaster.
Click to expand...

I think Geno serves a few purposes. One, we get to see if he can reclaim his WVU skillset. Two, we get to see him insulate Webb both in terms of meaningful reps and in terms of fan/media criticism.

PFF is meh with OL and QBs, but Bortles and Eli are basically peer players right now in terms of their ratings.
 
Hunter Gathers said:
I want all three gone, so I'm good with that. I'll take a 2nd and a 4th for Eli.
Click to expand...

Yeah I'm done with Eli. Thanks for the memories. Time to move on. Felt the same with Jeter. I'll feel the same with Henrik. To be fair to Eli he's been dealt a crappy hand this season but he's a commodity and its just a matter of time that putrid line exposes him to a horrible injury. Trade him ASAP, get picks, fire the two turds and rebuild the offensive line.

I think the plan is to get Webb some snaps later in the season but it's meaninless because this move will lock up a Top-3 pick and they'll draft a QB.

The OUTRRRRRRAGE!!!!! will be gone in a week or two.
 
And I don't think McAdoo is Ray Handley bad. The season ended when OBJ was hurt in the preseason. The Eagles' record would have made it impossible to win the division anyway. He'll catch on somewhere else but this season is ALL on Jerry Reeese.
 
This is really gross what has happened with the Giants here. They're supposed to be a class organization and this is not that, this is nonsenese you would expect from Oakland or Dallas. I hope McAdoo is fired at the end of the season.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom