2013 Islanders Prospect Poll #12

Status
Not open for further replies.
Trying to get Hickey off this list because he shouldn't be behind these players. He's got a one way contract and has a higher trade value than any further prospect. Overall, he is better than the others on this list. Can we please just vote for him because it would be stupid to have Hickey behind Russo or someone.
 
How is Poulin ranked lower than Nilsson. Poulin proved he can play at the NHL Level and had a far more productive season. Nilsson went AWOL half the year
 
How is Poulin ranked lower than Nilsson. Poulin proved he can play at the NHL Level and had a far more productive season. Nilsson went AWOL half the year

He was dealing with an illness. I like Poulin, but when each are playing at their best, Nilsson is more dominant IMO. Based on upside, I'd take Anders.

As for this poll, I went Pelech. Add Cammarata. Could end up being too small, or he could end up being:

images


..overall, I think his upside is just as high if not higher than any of the guys left after Pelech.
 
Hickey.

After researching Burroughs after DREx's nod, I like what I see. Avg size but plays bigger. Played well against guys 3 or 4 years older and 30(!) min a night. uhh don't blow out our prospect mmmkay?

http://www.langleytimes.com/sports/213204211.html

add him

damn, we have almost enough D prospects to ice two teams in the future. Hope we hold onto the right ones.

gonna have to agree... add burroughs
 
How is Poulin ranked lower than Nilsson. Poulin proved he can play at the NHL Level and had a far more productive season. Nilsson went AWOL half the year

Did he though? JMO, but the jury's still out. He proved that he won't **** his pants the first time a puck came near him but I wouldn't go so far as to call him a proven NHL goalie. He might show that he is this year, but so far, he's shown that when the team had absolutely no other option, he could get dressed and skate to the net and not let a beach ball past him - not convincing, but not also not too discouraging. Post a decent save % and steal a few in 25 games this year, I'll give him a bit more credit.
 
He was dealing with an illness. I like Poulin, but when each are playing at their best, Nilsson is more dominant IMO. Based on upside, I'd take Anders.

As for this poll, I went Pelech. Add Cammarata. Could end up being too small, or he could end up being:

images


..overall, I think his upside is just as high if not higher than any of the guys left after Pelech.

Is that Johnny Gaudreau? I saw him play once and he was awful (even though he scored). And I'm convinced he doesn't wear pads. He's ridiculously small.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad