OT: 2013 HFNYR Boardies — Most Knowledgeable

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why isn't Brian Boyle in the poll? He is one of the most knowledgable posters here, and definitely belongs on that list over several of the names there....
 
I love them all but most of them are not open to anything but their own opinion ...

I think I've gotten better as I've aged;)

We all have strong opinions on here, and it's hard to play nice all the time. I called out a few newbie posters in the last year, had a few heated PM's then decided to talk it out, now we are friends and discuss things like adults.

But you know dagoon I will always hold you to a higher standard as one of the old timers round here. And I always like your take on things, and you definitely love hockey.


My online mentor, wish he was here once a month rather than once a year.

The egos are blowing up! Haha

It was already way too inflated :D

Seriously, I have a tear in my eye from what some have said here, so appreciated. I really feel like 13th most knowledgeable, good number.

Would've voted NYR Sting, but decided Bluenote13 is best option available.

Stinger is the poster most likely to agree with me and vice versa, he's a great pick, mia lately.

He usually comes by around draft day.

Over at least 12 drafts Edge consistently picks out some of the top players for our draft spot. Only seen him whiff a few times over 13 years of reading his stuff. He would've kicked Sather's ass as GM of this club the last 13 years.

BN is one of the few who actually knows of what he speaks, from real experience. I value his opinions tremendously.

I have an extensive hockey background as a younger man, decided to go into entertainment biz instead of hockey which seemed alot harder then (and now) to get into. But my 'knowledge', if thats what ya call it, comes from all the playing, the interest and studying of anything hockey while I was growing up. Before the internet there was Hockey Digest. My letter to the editor was published in the first issue of the 93'94 season, they picked the Icelanders to win the division and I strongly disagreed, saying the Rangers were the tops and would beat Detroit in 7 games in the Cup Finals. My first article for HF was about an expansion ECHL team. You really love hockey when you go out of your way to write about the ECHL

With this list of nominations, I now know who to blindly agree with to sound smart.

Smart move ;)

I'm the only one that voted for Bleed Ranger Blue... wow. I'm honestly very surprised. Most logical poster on HFNYR. Very level headed. Knows his ****.

But there is some tough competition. I wouldn't mind any of these nominations winning.

That's who I voted for this year. I think he's been solid, even though I don't agree with all of what he's said, he's been here to back it up with some good rationale.

SBOB is in my hall of fame, can do no wrong.

When is there going to be a most hated one?

I'd definitely be near the top of that list, if not a landslide winner... mwuahaha. :naughty:

Hated would be too long a list and we'd all vote for 'the other guy' instead of who we really hate, why give them the attention they crave :p:
 
I think I've gotten better as I've aged;)

We all have strong opinions on here, and it's hard to play nice all the time. I called out a few newbie posters in the last year, had a few heated PM's then decided to talk it out, now we are friends and discuss things like adults.

But you know dagoon I will always hold you to a higher standard as one of the old timers round here. And I always like your take on things, and you definitely love hockey.



My online mentor, wish he was here once a month rather than once a year.



It was already way too inflated :D

Seriously, I have a tear in my eye from what some have said here, so appreciated. I really feel like 13th most knowledgeable, good number.



Stinger is the poster most likely to agree with me and vice versa, he's a great pick, mia lately.



Over at least 12 drafts Edge consistently picks out some of the top players for our draft spot. Only seen him whiff a few times over 13 years of reading his stuff. He would've kicked Sather's ass as GM of this club the last 13 years.



I have an extensive hockey background as a younger man, decided to go into entertainment biz instead of hockey which seemed alot harder then (and now) to get into. But my 'knowledge', if thats what ya call it, comes from all the playing, the interest and studying of anything hockey while I was growing up. Before the internet there was Hockey Digest. My letter to the editor was published in the first issue of the 93'94 season, they picked the Icelanders to win the division and I strongly disagreed, saying the Rangers were the tops and would beat Detroit in 7 games in the Cup Finals. My first article for HF was about an expansion ECHL team. You really love hockey when you go out of your way to write about the ECHL



Smart move ;)



That's who I voted for this year. I think he's been solid, even though I don't agree with all of what he's said, he's been here to back it up with some good rationale.

SBOB is in my hall of fame, can do no wrong.



Hated would be too long a list and we'd all vote for 'the other guy' instead of who we really hate, why give them the attention they crave :p:

You do post the best draft preview of anybody either professional or random poster.

SBOB is a first ballot Hall of Famer....A lot of posters could go into the "virtual" Hall of Fame on this board.
 
Why isn't Brian Boyle in the poll? He is one of the most knowledgable posters here, and definitely belongs on that list over several of the names there....

We had a nominations thread. BB himself tabulated the nomination totals and then ran this poll.
 
Why isn't Brian Boyle in the poll? He is one of the most knowledgable posters here, and definitely belongs on that list over several of the names there....

There are different dimensions of knowledge when it comes to hockey.
 
You do post the best draft preview of anybody either professional or random poster.

SBOB is a first ballot Hall of Famer....A lot of posters could go into the "virtual" Hall of Fame on this board.

Thanks, I do my HW when it comes to the draft. Pre internet there was really no way to see all the players in the draft back then unless you lived in Canada. Materials were hard to find too, that's why the Hockey News Draft preview was like a bible back then. Nowadays, I can at least see video from the most obscure prospects if I can't see them live.

One day someone will make a comprehensive list of the all time greats around here.

SOS, you are a really good poster, seen you get better over the years, definitely a candidate for most improved.
 
All nominees good.
Serious honorable mention to Jonathan, Bluenote 13.

I had to go with Rangerboy.
He comes up with stuff on everything, everybody.

Like the FBI/CIA etc all work directly for him.
Like a recent post. Brierre could be interested in NYR/NJD cause of family.

Ok, that was kinda known if you were paying attention,

Then there was something like, the wife divorced + got the kids.
So this is the kind of embellishment that tells you,
NO, REALLY,
it HAS TO BE CLOSE to home.

But were does he get this stuff from?
Amazing.

Most insightful, one of them for sure. More competition there.

But most knowledgeable, yeah, AIAEC.
 
When is there going to be a most hated one?

I'd definitely be near the top of that list, if not a landslide winner... mwuahaha. :naughty:

Please CM, don't be a rank amateur about this.:):D:laugh:

Whether or not I earned it or not,
too many people will ignore that I was right about
trading Girardi + early (now also vets for cap)
Kreider from early on [now that Torts is buh bye, I can't want to see him take off]
Richards had to go regardless of performance due to cap recovery
Miller good enough to play here last year [not that he didn't need more seasoning, but could physically play here]
that Torts should go...

but enough about me...:laugh::D:naughty:

You're too much of a nice guy for this.
We all know haters gonna hate, regardless.
You should just let me carry that albatross on my back, until my track record is far enough that they'll have to let go. :nod:

Of course, my Achilles heel will always remain Tysen Dowzak:cry::amazed:
 
Bern, you're one of my favorite posters because you don't take yourself too seriously, and you're a good sport.

:yo:
 
I love them all but most of them are not open to anything but their own opinion ...
Yeah, I would agree with this.

quote.jpg


That being said, this is a group of deserving candidates whose contributions to this boards are immense.
 
You do post the best draft preview of anybody either professional or random poster.

SBOB is a first ballot Hall of Famer....A lot of posters could go into the "virtual" Hall of Fame on this board.

Is there a wing for that?

Edge
Melrose
Singin
Fletch
BRF
Brooklyn
Anerin
Dedalus
JR
Jas
Jon
Eco

Leaving out a few......
 
Is there a wing for that?

Edge
Melrose
Singin
Fletch
BRF
Brooklyn
Anerin
Dedalus
JR
Jas
Jon
Eco

Leaving out a few......

Great names, all of them.

Laches ! Whatever happened to you man??

Fletch is missed on a daily basis. If I had the means I'd pay him to write on HF after every game, he always seemed to have a good idea on what was going on, plus he knew a good deal of Ranger history/personnel. Perennial winner of the 'Fans fan' award.

SOTI ? Park #2 ? smashley ?
 
Great names, all of them.

Laches ! Whatever happened to you man??

Fletch is missed on a daily basis. If I had the means I'd pay him to write on HF after every game, he always seemed to have a good idea on what was going on, plus he knew a good deal of Ranger history/personnel. Perennial winner of the 'Fans fan' award.

SOTI ? Park #2 ? smashley ?

As a longtime lurker here, even before I finally created an account, these names are all blasts from the past.
I remember SOTI, must have had some very well placed sources in the organization. Always had legit info on trade rumors, etc. Made trade deadlines very entertaining.
 
Oye. Going to abstain from this one. Could make a case for everyone listed.

Someone has to say it - You should be up there too ! :nod:

As a longtime lurker here, even before I finally created an account, these names are all blasts from the past.
I remember SOTI, must have had some very well placed sources in the organization. Always had legit info on trade rumors, etc. Made trade deadlines very entertaining.

Yeah, guys like SOTI made it 'the' place to be around the deadline. Good times.
 
Please CM, don't be a rank amateur about this.:):D:laugh:

Whether or not I earned it or not,
too many people will ignore that I was right about
trading Girardi + early (now also vets for cap)
Kreider from early on [now that Torts is buh bye, I can't want to see him take off]
Richards had to go regardless of performance due to cap recovery
Miller good enough to play here last year [not that he didn't need more seasoning, but could physically play here]
that Torts should go...

but enough about me...:laugh::D:naughty:

You're too much of a nice guy for this.
We all know haters gonna hate, regardless.
You should just let me carry that albatross on my back, until my track record is far enough that they'll have to let go. :nod:

Of course, my Achilles heel will always remain Tysen Dowzak:cry::amazed:

And Postma?

I find your posts hilariously entertaining.
Neither you or CM should be on the hated list.
Come to think of it, i can't think of any name that should be on that list, but i am relatively new :sarcasm:
 
I haven't gotten to see many guys actually present their knowledge because I'm too knew(...wait too kn....oh jesus christ I need to start sleeping more wtf) but I've consistently seen BRB and RB around here. I had a huge tiff with john over my presentation of my opinion of BR but I've seen him in many other threads clearly knowing more than most could even read. Singn seems like he's too disenfranchised w/ the team/HF to post much but you can tell he knows a lot while saying very little which counts for a lot.

BN has Hank for his avatar ( b/c really it doesn't get any smarter than that)
 
Last edited:
RangerBoy, Bluenote13, Blueshirt Believer (always enjoy his take, keeps it short and sweet, and points out deficiencies in our system that anyone can understand, always look for his posts in the GDT's.

We are lucky to have these guys with us here on HFNYR, you guys are the reason I still come on, even after the season is over. You're all savages!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad