Avs draft forwards at an alarming success rate, not so much defenders. The Preds being high on Jones does not mean he is better than MacK it just confirms he is very good. I would like Jones, but I'll support whomever Pracey believes in the most, which is MacK.
I think the Avs have been better at drafting defensemen of late.
2012 Draft
No defensemen taken
2011 Draft
#11 - Siemens - Looks to have a NHL future as a shutdown middle pairing defensemen
#153 - Beaupre - I'm higher on him than most, but I can see him being a solid 5/6 defensemen in a couple years.
#183 - Donnelly - didn't sign, not unexpected for a 7th round pick.
2010 Draft
#95 - Silas - a bust here
#137 - Rutkowski - didn't sign, and probably won't amount to much. Still was deemed good enough to earn a contract from Ottawa.
2009 Draft
#49 - Elliott - close to being a regular NHL player. Still has significant upside.
#64 - Barrie - I would call him a regular NHL player now. Showed last season he can handle a top 4 role, and maybe more.
#184 - Young - meh prospect, but still a prospect. He could be a possible bottom pairing shutdown player. I doubt he gets a contract next year.
That looks to me like 3 solid hits out of 8 picks (Barrie, Siemens, Elliott). Beaupre might bring that to 4 if he can continue to develop. 38% success rate while only drafting 1 in the 1st round would actually be a really good. Hell, 25% is pretty damn good.