Exec 1: Toronto in 6. The narratives are what they are, but this is a very good Leafs team with some dirt under its nails now. Ottawa is not going to be a pushover, but as a relatively young group making their first playoff appearance in a while, I think Toronto gets the job done.
Exec 2: Pick Toronto but should be a doozy. Ottawa will be ready to compete, and Brady (Tkachuk) will drag them into the fight. I might actually give the edge to Ottawa on D and possibly in goal as well, but Toronto is just too loaded up front and have a huge experience edge being in many of these tough first-round series.
Exec 3: This brings back some great memories from a couple of decades ago. I think this series is going to be one of the best to watch in the first round. Ottawa has had Toronto’s number this year and I believe they will give the Leafs issues in the first round. Brady Tkachuk is built for the playoffs, so I’m excited to see him engage in this series and give the Leafs players fits. While I love the youth and enthusiasm from Ottawa, I think that this is the best team Toronto has had since those previous battles between these teams many years ago. Toronto is deeper on D and better in goal than they have been, which should pay dividends in this series. Toronto advances in a spirited series.
Exec 4: The Battle of Ontario could just as easily be called “David versus Goliath.” The star-studded Leafs are an offensive juggernaut and have the best D corps they’ve had in years. However, they are contending with massive expectations and immense pressure … particularly “the Core Four.” After not making the playoffs for the previous seven seasons, the Sens, on the other hand, are playing with house money. They will give the Leafs a handful. After much nailbiting, the Leafs will prevail. Leafs win 4-3.
Exec 5: Although this is an exciting series for Canada, I think Toronto is the superior team in most aspects. Toronto is probably thrilled to play someone other than Boston, Florida or Tampa. I have Toronto in five because they are just better offensively due to their superstars up front and will outscore their issues in this series.
Exec 6: Toronto. Deeper offense and better D.
Exec 7: Could go 7. … Think the Leafs sneak it out.
Coach 1: I like Toronto over Ottawa. I like Ottawa and their chances, but it’s more about Toronto. I like the way they have played all year. Not giving up easy offense, and their team game. I also love the balance and depth of the forwards and defense, especially if they get everyone back. (Jake) McCabe, (Oliver Ekman-Larsson) and (David) Kämpf are important for that depth. (Linus) Ullmark, however, could steal that series.
Coach 2: Two teams at different life stages. Toronto’s core has been together for years and has had multiple kicks at the can. Ottawa (is) just entering their playoff window after years of missing the playoffs. Toronto in 6.
Coach 3: Excited to see Ottawa make their first playoff appearance with this team. We played them a few weeks ago and were very impressed with their D core. They all defend hard, and (Jake) Sanderson is turning into a Norris trophy-caliber defenseman. He can do it all. Toronto doesn’t get enough credit for how hard they defend, as most people focus on the skill of their top guys, which they should but they also play hard. That being said, I like Ottawa in this series. Tkachuk will drag them all to another level.
Coach 4: I think Toronto is ready to make a long run and will win in 6 games. Experience will pay off for them this year, playing solid hockey all year long, more competitive. Ottawa’s a very good young team. Toronto’s just too deep.
Coach 5: Both teams have been good at home. Toronto has been equally comfortable on the road. Their added depth and experience on the back end is a factor in handling matchups on the road. Toronto’s goaltending will remain solid, Ottawa’s will need to be the “difference” in the series. Toronto in 6.
Coach 6: Toronto beats Ottawa. Too much firepower in Toronto and (Leafs GM Brad Treliving) made the D better.
Final tally: Maple Leafs 12-1.