i do agree Anderson is more talented but they are producing similarly and Hyman is a more complete player. Anderson is more of a pure power forward. When Hyman is a 2-way guyAnderson is bigger, much faster, more talented. Hyman works hard but he's more like Nick Foligno or Brooks Laich and sometimes shuts down his own line by being unable to keep the play alive. If Anderson didn't have the injury concerns he does it would be a complete no brainer.
i do agree Anderson is more talented but they are producing similarly and Hyman is a more complete player. Anderson is more of a pure power forward. When Hyman is a 2-way guy
Obviously it's Anderson. If you're a Leaf fan or anti Hab fan you most likely vote for Hyman but in reality, given the opportunity, you would take Anderson anyway.
Power forwards are at a premium. Two way players that can get you 30-40 points, a dime a dozen.
4 times? Hyman has been a 40+ point guy twice in the last 4 years on a stacked team playing with the likes of Matthews, Marner, JT and Nylander.
Anderson is younger, bigger, stronger, faster and more talented. It's really a no brainer.
Nope I wouldn’t. He’s the one player you can count on to bring 110% effort every time he steps on the ice. He is the heartbeat of the Leafs team.We'll just have to agree to disagree.
If you present both players to any gm in the league, I really can't see many of them, if any, choosing Hyman over Anderson. I've read multiple times in Leaf threads that Anderson would sure look good in a Leaf uniform. I don't think I've ever seen a Hab thread where anyone said that about Hyman.
Ask yourself honestly, as a Leaf supporter, would you trade Hyman for Anderson? I think you'd do it in a heartbeat. However, you'd be hard pressed to find a Hab fan that would trade Anderson for Hyman.
Anyhow, let the poll results play out and we'll see what the majority of fans think. I believe if you remove biased voters from the poll, on both sides, the results be much more one sided than they already are.