Proposal: WPG/Detroit and ANA/Detroit
- Thread starter Reddwit
- Start date
Wouldn’t add a first for Fowler with Nyquist/Tatar, especially because it might be quite a high first. I’d probably do the Trouba deal but no chance the Wings trade hometown boy Dekeyser.
OP has Detroit overpaying on all of them. I'd do Nyquist for Fowler straight up, though.
That's kind of the point. Represent the max offer for both players. In reality, Winnipeg probably throws in a middle pick and Detroit probably doesn't move the 1st, but its feasible in both respects and wouldn't ruin the Wings.
Both trades are very bad for Detroit combined and rob them of their offensive creativity. It's plugging one hole and creating another, larger, scarier hole.
Why? Trouba and Dekeyser are pretty similar defenseman at this point. Both play heavily on the PK and some on the PP (Trouba more so than Dekeyser on the PP). The difference is Dekeyser only has a little room to grow whereas Trouba has more upside. You take the risk of losing Tatar/Nyquist for nothing (in the event that Trouba doesn't grow at all) for the potential that Trouba ultimately becomes better than Dekeyser, which Detroit very much needs but Winnipeg not so much.
Also, Trouba (and Fowler) are both Michigan boys, so Holland can still keep the homeboy calling card.
I think Nyquist is overpaid for what he provides...not even sure if he (or Tatar for that matter) would be effective in the Ducks system.
What holes? These trades are contingent on the Wings using their capspace to buy both Okposo and Nielsen. Detroit supplants Tatar and Nyquist with Okposo and Nielsen, the downside being that their contracts will suck, the upside being that it allows the Wings to address their defense with the better valued players in Nyquist and Tatar without missing much of a beat up front.
hot dog
Registered User
- Mar 20, 2013
- 1,669
- 12
Done.
Wings can't move DD as they have legitimately nothing else in the pipeline aside from maybe Russo and any of the boom/busts from this draft.
hot dog
Registered User
- Mar 20, 2013
- 1,669
- 12
Number1RedWingsFan52
Registered User
Not giving up the 1st now for Fowler, Tatar+Pulkkinen should be fair value for Fowler right now.
Did you even read the OP? This has Detroit adding Fowler and Trouba. How do they need DD if they do that?
Nielsen doesn't need to do anything but take a good deal. Adding Nielsen gives Detroit the flexibility down the middle with Zetterberg, Nielsen, Larkin, and Sheahan where they can move bodies to the wing if they're too overwhelmed to stay at C (Zetterberg) or not ready to play C on the 1st line (Larkin)
Gabe Kupari
Registered User
irunthepeg
Board man gets paid
OP also understands if he's trying to acquire Trouba, it's going to cost more than if Trouba was on the block. Nice proposal, I'd probably do it.
or we can just do this.
or we can just do this.
Evil Little
Registered User
- Jan 22, 2014
- 6,311
- 2,739
Don't don't need wingers. Young, old, rich, poor--wingers won't convince the Jets to downgrade from Trouba.
Value ain't bad (though I wonder why Nyquist and Tatar keep coming up 'round these parts...).
Value ain't bad (though I wonder why Nyquist and Tatar keep coming up 'round these parts...).
Because Detroit has everyone and their brother playing wing in the system and desperately need top defenseman and good centers. Unlike a lot of fanbases, Detroit understands that acquiring good, young defenseman costs you good, young players. Hence the posts. Nyquist and Tatar are our best trade chips and we can afford to move them because we have winger depth.
Gabe Kupari
Registered User
Problem is. Jets also have tons of winger depth. So really there is no deal to be made here.
Think about this, Let's pretend the Boston offer sheet is legit, 4 first round picks... going the Jets way if the Jets don't match.
You think Dekeyser and Jurco/Tatar (wingers the Jets don't need) is similar to 4 first round picks? Nope.
When did I ever even insinuate that? Boston has to actually make that (moronic) offer in the first place.
As for the Jets winger depth, they certainly have it, but I'm only seeing two guys that are better than Tatar/Nyquist on the roster in Wheeler and soon-to-be Ehlers.
