Felidae
Registered User
- Sep 30, 2016
- 11,710
- 14,656
The Blackhawks star center before Toews, thought it would make for an interesting comparison. I think it's fair to say Toews had the much longer prime and easily the better career. But who was better at their peak? Comparing their best season(s)
Roenick
1991-92
5th in Hart voting
3rd in goals
7th in points
9th in selke voting
Toews
2012-13
4th in Hart voting
5th in goals
11th in points
Selke winner
And since some people prefer peaks to not be defined based off one season, it's worth noting both players performed at a similar level in at least one other year
Toews the year before was scoring goals at an identical rate (0.49, 7th in GPG) in more games, his award recognition was low since he missed nearly 30 games.
And Roenick was actually more productive in 1993 (5th in points) but scored less goals (10th in goals)
Roenick
1991-92
5th in Hart voting
3rd in goals
7th in points
9th in selke voting
Toews
2012-13
4th in Hart voting
5th in goals
11th in points
Selke winner
And since some people prefer peaks to not be defined based off one season, it's worth noting both players performed at a similar level in at least one other year
Toews the year before was scoring goals at an identical rate (0.49, 7th in GPG) in more games, his award recognition was low since he missed nearly 30 games.
And Roenick was actually more productive in 1993 (5th in points) but scored less goals (10th in goals)
Last edited: