To me Walton was a player who had all the makings of a star (talent wise). He was not an easy player to defend against. He was a bit unpredictable and irrational, so the defensemen had a hard time figuring him out. Walton had a pretty heavy shot with a quick release, overwhelming a lot of goaltenders. On top of that he had some wheels and world class first step acceleration.
His dad (the original Shakey Walton) was a fine hockey player in his own right and played briefly in the NHL for Montreal (early 40s), so Mike Walton definitely had that talent in his DNA.
He never lived up to his potential mainly because of his personality. From what I understand he was a well-liked teammate, a lot of fun to be around, but his work ethic, mental health (to some degree) and commitment to the game was just not enough.
Back in those days, you didn’t just mouth off against the GM or the coach, if you did, you got yourself into trouble, big time. Today the spoiled superstar players can get a coach fired overnight. The players today have much more leverage than they had in the 60s and 70s when Walton played.
Walton was somewhat of a rebel with an outgoing personality, liked to talk and had a bit of a laissez-faire attitude. He did things his way, for example using white medical tape for his sticks instead of the traditional black tape. There was a strict rule under Imlach, no long hair, so Walton walked around the dressing room with a ”Beatles wig” just to annoy Imlach.
Just the fact that he could hang around for six seasons with the Maple Leafs was a miracle in itself given some of his ”antics” in the eyes of Imlach. I would think Imlach was unaware of the fact that Walton battled depression and anxiety for long stretches, but I might be wrong.
When Walton was finally traded in 1971, Toronto was a bit in a turmoil. Bassett, Smythe and Ballard had their own little ”war” and Imlach was gone (replaced by Jim Gregory).
While being the GM, Imlach of course recognized that Walton was superbly talented and I also think that Walton being married to the granddaughter of Conn Smythe and niece of Stafford Smythe also had something to do with him not being traded sooner.
Later on Walton had his moments, some that comes to mind:
· Crashing through a plate glass at a hotel during a road game, almost losing his life in the process. He got away with 200+ stitches and a complete blood transfusion.
· Jumping off a diving board into a swimming pool, wearing his full hockey equipment, nearly drowning.
· Being so disgusted with a loss that he just walked out of the arena after the game, got into his car and drove right to the nearest bar, still in his hockey gear pouring down shots at the bar. That must have been a sight to behold.
· Doing TV-interviews while wearing only shaving cream to cover his private parts
· He was deathly afraid of insects, had a real phobia, which of course his teammates used against him whenever they could, resulting in a lot of funny moments
Walton had great skills. He went his own way, was a bit enigmatic, aloof, maybe even lazy to some extent. His non-conformist behavior did not sit well with NHL-management of the 60s and 70s. Still, I think he did quite well, close to 800 NHL/WHA points in almost 870 games is not bad at all.