I absolutely hear you but It’s not quite as straightforward as you make it IMO. Do the Avs have the ability to win? No doubt. The team is stacked. And you are right. It is on the players to execute. But I put a lot on Bednar because it’s the HC’s job to have the team ready, certainly by the start of the POs and especially with so many starters being scratched in April waiting for the end of the RS, and with a relatively healthy roster. Another way of putting it is, are the players still listening to the HC’s message. Yesterday, the answer was yes.
I just question JB’s adaptability/stubborness. This is reflected in his lineups. I can forgive JB’s playing EJ in the first two games because he wanted experience and size. Love EJ but his minutes should be limited and that was before he put in Big Sammy. The other major issue is his use of Necas. We saw 62-11-88 shortly after Necas was acquired and it worked. But JB insists on playing Necas next to Mack which is redundant given their speed and playmaking ability. So now some are saying Necas sucks but to me the issue is whether JB is using him correctly and placing him and other players in a position to succeed? Mind you, this was my concern when Nelson was struggling with his linemates. JB ‘s responsibility was to do everything to get Nelson going. That raised two concerns for me with JB.
First, why is JB insisting on playing Necas next to Mack when in four games it really hasn’t produced the way we hoped? Necas isn’t Rants and shouldn’t be played with the expectation that he should be. In this regard, JB’s pronouncement that this is a production oriented biz makes his stubbornness a head scratching WTH moment? The second issue was a much bigger concern.
The Avs have to be able to roll four effective lines if they want to advance in the POs much less win the SC. IMO, that’s inarguable. JB could get away with overloading the top line in the RS but that’s not how it works in the POs. Keeping Necas on the first line was hobbling the second line until we got lucky that Landeskog has made an incredible comeback so far and has been a valuable contributor. So, I feel like JB has been fortunate that Landeskog could play such a key role on ice.
IIRC, after the game three loss I specifically suggested JB drop Drouin to the third line if not scratch him if Colton was available and put Landeskog at 2LW. Look what happened when he did that. I also proposed switching Nuke and Necas but I was certain JB’s stubborness would put the kibbosh on this suggestion.
Unlike the RS, JB has got limited opportunities to get it right. If the team as a whole isn’t ready right from the get go in the POs then when as fans should we expect them to be? The fact that JB had the players playing DeBoer’s game and succumbing to his strategy and tactics in the initial three games was infuriating. You saw last night what this stacked team is truly capable of.
So I tip my hat to the coaching staff for getting the players to return to playing Avs hockey and adjusting tactics. They did a very good job in that regard. But I’m still not completely sold on JB. He needs to get the Avs to the WCF to be assured his job is safe IMO.
You’re also right about puck luck and the Stars being equally as talented as the Avs (IMO they’re unbalanced but that’s irrelevant here). With Heiskanen and JRob out, this shouldn’t have been close. Mind you, in game 3 the Avs had over three minutes of PP in the OT and could hardly even set up in the O-zone for the first couple of minutes. Like WTH was the coaching staff doing during the intermission? Overall I like JB’s ability to maintain an even keel. But there are times when one needs to be able to light a firecracker under their team.
FTR, I was a big JB backer up through the 2022 SC and even into this RS. I prefer JB’s up tempo, transition, offense first philosophy and I’m definitely not enthused at the prospect of replacing him. But overplaying and over relying on the top line made me question JB’s suitability and decisions.
The one thing about head coaching, no matter the sport, is the knowledge you’ll eventually be terminated from your job.