Book Feature Victory on Ice: The Chicago Blackhawks’ First Stanley Cups (by Paul Greenland)

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
Overview

Epic battles, fatal sacrifices, and highly improbable circumstances brought the Stanley Cup to Chicago twice during the 1930s. Long overlooked, the city’s 1934 and 1938 championships evoked a sense of triumph and jubilation during the darkness and gloom of the Great Depression. By combining tales of old-time hockey with rare photos and broader elements of history, Victory on Ice recreates a near-century-old landscape, teleporting readers to a bygone era when the Blackhawks’ earliest heroes played a brutal game against bitter rivals. Many players and their families lived simple, interconnected lives in small apartments and hotels. Teammates forged a unique camaraderie during long train rides between NHL cities. Salaries were modest, and players without cars took the bus to practices and games at the cavernous and electrifying Chicago Stadium. Underworld figures, intent on fixing games, occasionally threatened players. Experience all the action and excitement in this detailed account of two unforgettable seasons, concluding with one of the greatest Cinderella stories in professional sports.

Victory on Ice was written with strong cooperation from the families of many former players and members of the Society for International Hockey Research. The book includes a foreword by retired Northwestern University Professor Emeritus Virgil C. Johnson, whose father was a defenseman on the 1938 Stanley Cup team. Chicago artist Holly Tempka created an illustrated cover in the Art Deco style of the 1930s.

Publisher: North Hill Books
Released: November 2022
ISBN: 978-0-9659128-1-5
Soft Cover
Price: USD $21.95
Pages: 262
Photos: 126

Where to Order:

Amazon:
Victory on Ice: The Chicago Blackhawks' First Stanley Cups: Greenland, Paul R.: 9780965912815: Amazon.com: Books

Barnes & Noble:
Victory on Ice: The Chicago Blackhawks' First Stanley Cups|Paperback

Bookshop.org:
https://bookshop.org/p/books/victor...s-paul-r-greenland/19028949?ean=9780965912815

victory_on_ice_cover_final.jpg


About the Author

Paul Greenland (Paul Greenland – Nonfiction Author) is the author of Hockey Chicago Style—The History of the Chicago Blackhawks (Sagamore Publishing, 1995), an authorized account and one of five comprehensive histories of the team published since 1970. His essay on the Blackhawks appears in The Encyclopedia of Chicago (University of Chicago Press, 2004), a project of the Newberry Library in cooperation with the Chicago Historical Society. Greenland is a member of the Society for International Hockey Research and the Chicago Writers Association. He regularly contributes business and career content to reference books from leading publishers. In 2021, Greenland jointly authored The Vault Guide to Case Interviews, Ninth Edition (Vault.com Inc.), which Forbes calls “CliffsNotes for Careers.”

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments
Foreword
Introduction
Author’s Notes

SECTION I: HOCKEY, CHICAGO, AND THE GREAT DEPRESSION

Chapter 1: Hard Knock Hockey
Chapter 2: Working Class Heroes

SECTION II: 1933–34 STANLEY CUP

Section Introduction
Chapter 3: The Great Contenders (1933–34 player bios)
Chapter 4: Chasing Silver (1933–34 regular season)
Chapter 5: That Toddlin’ Title Town (1934 Stanley Cup playoffs)

SECTION III: 1937–38 STANLEY CUP

Section Introduction
Chapter 6: The Miracle Makers (1937–38 player bios)
Chapter 7: An Umpire Shall Lead Them (1937–38 regular season)
Chapter 8: Cinderella Story (1938 Stanley Cup playoffs)

Bibliography

Introduction (excerpt)

The inspiration for this book dates back to January 27, 1992, when I placed a long-distance call to Sun City, Arizona. After a few rings, I heard a voice that had been echoing through Chicago Blackhawks history since 1928, when Harold “Mush” March became one of the team’s earliest players. When his puck-shooting days were over in 1945, after 759 games, Mush stayed on the ice for another nine years as an NHL linesman. At 83, he was still golfing three to four times per week. I was barely 20, had never interviewed anyone, or written anything for publication. Mush probably did not realize that I was just a kid, and that in the world of writers and authors, I was as unknown and green as they came.

Back then, Ed Belfour, Chris Chelios, Jeremy Roenick, and Steve Larmer were my heroes. Pat Foley and Dale Tallon called games from the Madhouse on Madison. The previous summer, I had started researching what eventually became Hockey Chicago Style, an authorized history of the Blackhawks. Mush was the first of more than 40 players, coaches, and officials I interviewed for that project. But it was only fitting, because his name was synonymous with firsts. Mush scored the very first goal at Maple Leaf Gardens in 1931, and the goal that gave Chicago its first Stanley Cup in 1934.

When the final game was played at the Gardens in February 1999, Mush joined former Maple Leaf Red Horner, his one-time enemy, in a ceremonial puck drop, using the actual “first goal” puck from 1931. The year before he died, Mush dropped the puck for the 2000–01 season opener at United Center. Sadly, he was not there to see his old team win the Stanley Cup in 2010, 2013, and 2015. Following the third victory, NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman declared the Blackhawks a “dynasty.” The proclamation sparked more than a few debates but was widely accepted. Dynasty or not, a new era of NHL hockey had arrived in Chicago, defined by modern-day heroes like Corey Crawford, Patrick Kane, and Jonathan Toews.

Chicago’s recent Stanley Cup wins are fresh in the city’s collective hockey psyche. The 1961 championship, which happened six decades ago, can still be recalled by well-seasoned fans. Thanks to rekindled relationships between the team and icons like Bobby Hull and the late Stan Mikita, these greats of yesteryear became a more visible part of the United Center landscape. Their last names still appear on the backs of fans’ jerseys.

Most committed followers know the Blackhawks won Stanley Cups in 1934 and 1938, but these milestones, which happened a very long time ago—well before the “dynasty”—are seldom discussed and often overlooked. On April 14, 1994, the Blackhawks played their very last regular season game at Chicago Stadium. The cover of that night’s 72-page souvenir game program carried the tagline, “Remember the Roar,” in honor of the legendary arena. A full-page photo of the 1960–61 Stanley Cup team appears midway through the book, along with tributes to legends Tony Esposito, Glenn Hall, Bobby Hull, and Stan Mikita. An entire page is devoted to Al Secord, but photos of the 1933–34 and 1937–38 Stanley Cup teams are missing.

Their absence is unfortunate, because these early championship teams initiated the “roar” that fans were being encouraged to remember. Long before Tony “O” and Mr. Goalie made their marks as puck stoppers and the Golden Jet and Stosh became scoring legends, an earlier generation of players electrified Stadium crowds. Chicago’s early hockey milestones were attained by players who were the superstars of their day. Many were pioneers, and some were enshrined in the Hockey Hall of Fame, the United States Hockey Hall of Fame, and numerous Canadian provincial halls of fame.

Like life itself, hockey was different during the Blackhawks’ formative years. In a later interview, Mush recalled the early days of his career when hockey players earned meager salaries. “It was a different time,” he said, remembering a game that was slower, but also tougher, with longer shifts for players, no helmets, modest protective equipment, brutal physical play, and locker rooms that were anything but plush.

Many players and their families lived in Chicago’s Garfield Park neighborhood, in small apartments and hotels where they did life together, celebrating birthdays, cooking meals, playing games, and watching out for each other. Some took the bus to practices and games at the Stadium. Travel between Chicago and other NHL cities involved long train rides. Camaraderie was strengthened aboard Pullman cars, where players smoked cigarettes, played cards, and engaged in practical jokes.

When I described this project to other hockey authors and researchers, more than one said the Chicago Blackhawks’ early history has never been honored very well. This did not surprise me, but it confirmed that my efforts were meaningful. So did the remembrances of the many families I connected with. Sons, daughters, nieces, nephews, and grandchildren of former players generously took the time to recall not just hockey accomplishments, but the kind of people their ancestors were. The photographs, scrapbook pages, telegrams, and letters they provided helped me to re-create scenes from Chicago’s golden era of hockey, which is worth remembering and celebrating.

The quest for Chicago’s first Stanley Cup unfolded against the backdrop of the World’s Fair, an exciting event that inspired millions of people to experience the latest wonders, even as the Great Depression imposed incredible suffering and hardship on the nation. Victory was achieved with legendary players like offensive powerhouse Paul Thompson, who led the Blackhawks in scoring for six consecutive seasons; defensemen Lionel “Big Train” Conacher, who later became Canada’s “Athlete of the Half Century” for his athletic prowess in multiple sports; and Chuck Gardiner, one of the greatest goaltenders in NHL history. Chicago’s heart was broken when Gardiner died the summer after the 1934 victory, as did rookie forward Jack “Newsy” Leswick, whose body was recovered from a muddy Winnipeg river, less his gold Stanley Cup watch.

This book ends with coverage of the 1938 Stanley Cup finals—one of the greatest Cinderella stories in professional sports. After winning just 14 of 48 regular season games, the Blackhawks won the Stanley Cup under coach Bill Stewart. An NHL referee and Major League Baseball umpire by trade, Stewart was the first American to lead an NHL team to hockey’s ultimate prize. In the nets that season was “Iron Mike” Karakas, the first American-born goalie to play in the NHL. Earl Seibert, the bone-crushing “Big Dutchman,” patrolled Chicago’s blue line, striking fear in the hearts of opponents, including Boston’s notorious Eddie Shore.

By resurrecting, honoring, and preserving the Blackhawks’ first two championships, I have attempted to fill a void in the canon of sports books. Victory on Ice recreates a near-century-old landscape, taking readers beyond scores and statistics and allowing them to grasp what it was like to be a professional hockey player in Chicago during the 1930s. It is a tribute to the generation that ignited the roar that echoes through United Center today.

24-25.png

134-135.png

210-211.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
Apologies for being missing in action over the last few months. Let's give this book the attention it deserves.

@HawkyHistory: Thank you very much for your presentation!

I'll start with a go-to question for every historian. What sources did you use for the book? Contemporary newspapers are certainly a given and you also mention the help of the families of former players.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bear of Bad News

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
Thanks for your question! Yes, hundreds of U.S. and Canadian newspaper articles were essential sources. Thanks to modern technology, it is now possible to locate information in digitized newspapers that would have been extremely difficult in the age of microfilm, especially for papers that were never indexed.

Back in the 1990s, I was honored to interview some of the players from Chicago's 1934 and 1938 Stanley Cup teams, like Mush March and Cully Dahlstrom. I still had these on tape, fortunately. In 1995, I also interviewed John Robertson, who had joined the team as a trainer in 1937 and was still guarding the Hawks' locker room door at United Center. He recalled many great stories. There is a photograph of him in the book, along with his father and brother, who also worked for the team in different capacities.

Over the past seven years, I was able to locate and interview the children and grandchildren of many players. Some were extremely generous in sharing rare photographs, letters, telegrams, and scrapbook pages.

Last but certainly not least, I relied on assistance from various archives in the United States and Canada. These included many provincial and national halls of fame, as well as Chicago-area institutions. For example, the Chicago History Museum has a collection of letters and photographs from defenseman Virgil S. Johnson, who played on the 1937-38 team. His son, Virgil C. Johnson, wrote the book's foreword. Being able to read all these letters teleported me back in time, giving me a sense of what it was like to live and play hockey in Chicago almost a century ago.

I should add that members of the Society for International Hockey Research were incredibly helpful, particularly fellow hockey authors Roger Godin, Ty Dilello, and Jeff Miclash. We all share a common interest in hockey's early history, so this book would not have been possible without their feedback, assistance, and help in finding essential information.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
Thanks for your question! Yes, hundreds of U.S. and Canadian newspaper articles were essential sources. Thanks to modern technology, it is now possible to locate information in digitized newspapers that would have been extremely difficult in the age of microfilm, especially for papers that were never indexed.

Back in the 1990s, I was honored to interview some of the players from Chicago's 1934 and 1938 Stanley Cup teams, like Mush March and Cully Dahlstrom. I still had these on tape, fortunately. In 1995, I also interviewed John Robertson, who had joined the team as a trainer in 1937 and was still guarding the Hawks' locker room door at United Center. He recalled many great stories. There is a photograph of him in the book, along with his father and brother, who also worked for the team in different capacities.

Over the past seven years, I was able to locate and interview the children and grandchildren of many players. Some were extremely generous in sharing rare photographs, letters, telegrams, and scrapbook pages.

Last but certainly not least, I relied on assistance from various archives in the United States and Canada. These included many provincial and national halls of fame, as well as Chicago-area institutions. For example, the Chicago History Museum has a collection of letters and photographs from defenseman Virgil S. Johnson, who played on the 1937-38 team. His son, Virgil C. Johnson, wrote the book's foreword. Being able to read all these letters teleported me back in time, giving me a sense of what it was like to live and play hockey in Chicago almost a century ago.

I should add that members of the Society for International Hockey Research were incredibly helpful, particularly fellow hockey authors Roger Godin, Ty Dilello, and Jeff Miclash. We all share a common interest in hockey's early history, so this book would not have been possible without their feedback, assistance, and help in finding essential information.

Quite a wealth of sources.

The Chicago Blackhawks had already made one prior appearance in the Stanley Cup finals back in 1931. What would you say is it that the 1935 team had going for itself that the 1931 team did not?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bear of Bad News

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
Quite a wealth of sources.

The Chicago Blackhawks had already made one prior appearance in the Stanley Cup finals back in 1931. What would you say is it that the 1935 team had going for itself that the 1931 team did not?
Interesting question. Victory on Ice focuses on the 1933-34 and 1937-38 Stanley Cup seasons, so my research for this project did not involve a deep dive into other seasons during the 1930s. However, it seems that Chicago had plenty of potential in both 1930-31 and 1934-35.

In 1930-31 Chicago had a great coach in Dick Irvin and some of the same players who contributed to the 34 Cup victory, including Chuck Gardiner in goal. The Canadiens beat them three games to two in the finals, so I think things easily could have turned out in Chicago's favor that year.

In 1934-35, Paul Thompson and Johnny Gottselig were among the NHL's scoring leaders, and the Hawks had other solid contributors like Howie Morenz and Mush March. Following the tragic death of Gardiner, Chicago had Lorne Chabot in goal. He won the Vezina that year, just like Gardiner had the previous season. Despite all this talent, things fell apart in the quarterfinals when Lolo Couture was slapped with a major penalty for hitting the Montreal Maroons' Dave Trottier on the head with his stick. Montreal then scored a power-play goal on Chabot and the Hawks were out of the playoffs.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
Interesting question. Victory on Ice focuses on the 1933-34 and 1937-38 Stanley Cup seasons, so my research for this project did not involve a deep dive into other seasons during the 1930s. However, it seems that Chicago had plenty of potential in both 1930-31 and 1934-35.

In 1930-31 Chicago had a great coach in Dick Irvin and some of the same players who contributed to the 34 Cup victory, including Chuck Gardiner in goal. The Canadiens beat them three games to two in the finals, so I think things easily could have turned out in Chicago's favor that year.

In 1934-35, Paul Thompson and Johnny Gottselig were among the NHL's scoring leaders, and the Hawks had other solid contributors like Howie Morenz and Mush March. Following the tragic death of Gardiner, Chicago had Lorne Chabot in goal. He won the Vezina that year, just like Gardiner had the previous season. Despite all this talent, things fell apart in the quarterfinals when Lolo Couture was slapped with a major penalty for hitting the Montreal Maroons' Dave Trottier on the head with his stick. Montreal then scored a power-play goal on Chabot and the Hawks were out of the playoffs.

I'm sorry, I meant the 1934 team that won the Stanley Cup, not the 1935 team.
 

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
I'm sorry, I meant the 1934 team that won the Stanley Cup, not the 1935 team.
No worries! I think it’s interesting to compare the leadership of Chicago’s 1930-31 and 1933-34 teams. Both had strong coaches (Dick Irvin in 1931 and Tommy Gorman in 1934) who eventually were inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame, yet that phase of Irvin’s career was just beginning during the early 1930s. In the coming years, he would coach four Stanley Cup winners and his teams made it to the finals on numerous occasions. When Gorman arrived in Chicago, he already had managed three Stanley Cup winners in Ottawa during the early 1920s, so he brought that background to the table. After leaving the Windy City, he coached the Montreal Maroons to the Cup the following season. I’ve often wondered how things might have turned out for Chicago had owner Major Frederic McLaughlin been able to keep Gorman behind the bench for another season. I think the Blackhawks had the talent to win at least one additional championship during the 1930s, and Gorman’s direction and influence certainly could have tipped the scales in their favor. Interestingly, Gorman was the Canadiens’ manager for two of their Cup winners (1943-44 and 1945-46) that were coached by Dick Irvin. You obviously need the right players, but I think it's safe to say that Irvin and Gorman knew a thing or two about winning!
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
When Gorman arrived in Chicago, he already had managed three Stanley Cup winners in Ottawa during the early 1920s, so he brought that background to the table. After leaving the Windy City, he coached the Montreal Maroons to the Cup the following season. I’ve often wondered how things might have turned out for Chicago had owner Major Frederic McLaughlin been able to keep Gorman behind the bench for another season. I think the Blackhawks had the talent to win at least one additional championship during the 1930s, and Gorman’s direction and influence certainly could have tipped the scales in their favor. Interestingly, Gorman was the Canadiens’ manager for two of their Cup winners (1943-44 and 1945-46) that were coached by Dick Irvin. You obviously need the right players, but I think it's safe to say that Irvin and Gorman knew a thing or two about winning!

Gorman is a good cue. Another book I'm currently reading is quoting an 1934 article as follows:

"Forechecheking, a new development in professional hockey, won the Stanley Cup and world championship for Chicago... Tommy Gorman talked about the system he believes will be generally used by National League teams next season. The Hawks, he said, used a revolutionary idea for the last six weeks of the season and in the playoffs. 'True, our backchecking was great,' said Gorman, 'but it was our forechecking that downed all our rivals. About five weeks ago, just prior to playing the Rangers in New York, we conceived the idea of bottling up the opposing forwards - not letting them out of their own zone... In each playoff series we steam-rolled our opponents and wore them down. Instead of backing out of the enemy zone, the Black Hawks kept charging in. The system worked much better than we expected.'"

This indicates that the Blackhawks' (or, back then, Black Hawks') 1934 Stanley Cup campaign had a lasting impact on the NHL and deserves to be remembered much more widely.

Did your sources say anything about the introduction of forechecking?
 

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
Gorman is a good cue. Another book I'm currently reading is quoting an 1934 article as follows:

"Forechecheking, a new development in professional hockey, won the Stanley Cup and world championship for Chicago... Tommy Gorman talked about the system he believes will be generally used by National League teams next season. The Hawks, he said, used a revolutionary idea for the last six weeks of the season and in the playoffs. 'True, our backchecking was great,' said Gorman, 'but it was our forechecking that downed all our rivals. About five weeks ago, just prior to playing the Rangers in New York, we conceived the idea of bottling up the opposing forwards - not letting them out of their own zone... In each playoff series we steam-rolled our opponents and wore them down. Instead of backing out of the enemy zone, the Black Hawks kept charging in. The system worked much better than we expected.'"

This indicates that the Blackhawks' (or, back then, Black Hawks') 1934 Stanley Cup campaign had a lasting impact on the NHL and deserves to be remembered much more widely.

Did your sources say anything about the introduction of forechecking?
While I did not uncover sources that focused specifically on forechecking, Lionel Conacher described this style of play in an article he wrote about the strategies both teams employed during the first two games of the 1934 finals. He explained that, in game two, the Red Wings focused on sending their forwards in to meet the Black Hawks' attack, just as Chicago had done in game one. It's funny, because following Chicago's victory in game one, James Norris criticized the Black Hawks for being a "sort of backcheck, pokecheck and pray club," stating that they "could do nothing but backcheck and wait for breaks." The game was definitely evolving a lot during these early years, and I think Gorman's comments are a great example.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
While I did not uncover sources that focused specifically on forechecking, Lionel Conacher described this style of play in an article he wrote about the strategies both teams employed during the first two games of the 1934 finals. He explained that, in game two, the Red Wings focused on sending their forwards in to meet the Black Hawks' attack, just as Chicago had done in game one. It's funny, because following Chicago's victory in game one, James Norris criticized the Black Hawks for being a "sort of backcheck, pokecheck and pray club," stating that they "could do nothing but backcheck and wait for breaks." The game was definitely evolving a lot during these early years, and I think Gorman's comments are a great example.

Speaking of the finals against Detroit, here's a little more by Tommy Gorman:

'Against Detroit, we carried out the same system with equal success... Jack Adam was the first of the opposing managers to see through our new system... but our forwards kept on going in and the Red Wings could never get organized.'

Interesting stuff for sure.

Paul, you mentioned before that your research also covered the origins of hockey in Chicago and the founding of the Chicago Black Hawks, but the material turned out to be too much for one book. So you basically have another book in the pipeline, is that correct?
 

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
Speaking of the finals against Detroit, here's a little more by Tommy Gorman:

'Against Detroit, we carried out the same system with equal success... Jack Adam was the first of the opposing managers to see through our new system... but our forwards kept on going in and the Red Wings could never get organized.'

Interesting stuff for sure.

Paul, you mentioned before that your research also covered the origins of hockey in Chicago and the founding of the Chicago Black Hawks, but the material turned out to be too much for one book. So you basically have another book in the pipeline, is that correct?
My project's focus changed a few times over seven years. Initially, I intended to concentrate on the Blackhawks' origins, early history, and first Stanley Cups. Then I began wondering how Chicago discovered ice hockey in the first place, which pushed my research all the way back to the 1890s.

Ultimately, I had a 100,000-word manuscript covering the sport's origins and early development in the Windy City, the birth of the Blackhawks, Major Frederic McLaughlin, Chicago Stadium, and the Blackhawks' first two Stanley Cups. It's a lot of content and I decided to break the manuscript in half and start with the 1934 and 1938 championships, on the assumption that all hockey fans can easily relate to and appreciate stories about the Stanley Cup.

Obviously, there are plenty of hockey history enthusiasts out there who would be interested in the earlier material. Yet, it's easy (at least for me) to forget how long ago all of these things happened. Recently, I was doing an interview with a Canadian sportswriter who is reviewing Victory on Ice. He thanked me for including short biographies of the players from both Stanley Cup teams, because most were unfamiliar to him. He also mentioned how the two championships happened almost 100 years ago. Of course, the earliest information I found takes readers back roughly 130 years.

While doing another book is a definite possibility, I don't have anything concrete in the works at this point. I'm thinking that the earlier material could make for some interesting articles. Or maybe it could be part of a joint project, if there is another author out there doing something similar.

I think it's cool that hockey caught on and grew in Chicagoland despite challenging conditions (namely a lack of indoor facilities and lighted outdoor rinks) that made it hard, at first, to organize and maintain local leagues. I would be willing to provide a brief synopsis of Chicago's early hockey history here, based on my research so far, if anyone is interested.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
I think it's cool that hockey caught on and grew in Chicagoland despite challenging conditions (namely a lack of indoor facilities and lighted outdoor rinks) that made it hard, at first, to organize and maintain local leagues. I would be willing to provide a brief synopsis of Chicago's early hockey history here, based on my research so far, if anyone is interested.

I'd be very interested to learn more!
 
Last edited:

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
I'd be very interested to learn more!
Great! I discovered that, by the 1890s, Chicago already had embraced ice skating. In Lincoln Park alone, as many as 20,000 people skated on the park’s 40 acres of ice at once. With two lakes and connecting lagoons, Lincoln Park offered both wide-open stretches of ice for fast skaters and secluded areas where "fancy" skaters could practice intricate moves.

In Garfield Park (located in the same area where many of the Blackhawks' players and their families would later live during the 1930s), crowds of 2,000 skaters were common on Saturday afternoons. The park was home to one of the finest curling tracks in the West. Along with activities like ice boating, improvised ice games became popular, including shinny, ice polo, and eventually hockey.

By the winter of 1895, hockey began to gain momentum in Chicago, with teams forming throughout the city. The Chicago Athletic Association (CAA), a prominent athletic club established in 1890 by business magnates like William Wrigley, Marshall Field, and Cyrus McCormick, was among the sport’s early proponents. The CAA held practices and games at Tattersall’s, a former boxing facility that was converted into an indoor rink.

Tattersall’s was a major exception, because virtually all of the city’s first major organized hockey contests were played outdoors and thus subject to the weather. Many games took place in brutal conditions, including frigid winds and blinding snow. On the flip side, warmer winter conditions were just as bad, making it impossible for early teams to practice or play. Another challenge was that many outdoor rinks were unlit, making it difficult or impossible to play at night.

Some of Chicago's earliest hockey teams included the Wanderers’ Cricket Club, the Chicago Hockey Club, the Skaters’ Club, and the Prairie Avenue Hockey Club. By 1902, the Highland Park Hockey club had been established and was holding matches with other teams, including Kenwood Country Club, which included future NHL builder James Norris. In November of that year, the Chicago College of Dental Surgery organized a team to play in the Intercollegiate Hockey Association.

A major development occurred in September 1910 when a new indoor rink called the Ice Palace opened its doors, offering seating for 3,400 spectators and a 21,000-square-foot sheet of ice. Perhaps the most incredible aspect of the Ice Palace was its unique roof, which enabled elevated train lines to run directly through the building. The approximately 192,000 passengers who traveled through the facility’s roof each day could see skaters below through glass windows.

The Ice Palace was an important development for ice hockey enthusiasts, providing a new option for regular indoor practices and games. On December 30 and 31, 1910, and January 2, 1911, the facility hosted a series of three games between Yale and Cornell Universities, in what was the very first matchup between two college hockey teams in Chicago.

About 10 years before the Blackhawks' formation, enthusiasm for hockey was building in Chicago, but organizing local leagues and keeping them going seemed to be a struggle. One of the first efforts to organize a high school league occurred in early 1916, when Hyde Park High School established a team and began searching for other suburban or city schools to compete against.

Hyde Park was the clear leader among local high school teams, facing off against competitors such as St. John’s Military Academy and Culver Military Academy. (Incidentally, many years later, Major Frederic McLaughlin's son attended and played hockey at Culver). When the Chicago High School League dissolved in 1916-17, the Hyde Park team played against outside clubs, including college teams, and garnered attention with a victory over Northwestern University.

Despite a growing number of options for indoor play, many Chicago-area hockey matches continued to be played outdoors during the first half of the 1920s, at the mercy of the weather. Throngs of Chicagoans attended speed skating races, including The Tribune Silver Skates Derbies, which had been popular for nearly a decade. Yet by 1925, most of the city’s residents were still unfamiliar with the sport of hockey.

NHL competition was finally possible following the installation of an ice rink at the Chicago Coliseum, where the Blackhawks first played. For many years, the Coliseum was one of the Windy City’s premier sports and entertainment venues. Following Blackhawks home games in 1926-27, the Chicago Senior Amateur Ice Hockey League hosted games on Coliseum ice. The league included teams from the Chicago Athletic Association, the Illinois Athletic Association, the Chicago Yacht Club, the Midway Athletic Club, and the Lake Shore Athletic Club, so by this times things were becoming more organized.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
Great! I discovered that, by the 1890s, Chicago already had embraced ice skating. In Lincoln Park alone, as many as 20,000 people skated on the park’s 40 acres of ice at once. With two lakes and connecting lagoons, Lincoln Park offered both wide-open stretches of ice for fast skaters and secluded areas where "fancy" skaters could practice intricate moves.

In Garfield Park (located in the same area where many of the Blackhawks' players and their families would later live during the 1930s), crowds of 2,000 skaters were common on Saturday afternoons. The park was home to one of the finest curling tracks in the West. Along with activities like ice boating, improvised ice games became popular, including shinny, ice polo, and eventually hockey.

By the winter of 1895, hockey began to gain momentum in Chicago, with teams forming throughout the city. The Chicago Athletic Association (CAA), a prominent athletic club established in 1890 by business magnates like William Wrigley, Marshall Field, and Cyrus McCormick, was among the sport’s early proponents. The CAA held practices and games at Tattersall’s, a former boxing facility that was converted into an indoor rink.

Tattersall’s was a major exception, because virtually all of the city’s first major organized hockey contests were played outdoors and thus subject to the weather. Many games took place in brutal conditions, including frigid winds and blinding snow. On the flip side, warmer winter conditions were just as bad, making it impossible for early teams to practice or play. Another challenge was that many outdoor rinks were unlit, making it difficult or impossible to play at night.

Some of Chicago's earliest hockey teams included the Wanderers’ Cricket Club, the Chicago Hockey Club, the Skaters’ Club, and the Prairie Avenue Hockey Club. By 1902, the Highland Park Hockey club had been established and was holding matches with other teams, including Kenwood Country Club, which included future NHL builder James Norris. In November of that year, the Chicago College of Dental Surgery organized a team to play in the Intercollegiate Hockey Association.

A major development occurred in September 1910 when a new indoor rink called the Ice Palace opened its doors, offering seating for 3,400 spectators and a 21,000-square-foot sheet of ice. Perhaps the most incredible aspect of the Ice Palace was its unique roof, which enabled elevated train lines to run directly through the building. The approximately 192,000 passengers who traveled through the facility’s roof each day could see skaters below through glass windows.

The Ice Palace was an important development for ice hockey enthusiasts, providing a new option for regular indoor practices and games. On December 30 and 31, 1910, and January 2, 1911, the facility hosted a series of three games between Yale and Cornell Universities, in what was the very first matchup between two college hockey teams in Chicago.

About 10 years before the Blackhawks' formation, enthusiasm for hockey was building in Chicago, but organizing local leagues and keeping them going seemed to be a struggle. One of the first efforts to organize a high school league occurred in early 1916, when Hyde Park High School established a team and began searching for other suburban or city schools to compete against.

Hyde Park was the clear leader among local high school teams, facing off against competitors such as St. John’s Military Academy and Culver Military Academy. (Incidentally, many years later, Major Frederic McLaughlin's son attended and played hockey at Culver). When the Chicago High School League dissolved in 1916-17, the Hyde Park team played against outside clubs, including college teams, and garnered attention with a victory over Northwestern University.

Despite a growing number of options for indoor play, many Chicago-area hockey matches continued to be played outdoors during the first half of the 1920s, at the mercy of the weather. Throngs of Chicagoans attended speed skating races, including The Tribune Silver Skates Derbies, which had been popular for nearly a decade. Yet by 1925, most of the city’s residents were still unfamiliar with the sport of hockey.

NHL competition was finally possible following the installation of an ice rink at the Chicago Coliseum, where the Blackhawks first played. For many years, the Coliseum was one of the Windy City’s premier sports and entertainment venues. Following Blackhawks home games in 1926-27, the Chicago Senior Amateur Ice Hockey League hosted games on Coliseum ice. The league included teams from the Chicago Athletic Association, the Illinois Athletic Association, the Chicago Yacht Club, the Midway Athletic Club, and the Lake Shore Athletic Club, so by this times things were becoming more organized.


Thank you very much.

Were the earliest players in Chicago all Americans or have you been able to identify any Canadians?
 

HawkyHistory

Registered User
Nov 9, 2022
9
5
Thank you very much.

Were the earliest players in Chicago all Americans or have you been able to identify any Canadians?
It was a mix. The game was definitely catching on with Chicago natives. However, Canadian transplants were a major factor, especially when it came to organizing and promoting the sport.

One early pioneer was a psychologist named Dr. Herbert A. “Harry” Parkyn, who graduated from Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, and completed post-graduate coursework at Toronto University and McGill in Montreal. He first played hockey in Canada and was captain of the Queen’s University, Toronto University, and Victoria teams. Parkyn also served as secretary of the Ontario Hockey Association before relocating to the United States. In Minnesota, he is said to have helped organize the first hockey team at the University of Minnesota in January of 1895, which was then unsanctioned by the university.

A season summary in the 1917 Aitchpe, Hyde Park High School’s yearbook, provided evidence that the team was encountering plenty of Canadian players at that time. It describes three practice games with Northwestern University "which is composed of Canadian stars" and a February trip to Culver, Indiana, to face a team described as "the champions of Indiana" that was "composed chiefly of Canadian students."
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,655
5,056
It was a mix. The game was definitely catching on with Chicago natives. However, Canadian transplants were a major factor, especially when it came to organizing and promoting the sport.

One early pioneer was a psychologist named Dr. Herbert A. “Harry” Parkyn, who graduated from Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, and completed post-graduate coursework at Toronto University and McGill in Montreal. He first played hockey in Canada and was captain of the Queen’s University, Toronto University, and Victoria teams. Parkyn also served as secretary of the Ontario Hockey Association before relocating to the United States. In Minnesota, he is said to have helped organize the first hockey team at the University of Minnesota in January of 1895, which was then unsanctioned by the university.

A season summary in the 1917 Aitchpe, Hyde Park High School’s yearbook, provided evidence that the team was encountering plenty of Canadian players at that time. It describes three practice games with Northwestern University "which is composed of Canadian stars" and a February trip to Culver, Indiana, to face a team described as "the champions of Indiana" that was "composed chiefly of Canadian students."

Thank you very much for the insights. I'm looking forward to future publications by you on early Chicago hockey history!
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad