But I don't understand why anybody would think Detroit would be willing to pay him $9M a year. If it's public that Ottawa is taking him to arbitration to try to get his AAV down to $7.65M, why would the Wings pay significantly more?
If Debrincat comes here it's because he's willing to take about $8M annually, not $9M.
I am pretty confident, obviously could be wrong, but pretty confident that they elected for arbitration to extend the life of his RFA signing status. So, by adding the extra month, they have the ability to still do a sign and trade past the usual deadline to have whatever team trades for him be able to get the 8 years for him still. If the RFA window for resigning ended and they didn't do a QO, they would lose him for nothing and he walks. If they signed him to a 1 year deal to keep him afloat before they trade him later in the summer, then whatever team that trades for him has to have a lower cap situation to eat the 7.65-9 mil contract.
In essence, club-elected arbitration extends the clock to keep the possibility of an 8 year contract. If they didn't do it then see above and add that whatever team trades for him would only be able to do a 7 year contract.
If you look up DeBrincat's metrics he is not as one dimensional as fans here think. He isn't a Selke winner but he's not abysmal defensively. +/- on bad teams doesn't tell the whole story.
He also was trying to fight seider that one time. Yes, it was laughable because seider scoffed at him, BUT he didn't back down right???? Right???? am I right???