The important positions are first who decides on the players to be drafted/signed as FAs/brought on in trades and then the head coach. Adams has had years to decide on who he wants playing for the team--basically undersized players who run up a lot of points playing against other teenagers with few if any who being drafted who have made enough of a difference in the NHL. We all appreciate the smaller gifted players but they are not all Marner, P. Kane or Hutson. Looking at how the game is played today you need more bigger aggressive players than we have been drafting-I hope this changes this year. Sometimes players with a little less skill can mesh together better as a team because they are coachable, have hockey sense and hustle every shift.
I honestly think the draft strategy is the biggest example of lack of 'adults in the room'
Teams will come up with a scoring system for players when making draft boards. This was probably done with analytics in minds. Its obvious their scoring system has a bias towards speedy scoring forwards. Which led to an absolute glut of undersized similarly sized forwards...because while other teams were considering size, d-men, goalies, other things on their draft boards, especially as you got to the 2nd and 3rd rounds, they felt these 'highly ranked' players were dropping to them....because they failed into account that you need more than one type of player to win games. There were a few years in a row where Adams says he was trying to trade up to get a guy at the end of the 1st round and was shocked that they fell to him. It was obvious their draft boards were wildly different than everyone else's.
Looking at Adams drafts:
2020; 4 F, 1 D
2021: 10 F, 1 D
2022: 8 F, 2 D, 1 G
So in 3 years, he selected 22F, 4D d-men, 1 goalie. And sure, certain draft classes will have biases in them in terms of quality of players there. but drafting F to D at a six to 1 ratio over 3 years is obviously a mistake that anyone with a twinge of common sense can see.
At some point they were made aware of the errors of their ways, because the 2023 draft they picked 4D, 3F, 1 G, and in 2024 they went 4 D, 3 F, 1 G. So obviously there is a bit of over correction happening now.
But there are so many examples of just dumb errors happening under the Adams front office. And I think most of it can be explained by a simple "nobody knows what they are doing". Their processes are broken. Its a owner and GM, both of whom have never built a winning team, essentially "faking it till you make it" while the fans have to suffer through over a decade of incompetence.