I rarely post on a team's board. But I have decided to here. Some Islanders fans that post on the mainboard know I watch the Isles due to being a fan of Mathew Barzal.
But I made a series of posts late in the season of how Tavares played. Particularily he looked suddenly slower than I ever saw him. He was never fast to begin with. But at that time I did say I had my reservations to signing a player that looked like a combination of age and the game getting faster catching up with him to the expected 11 x 8 year contract he would sign. At the time I did not know where he would sign, on the Island, be traded at the deadline, or he hit would even hit UFA status.
I just knew what I saw, and commented on what I saw. And said I had reservations on a long contract for a player that looked like he was starting his decline. Maybe JT was hurt, to give him the benefit of doubt. But it's hard to see him getting faster in an increasingly faster game.
I advocated Snow trading him for draft picks. A 1st and a 2nd could have easily had. This is the true and only crime here. Snow for some reason did not do a good job at protecting his assets by securing assets for a potential lost asset.
Now make no mistake about it, Tavares is going to produce in Toronto. He may find his 5v5 game there too. But on the Island especially in the 2nd half of the year, he was pretty much a PP specialist, his line did not lead the team to the playoffs. Barzal's line was good enough that it should have been closer and if JT played like the elite player he is supposed to be with good goaltending, the Isles should have made it. You can look around the NHL at players that have declined as we head into the longer term of their contracts. Weber, Parise, Toews, Perry, and past ones like Mike Richards.
What I am saying here is, I know this is not a good day for Isles fans. You guys have every reason to be angry. You may even feel betrayed. But in my experience of following the game. Buying a Cup rarely happens. And sometimes the better thing is not to be tied to a long unmovable contract when the player declines. We have no way of knowing how this plays out. Isles have some great young talent coming up from a A+ draft. A new Mgr and stanley cup winning coach. A new arena. Time is on the side of this team. It doesn't take much to turn a team into a playoff team in the new NHL.