Thanks for this. Certainly shows Dick Duff to be a clutch player, doesn't it? Think he's about 12th for points in the finals.
Dick Duff's record did impress me. Almost half his playoff points were from the finals.
However, the player whom I often tout as underrated(At least by a few people who think he is overrated) is Henri Richard. He was the player on that team everyone looked to as a clutch leader. Even Captain Beliveau.
I always refer to Henri Richard as "Messier-lite", because of the similarities of their situation. Both were 2nd line centers behind legendary players. Both integral parts of Dynasties and clutch players who were considered leaders even before they got their "C".
Both were considered good complete players, but Messier was "very Good" two way(But never a Selke candidate) and Richard was one of the best two way players(Selke caliber if the trophy had existed), although Messier has an edge in scoring. Era's were very different, but how they scored in relation to their peers is similar.
Messier:
Goals
1981-82 NHL 50 (8)
1982-83 NHL 48 (9)
1989-90 NHL 45 (9)
1995-96 NHL 47 (9)
Assists
1986-87 NHL 70 (3)
1987-88 NHL 74 (5)
1988-89 NHL 61 (8)
1989-90 NHL 84 (2)
1991-92 NHL 72 (6)
1994-95 NHL 39 (6)
Points
1982-83 NHL 106 (7)
1986-87 NHL 107 (3)
1987-88 NHL 111 (5)
1989-90 NHL 129 (2)
1991-92 NHL 107 (5)
1994-95 NHL 53 (10)
Richard:
Goals
1957-58 NHL 28 (7)
1959-60 NHL 30 (5)
Assists
1956-57 NHL 36 (8)
1957-58 NHL 52 (1)
1959-60 NHL 43 (4)
1960-61 NHL 44 (7)
1962-63 NHL 50 (1)
1963-64 NHL 39 (10)
1965-66 NHL 39 (8)
Points
1956-57 NHL 54 (9)
1957-58 NHL 80 (2)
1959-60 NHL 73 (5)
1960-61 NHL 68 (9)
1962-63 NHL 73 (4)
1965-66 NHL 61 (9)
1966-67 NHL 55 (10)
And their all star records at a glance look different, but are not that much. Messier first 2 Selections came from the LW position(A selection much easier to attain than center in either era) playing on Gretzky's line. His 3rd season was also a LW selection, but I am certain he was a center on the 2nd line that year with Anderson.
Messier:
1981-82 NHL NHL All-Star Team (1st)LW
1982-83 NHL NHL All-Star Team (1st)LW
1983-84 NHL NHL All-Star Team (2nd)LW
1989-90 NHL NHL All-Star Team (1st)C
1991-92 NHL NHL All-Star Team (1st)C
Richard:
Honors
1957-58 NHL NHL All-Star Team (1st)C
1958-59 NHL NHL All-Star Team (2nd)C
1960-61 NHL NHL All-Star Team (2nd)C
1962-63 NHL NHL All-Star Team (2nd)C
Anyways. I know Messier is a superior player. No doubt about that at all, and I agree with Richard's placement on the list.
However, Richard often gets tabbed as a "Tag along" by his detractors when his supporters mention how invaluable he was in 11 Cup wins. His teammates and coaches all consider him to be one of the greatest ever and the leader of that team, by word and deed. His finals numbers, combined with his terrific two way play from the second line clearly show just how invaluable he was.