Sheldon Keefe Discussion Thread

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Keefe has literally been out coached three successive post seasons, it’s behind frustrating enduring this guy figuring it out while we blow prime window years.
That's what stings for me the most, window is this season and next. If Matthews bolts all bets are off. Keefe can only use what he has, but it's clear he and Dubas share a vision/attachment to certain players.

There was a good chunk of salary to move this off-season to badly retool this team on the fly but management had other ideas. Shuffling deck chairs on the Titanic at this point.
 
Keefe has lost them, and I'm not entirely sure it's all his fault either. Core players are a problem, team has zero, zero identity.
Keefe's strange statements to the media and then back tracking twice was really curious.

It seems like someone (or several) on the team are out to get coach Keefe. Did Matthews/Marner not like Keefe benching Bunting?
 
Keefe has lost them, and I'm not entirely sure it's all his fault either. Core players are a problem, team has zero, zero identity.

The way this team plays and behaves in certain, predictable trap game conditions, takes the foot off the gas, no shows the start of games/periods and tenses up in elimination games is a very distinct identity. We just want it to change...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ianturnedbull
I don't care for Sheldon Keefe.

I know it's early, but 5 more games will likely tell the tale.

For now it seems like either Keefe is not preparing these guys for games, or they are tuning him out.

Either way it's bad for Keefe and really bad for Shanny/Dubas.
When teams start of each period in a fog...it's the coach most of the time that is responsible. He is supposed to get them geared up for each period. I think they have started the process of tuning him out completely. I see another 10 or so games of rope before he gets packing. Dubas will only do it if its bad enough that he has no choice but to fire him like Babs.
 
Kallgren starting against the Sharks and likely again on the weekend back-to-back. This guy overlooks opponents and the team obviously rubs off on his arrogant attitude
 
When teams start of each period in a fog...it's the coach most of the time that is responsible. He is supposed to get them geared up for each period. I think they have started the process of tuning him out completely. I see another 10 or so games of rope before he gets packing. Dubas will only do it if its bad enough that he has no choice but to fire him like Babs.
I think they’ve tuned him out as well, we can win in spite of that, but he seems diminished.
 
Calgary lost 2 100 point guys. Are they better or worse? Time will tell but team > individual.
People here would meltdown on just moving a Nylander/Muzzin in a deal. Which we should have done at the start of the year to prepare for the next UFA wave.

If we didn’t prepare for that next wave, we’d be sorry. Just like asset management doesn’t hurt you today but you’ll be sorry.
All of the core assets are still under contract beyond this season though. It simply wasn't a now or never situation this offseason. there's still time for asset management type moves - be it Nylander or Marner or even Matthews if things don't go well this season-post season
 
Kallgren starting against the Sharks and likely again on the weekend back-to-back. This guy overlooks opponents and the team obviously rubs off on his arrogant attitude
If that's the plan, it's a big mistake. Kallgren's just not very good. He's barely an AHL goalie and you're going to start him 2 out of 3 games when the team has been underwhelming? If it wasn't for Samsonov the score would have been 6-1 or more against Vegas. Big BIG mistake.
 
Kallgren starting against the Sharks and likely again on the weekend back-to-back. This guy overlooks opponents and the team obviously rubs off on his arrogant attitude
He's starting Kallgren against the Sharks? Are you kidding?
 
Keefe has lost them, and I'm not entirely sure it's all his fault either. Core players are a problem, team has zero, zero identity.
I definitely saw this same core "coach-kill" when they didn't want Babs around anymore, hoping they haven't already tuned out Keefe but there's a lot of the same symptoms

Saying that tho I don't wanna see the season go down the drain and I think Liljegren will improve this team on his very first shift, especially in transition

He's starting Kallgren against the Sharks? Are you kidding?
That's what the overdrive guys were saying, haven't seen Keefe say it for sure tho
 
So the Kings and Ducks games are back to back...

Does that mean they accidentally committed to Kallgren is starting 2 of the next 3 games with a back to back split? Or is Samsonov playing back to back in both those games?

Aren't back to back games generally to be avoided from a sports science, load management perspective?

Isn't the whole purpose of giving the Kallgren the Thursday start to give Samsonov a break?

But why are they giving Samsonov a break as he's breaking out and trying to establish himself as a number one?

Wouldn't a SJ, LA start and an Anaheim rest be the best game selection for Samsonov?

Of all the angles, starting Kallgren on Thursday seems to be the worst decision. Keefe is over thinking things. The way things are going, I wouldn't be surprised if he changed his mind tomorrow on the starts.
 
So the Kings and Ducks games are back to back...

Does that mean they accidentally committed to Kallgren is starting 2 of the next 3 games with a back to back split? Or is Samsonov playing back to back in both those games?

Aren't back to back games generally to be avoided from a sports science, load management perspective?

Isn't the whole purpose of giving the Kallgren the Thursday start to give Samsonov a break?

But why are they giving Samsonov a break as he's breaking out and trying to establish himself as a number one?

Wouldn't a SJ, LA start and an Anaheim rest be the best game selection for Samsonov?

Of all the angles, starting Kallgren on Thursday seems to be the worst decision. Keefe is over thinking things. The way things are going, I wouldn't be surprised if he changed his mind tomorrow on the starts.
As far as I can tell Samsonov is it. There is no other plan now. I think they need to play him as much as possible. I don't see any other way. What? We're hoping Murray will return, be healthy, and help TOR? Not with that injury history. Not with that glove hand.
 
No kidding. He is.
1666833247190.png
 
I would love to say to everyone on this board that our great coaching will get us past our recent shortcomings (goals for, injuries, identity, heart, hustle, the power play, organizational depth, bottom 6, lack of toughness, defense, etc.), but I would be fool for posting that.
I'm confident Trotz would have a hard time with this team. The way it's been constructed has been a massive failure.

I think the only way this gets corrected is if JT's 11 million is moved.

Matthews and Marner and incredible talents. Nylanders contract is pure value right now with the way he's playing. We need a cheaper #2 centre so we can spread the rest of the money out on quality depth. Kadri's 7 million would be perfect there right now.


In 10 years time when Dubas's Maple Leaf career is looked back on, the Kadri trade will go down as his worst move.
 
  • Like
Reactions: supermann_98
Keefe has lost them, and I'm not entirely sure it's all his fault either. Core players are a problem, team has zero, zero identity.
To a certain extent I feel for him, like look at this:



He looks like he's said it 1000 times but they won't listen, like he's fed up. Can't really blame him, his job is on the line and the players keep repeating bad habits
 
  • Like
Reactions: francis246
To a certain extent I feel for him, like look at this:



He looks like he's said it 1000 times but they won't listen, like he's fed up. Can't really blame him, his job is on the line and the players keep repeating bad habits

Haha.. wow.. yep thats the why dont you listen to me face
 
  • Like
Reactions: leafsfan5
He lost me Game 4 pre-game, so self satisfied to have already achieved a split, it’s all gravy now mentality. His team came out just like the coach, foot off the gas, facing a wounded animal, content. He didn’t understand the moment, his inexperience was apparent and they squandered a chance to bury the champs. Keefe has literally been out coached three successive post seasons, it’s beyond frustrating enduring this guy figuring it out while we blow prime window years.
That game was the single most infuriating display I think I've seen out of this core. Which is surprising, because we have seen so many

Up 2-1 on the defending champs, you have them weak with a chance to make it 3-1 going back to an insanely loud crowd. You pissed away an amazing chance the year prior in a historical collapse where you took your foot off the gas. You should be hungry and driven to put the champs on the ropes. Instead we came out limp and the game was over in 10 minutes, pathetic.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad