Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Shea Weber to VAN

Status
Not open for further replies.
LMAO......Montreal just traded for this guy. They are not going to be trading him away for at least 3 years if not more.
 
Wow. That's pretty bad. Sorry. I wouldn't even trade that for Subban.

If this were to become something like the Jeff Carter in Clb then Mtl would be getting much less than this. If Mtl was smart they would target Tanev + Horvat and that's probably enough to do it.
 
iloveloov said:
Basically Vancouver needs Weber and Montreal needs to win a big trade again
Click to expand...

Why does Vancouver need Weber? Why does Montreal need to win a trade again? They're doing just fine. They might do this based on Vancouver giving up more than 4 first round picks. At the same time though they aren't rebuilding. Vancouver is not competing and I wouldn't be surprised if they finished last in the pacific
 
I see this as a bad trade for both teams.

What Van gives is clearly more valuable but it hurts Montreal window. Van isn't a contender even with Weber and they should keep their assets and hope to be a contender in 5 years.

That 1st rounder could be #1st pick.
 
Montreal isn't going to trade for Weber and then flip him shortly afterwards.

Vancouver would be really stupid to do this. Do they want a future?
 
OK I changed it a bit to make it more fair for Vancouver..

SJSharks39 said:
Why does Vancouver need Weber? Why does Montreal need to win a trade again? They're doing just fine. They might do this based on Vancouver giving up more than 4 first round picks. At the same time though they aren't rebuilding. Vancouver is not competing and I wouldn't be surprised if they finished last in the pacific
Click to expand...

Vancouver needs Weber because it has no point shot on the PP but most importantly Shea will be a good mentorship for the young kids. Canucks would be cup contenders with Weber I.M.H.O.

Montreal will love Chris Tanev he is like PK Subban defensively.. Habs can afford to wait the 1 more year it will take for Boeser and Juolevi to make the NHL since Price is still young.
 
iloveloov said:
Wow Weber is really underrated in by Vancouver fans
Click to expand...

No, he's over rated by Canucks fans, but this idea of yours essentially salts the earth with our future and keeps us in purgatory.

Weber would be AMAZING as an add, but the added physicality and offense Weber provides over Tanev isn't worth our top prospect, our top D prospect we've had since Ohlund (with our highest pick since the Sedins were drafted) and the added weight of Desharnais.

The only reason we'd want to move Burrows, by the by, is to make room for someone else, not for another cap dump...so I mean that's not going to register as the main problem with Canucks posters, but I love how you snuck that in there.
 
I would not trade Tanev one for one for Weber. Hell, I wouldn't trade any of the pieces in this trade aside from maybe Burrows one for one for him.
 
Many things wrong with this deal, both the editted one and the original. Vancouver loses their top prospects and gets Weber (right after the Canadians just got him so it wouldn't happen anyway). Montreal walks away with a bandit and doesn't have to pay Shea Weber his ridiculous contract where he is makes 6mil until he is 36. Just a terrible deal for Vancouver. Shea Weber is a game changer but not this much
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom