The bottom line is that at this point Scrivens is a mess. The causation does not change that. You know and I know that the lack of D and Eakins stink is all over Scrivens like it was on Dubnyk last year. It won't change here in all likelihood IMO. Until MacT gets at least a decent defense in front of him I don't want to see Brossoit here, he's too promising a young player to just hang him out to dry night after night.
Brossoit for me is at least a year away from being an NHL backup. Let him become a dominant AHL goalie first and then mentor behind a solid #1 in the NHL for a year or more. Bachman is a career AHL goalie IMO. Their NHL results are not particularity significant.
I think Scrivens would be ok as a backup if 2 things happen....the D gets an overhaul and an experienced #1 gets brought in. Craig Anderson would be a great fit for many reasons not the least of which is that he manages the game very well.
If those 2 things happen I see Scrivens regaining his confidence and turning his game around. He is not a #1 goalie especially behind this train wreck of a team.
He would be fine as a backup that plays 25+ games behind a solid vet and a decent defence..