Discoverer
Registered User
- Apr 11, 2012
- 11,608
- 7,295
I have a crazy trade proposal, but bear with me.
Bichette (24) + throw-in for Reynolds (27) + Bednar (27) + Prospect/Player
Rationale for Toronto:
We need a good lefty bat and late-inning bullpen help.
Reynolds is a power-hitting, switch-hitter who can play center field (although his defense this year has declined). He's good for at least 3WAR per year and put up 6WAR last season. He's only 27 so in the prime of his career, and still has 4 years of team control left.
Bednar is one of the best closers in baseball right now. He has strikeout stuff and could spell Jordan Romano when he needs rest. He's 27, not arb eligible until 2024, and has 5 years of team control remaining.
Bichette is a great young offensive player, but he's also not very good defensively. We could slot Espinal in at shortstop and actually improve from a defensive standpoint. Espinal will not replace his offensive potential, but he's shown he can contribute at least league average offense if not better, and whatever offense we lose at short we gain from Reynolds.
The third piece imo is necessary to even out value but I'm not sure which direction to go. We could target a prospect with potential like Ji-hwan Bae or Anthony Solometo, a young post-hype starter like Mitch Keller, or veteran starter like Jose Quintana to give us rotation depth (granted, Quintana is more smoke and mirrors than stuff now).
Acquiring Reynolds allows us to possibly move one of Teo or Gurriel for a top starter with Springer moving to RF and Reynolds to CF.
The Toronto throw-in could be any prospect type we have in excess and don't really need or a player really far away.
Rationale for Pittsburgh:
Bo is an all-star caliber, former 5WAR player, who fits Pittsburgh's rebuild timeline perfectly at only 24 years of age.
Their front office would know him well since they used to be ours. He has 4 years of team control left, but is arb eligible in 2023.
Pitt could probably get a bunch of prospects for these veterans but Bo is already established and still young with lower risk. He's arguably the best player they could get in a trade, and they're able to get him for two veterans who won't be part of their rebuild anyway.
I'm pretty sure Bo has three years left... same as Reynolds.
I honestly don't think this makes sense for either side. I like Reynolds, but the Jays need an OF a lot less than they need a SS right now. If you want a guy like Bednar, just make it a simple deal for prospects.
As an offseason move, I guess I can kind of see it if you want to shake things up. But during the season I don't love the idea of shuffling all kinds of parts around to address what should be a pretty straightforward hole.