Like I said, you can look it up. Multiple teams have had top 5 picks three consecutive years and NONE OF THEM have ever drafted a wing each time with that top 5 pick. That's not an opinion, it's a fact. You can give me whatever BPA bullshit you want to but it's never happened before and the NHL draft is old enough that you can draw clear conclusions from its history.
RW Matvei Michkov (2023, 7th, PHI) Part 4
- Thread starter GermanSpitfire
- Start date
- Status
Rob Brown
Way She Goes
- Dec 17, 2009
- 17,426
- 14,496
Truthfully I'm not entirely sure what your point is. It's pretty understood that Russian players come with a bit extra 'complications' in terms of contract situations, logistics etc. and it's been widely reported on that many NHL teams were worried that he might not come over for a while, so they drafted other players and thus he slipped. None of your examples are Russian players and most played in the NHL sooner than their D+4 season, so I'm not sure what your point is.
Why didn’t you want Cooley or Wright instead of Nemec? Both were ranked higher on most lists. Do you also think NJ would be better with Wright/Cooley instead of Nemec going forward? They were BPA at the time.
- Apr 27, 2005
- 35,402
- 34,166
Do you regret your team choice a few years later?
Edit: Do you think you’re better off with Cooley or Nemec right now?
- Apr 27, 2005
- 35,402
- 34,166
I would have preferred Cooley at the time and still would prefer Cooley.
TheKrebsCycle
Throwing Confetti for Perfetti
The quote exists multiple times in this thread . You’re quite capable of tracking it down .
Guadana
Registered User
Meh. You are picking better player. Especially when we talk about players with potential in 80-90-100 points or even more. Go find your RD on the market.
Chicago have their own chances to regret about it later.
Last edited:
Nico Cauzuki
Registered User
yes im sure its very easy to find good young RDs on the market
My point was that nhl gms are not worried about having high draft picks becoming immediate impact players. Which was the suggested reason that teams passed on mickhov.
CanadienShark
Registered User
- Dec 18, 2012
- 40,079
- 14,773
Closest I can think of off the top of my head would be Oilers picking Hall, RNH, Yakupov in consecutive years at #1. Obviously RNH can play wing or centre though.
It doesn’t exist
Lapointe said it played a role as much as he hinted michkovs play in the defensive end played a role as well
Guadana
Registered User
Who said “young”? And it’s easier to find young RD on the market than young winger with real 80-100+ points potential.
Chicago did, Buffalo didn’t, Rangers drafted left handed wingers all the time. With Panarin and Kreider in the roster. Both Demidov and Michkov have better ceiling than Kakko an Laf. Rangers drafted Otthman, Perrault after. With Cuylle and Sykora picks in seconds rounds. With huge need in centers all those years. Devils drafted Silayev with great NHL defense and very good prospect defensive pool, with Huuuuge need in centers. It’s not an argument.
It’s way harder to acquire young top pairing RHD than young PPG winger. Let’s not kid ourselves here.
TheKrebsCycle
Throwing Confetti for Perfetti
Dude you’re getting caught up in semantics . They were concerned about the 3 year time frame and the unknown nature of when he’d be coming over . He also gushed about his offense ability/ potential . Sorry for using a big word … yikes . It was a factor . Literally from the horses mouth .
Dr Jablonski PhD
Registered User
You mean the Galchenyuk who scored 0.68 points per game on a powerhouse and the Michkov who scored 0.87 points per game on a pile of shit team?
Crazy man
If you had a chance to draft matt tkachuk, ovi, Kane and in consecutive years you wouldn’t do it?
They didn’t pass on Michkov because of the contract
If they loved the player they would have made it work
They just thought Reinbacher was going to end up being the better player of the two and the more impactful. Your small quote is taken out of context. The full article/interview is here: Subscribe
EDIT:
https:// recrutes.ca/ habs-lapointed-in-the-right-direction/
Just like Juraj Slafkovsky’s selection the year before, the Reinbacher pick can be explained by the high compete level he showed at the World Championships. Both players wanted to make a difference, to “be the guy” for their team.
The Canadiens’ co-director of amateur scouting explained that for the organization, skills matter but it’s not the most important component when it comes to picking a player. As skillful as Michkov was, his compete level was not as high as Reinbacher’s and that matters.
*Stop spreading misinformation around when you have no idea what you’re talking about.
2 hints I saw on why they passed on the player not the contract
Defensive play and compete level
Both from the horses mouth
Laughable
Defensive play and compete level
Both from the horses mouth
It’s in his best interests to believe that the habs are run by buffoons that would pass on a sure fire superstar because he wasn’t available for 3 years
Laughable
Last edited:
TheKrebsCycle
Throwing Confetti for Perfetti
The quote from Lapointe exists whether you want to play down the significance or not . I’ll let people decide for themselves if they choose to search it out. It’s all there . Even when I’m not talking about a Hab player I still have lemmings following me … if you don’t like my posts put me on ignore . Or not .
I have no problem putting people on ignore
I have zero issues with you personally
TheKrebsCycle
Throwing Confetti for Perfetti
Cool dude enjoy Reinbacher and his “ compete “ . I’ll take skills all day . I recon the majority would as well if there is a significant talent divide . Michkov is plenty competitive additionally.
Of course, the leafs are full of stars that don’t compete
Worked out well for Montreal with Slafkovsky over Wright and Cooley and I’m sure Reinbacher will work out alright.
You mean the majority of fans who never played anything other than beer leagues and rely on hockeydb and youtube to make up their mind of a player? Yeah, I’ll give the benefit of the doubt on the team who’s drafted Slaf, Hutson, Beck, Demidov, Reinbacher, Fowler, Hage over the last 3 draft. They seem to know what they’re doing.
FYI, since Lapointe took over the draft department from Timmins Montreal drafted Caufield (15), Guhle (16), Mailloux (31), Slafkovsky (1), Mesar (26), Reinbacher (5), Demidov (5) and Hage (21). He does seem to know what he’s doing - Better than HFboards at least and the « majority » of its members
Every team needs a player that does the scoring. Every team needs a player who plays hard. To each their own.
- Status
