ATD: Rules - Discussion - Trades Thread

[GKJ]

I can keep going past 33 rounds, I’m just sayin

 

[spintheblackcircle]

So happy to get Bavaro and Blair.

 

[Tony Romo]

So happy to get Bavaro and Blair.

Sounds like a bad cop show

 

[spintheblackcircle]

Sounds like a bad cop show

A fake Mel Gibson and a fake Danny Glover

 

[Holden Caulfield]

I'm not super sure how I should evaluate kickers. Old timey guys had percentages that wouldn't have even gotten you into training camp nowadays, but were winning league MVP's (at least one of the versions of MVP) as recently as 1970. But a guy who was kicking at 55% and from beyond 40 when most kickers were at 45% and not kicking outside 40 vs a guy who's kicking 85% when most guys were at 80% and the distances are similar, would be far more dominant for his era. If for example one of those guys had modern fields, equipment, training, and practicing and has shown that they can dominate their peers at the time should be able to maintain that advantage. Kicker is probably one of the positions that has evolved the most over time so it'll make it tricky. Every one of the top 5 in all-time FG% are currently active in the NFL and #6 is a 33 year old who has been bounced out of the league involuntarily.

 

[Hasbro]

Been almost 12 hours. Should I go?

 

[Ben Grimm]

Terrell Suggs is joining the Raven's Ring of Honor. Jerry Jones still won't let Jimmy Johnson in the Cowboys.

Edit: Bob Griese wore glasses (not goggles) during games.

Edit: There's a funny old clip of Staubach being a little bit defensive about Namath. He says "Hey, I like sex too"!

 

[VanIslander]

A team with Aaron Rodgers just drafted a QB in Roger Staubach?!

Doesn't history teach us anything!

It is said a team with two QBs has none, and certainly Aaron isn't happy with this kind of situation.

 

[Hasbro]

A team with Aaron Rodgers just drafted a QB in Roger Staubach?!

Doesn't history teach us anything!

It is said a team with two QBs has none, and certainly Aaron isn't happy with this kind of situation.

What's worse is he's taking Craig Morton next.

 

[Ben Grimm]

The Chargers are retiring Joiner and Winslow's numbers.

Sadly, Steve Sidwell passed away.

 

[Michael Farkas]

Skip me, I'll make it up. Work has been a bear this week.

 

[Hasbro]

Skip me, I'll make it up. Work has been a bear this week.

 

[Tony Romo]

@LT you are up!

Will update the draft thread soon.

 

[Voight]

If this draft was held a year ago Russell Wilson may have been drafted.

 

[GKJ]

Bob St. Clair was taken much too late. It was a debate in my head between he and Lane Johnson

 

[Tony Romo]

Bob St. Clair was taken much too late. It was a debate in my head between he and Lane Johnson

I considered him when I took Slater. It was a really solid pick.

 

[GKJ]

I considered him when I took Slater. It was a really solid pick.

The only reason I think I didn’t take him was because I did take him whenever the last time we did this was

 

[DaaaaB's]

Yeah, I can't believe St. Clair was still available.

 

[VanIslander]

I

 

[VanIslander]

Two rounds ago i wanted to take an extra lineman ("you can't have enough if them" is an NFL GM mantra), and i had McCormack & St. Clair left on my long list at RT. I went with the 9-time all-pro, two-time champion team leader. But if I had known he and St.Clair would have been available, I might have left starting RT until last.

 

[LT]

Some insight on that pick:

We have long past reached the extent of my NFL history knowledge

And I couldn't think of what else I wanted besides a different-look dual-threat QB

 

[DaaaaB's]

Two rounds ago i wanted to take an extra lineman ("you can't have enough if them" is an NFL GM mantra), and i had McCormack & St. Clair left on my long list at RT. I went with the 9-time all-pro, two-time champion team leader. But if I had known he and St.Clair would have been available, I might have left starting RT until last.

McCormack was a great value pick too. Most have him as a top 5 RT of all-time and some have him top 3.

 

[tony d]

Has @Michael Farkas been skipped?

 

[VanIslander]

Only Ted Hendricks has more sacks among the 20/20 club...

6'7 Guatemalan-born Ted Hendricks, the "Mad Stork" whose height was accompanied by 230 lbs of speed and nastiness, on both the 1970's and 1980's all-decade team (on the NFL 100 team), with noted plays in four Super Bowl victories.

If 'only' Hendricks is better, consider your guy tops, as Hendricks is an outlier.

 

[GKJ]

6'7 Guatemalan-born Ted Hendricks, the "Mad Stork" whose height was accompanied by 230 lbs of speed and nastiness, on both the 1970's and 1980's all-decade team, with noted plays in four Super Bowl victories.

If 'only' Hendricks is better, consider your guy tops, as Hendricks is an outlier.

Yeah, he only started getting hall of fame momentum recently. Wasn’t even in the Eagles own hall of fame until 2018. A bunch of the Buddy Ryan eagles look to be very underrated, likely because they didn’t win a playoff game. Joyner did get to 2 Super Bowls both against and with the Broncos, but long past his best.

Todd Christensen - that was a guy I almost just took. My last 2 picks, I had a bunch of guys all on the same level.