Roster Building Thread V (2022-23): Cheese and WINE

[BBKers]

Compare NYR PO rosters in Regular seasons 2023 vs 2022​

2023 Panarin = 2022 Panarin
2023 Zibanejad = 2022 Zibanejad
2023 Kreider < 2022 Kreider
2023 Lafrenière > 2022 Lafrenière
2023 Kakko > 2022 Kakko
2023 Chytil > 2022 Chytil
2023 Goodrow = 2022 Goodrow
2023 Motte = 2022 Motte
2023 Trochek > 2022 Strome
2023 Tarasenko > 2022 Copp
2023 Kane > 2022 Vatrano
2023 Vesey > 2022 Reaves
2023 Blidh/Brodzinski = 2022 Hunt

2023 Fox = 2022 Fox
2023 Lindgren < 2022 Lindgren
2023 Trouba > 2022 Trouba
2023 Miller > 2022 Miller
2023 Schneider = 2022 Schneider
2023 Mikkola > 2022 Braun
2023 Harpur > 2022 Hajek

2023 Shesterkin < 2022 Shesterkin
2023 Halak = 2022 Georgiev

2023 Mr Proper = 2022 Don Rickles

Kids progression and better acquisitions make for a better team
Kreiders season is by no means bad, but far from last years all star play
The Big intangible will be Igor’s play.
If he can rekindle his magic, been pretty good as of late.,The team can go very far.
But now we see what happens when reality meets theory, in the playoffs where nothing else matters excepts for “what have you done for me lately?”

 

[tlk]

Compare NYR PO rosters in Regular seasons 2023 vs 2022​

2023 Panarin = 2022 Panarin
2023 Zibanejad = 2022 Zibanejad
2023 Kreider < 2022 Kreider
2023 Lafrenière > 2022 Lafrenière
2023 Kakko > 2022 Kakko
2023 Chytil > 2022 Chytil
2023 Goodrow = 2022 Goodrow
2023 Motte = 2022 Motte
2023 Trochek > 2022 Strome
2023 Tarasenko > 2022 Copp
2023 Kane > 2022 Vatrano
2023 Vesey > 2022 Reaves
2023 Blidh/Brodzinski = 2022 Hunt

2023 Fox = 2022 Fox
2023 Lindgren < 2022 Lindgren
2023 Trouba > 2022 Trouba
2023 Miller > 2022 Miller
2023 Schneider = 2022 Schneider
2023 Mikkola > 2022 Braun
2023 Harpur > 2022 Hajek

2023 Shesterkin < 2022 Shesterkin
2023 Halak = 2022 Georgiev

2023 Mr Proper = 2022 Don Rickles

Kids progression and better acquisitions make for a better team
Kreiders season is by no means bad, but far from last years all star play
The Big intangible will be Igor’s play.
If he can rekindle his magic, been pretty good as of late.,The team can go very far.
But now we see what happens when reality meets theory, in the playoffs where nothing else matters excepts for “what have you done for me lately?”

Tarasenko maybe, but Kaner?

 

[HockeyBasedNYC]

2023 Panarin = 2022 Panarin

I actually think he will be a lot better this year. In addition to an injury he was dealing with he was really upset about his performance last playoffs, even with that game 7 winner. I actually think youll see Bread manage the puck better and even throw the body around (we've already seen more of that in his game).

2023 Panarin > 2022 Panarin

 

[haohmaru]

Tarasenko maybe, but Kaner?

Over Vatrano? In the playoffs?

Kaner is a gamer. He's a guy you want specifically for this time of year.

Kaner no brainer.

 

[GoAwayPanarin]

2023 Panarin = 2022 Panarin

I actually think he will be a lot better this year. In addition to an injury he was dealing with he was really upset about his performance last playoffs, even with that game 7 winner. I actually think youll see Bread manage the puck better and even throw the body around (we've already seen more of that in his game).

2023 Panarin > 2022 Panarin

Wayyyyyyyy better this year.

2022 Panarin was awful for most of the season. His game flipped a bit once Copp was Acquired but he blew for the large majority of the season despite having a good stat line. Kreider's PP god work kept him above a PPG the first half of the season.

 

[Chytilmania]

Wow over the past two seasons Fox has 1 PP goal. That's really bad lol. Goodrow, Kakko, Lundqvist have just as many and Trouba has more lol.

I think Kreider's huge drop in PPG is force feeding Mika and overpassing. If Fox actually shot then both him and Kreider would have more goals. But overall I'd say he's still the same player. Scoring more 5v5 I think.

 

[Machinehead]

This was Panarin's best season since 19-20.

90+points but he also f***ed around and became a plus defender because he remembered that he's just really good at hockey.

 

[SA16]

Wow over the past two seasons Fox has 1 PP goal. That's really bad lol. Goodrow, Kakko, Lundqvist have just as many and Trouba has more lol.

I think Kreider's huge drop in PPG is force feeding Mika and overpassing. If Fox actually shot then both him and Kreider would have more goals. But overall I'd say he's still the same player. Scoring more 5v5 I think.

Kreider attempted 23.0 shots/60 at 5v4 last year and is attempting 24.2 this year. You think his huge drop is that he's overpassing, despite shooting more, and not that he went from shooting 38% to 12%?

 

[Ruggs225]

Kreider attempted 23.0 shots/60 at 5v4 last year and is attempting 24.2 this year. You think his huge drop is that he's overpassing, despite shooting more, and not that he went from shooting 38% to 12%?

His huge drop is because he isnt getting every single deflection into the back of the net.. and frankly i think he he actually deflecting less pucks in general this year.

 

[Chytilmania]

Kreider attempted 23.0 shots/60 at 5v4 last year and is attempting 24.2 this year. You think his huge drop is that he's overpassing, despite shooting more, and not that he went from shooting 38% to 12%?

No he has sucked at tip ins this year. What’s his career average on PP

 

[SA16]

No he has sucked at tip ins this year. What’s his career average on PP

I don't know why don't you go to the website and look it up?

 

[duhmetreE]

I don't know why don't you go to the website and look it up?

Inundates you with stats until it doesn't fit his narrative LOL

 

[Avery16]

Wow over the past two seasons Fox has 1 PP goal. That's really bad lol. Goodrow, Kakko, Lundqvist have just as many and Trouba has more lol.

I think Kreider's huge drop in PPG is force feeding Mika and overpassing. If Fox actually shot then both him and Kreider would have more goals. But overall I'd say he's still the same player. Scoring more 5v5 I think.

I think Fox keeps the zone better than any other of our D. It’d be great if he scored goals too, but that’s just not how our PP runs.

 

[haohmaru]

Here's little perspective that might raise some eyebrows:

Player A

326 career games as a Ranger 64G 74A 138 Points

Player B

320 career games as a Ranger 61G 54A 115 Points

Who am I?

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Here's little perspective that might raise some eyebrows:

Player A

326 career games as a Ranger 64G 74A 138 Points

Player B

320 career games as a Ranger 61G 54A 115 Points

Who am I?

Chytil and Vesey

 

[Rangerfan4life90]

Here's little perspective that might raise some eyebrows:

Player A

326 career games as a Ranger 64G 74A 138 Points

Player B

320 career games as a Ranger 61G 54A 115 Points

Who am I?

Not sure of Player B, but I think Player A could be Chytil?

 

[bhamill]

Here's little perspective that might raise some eyebrows:

Player A

326 career games as a Ranger 64G 74A 138 Points

Player B

320 career games as a Ranger 61G 54A 115 Points

Who am I?

I don't know. Who?

Chytil and Vesey

Ha! Though Chytil started on NYR as an 18YO, and Sick Jimmy was 22...

 

[haohmaru]

Chytil and Vesey

Nailed it

 

[IDvsEGO]

Compare NYR PO rosters in Regular seasons 2023 vs 2022​

2023 Panarin = 2022 Panarin
2023 Zibanejad = 2022 Zibanejad
2023 Kreider < 2022 Kreider
2023 Lafrenière > 2022 Lafrenière
2023 Kakko > 2022 Kakko
2023 Chytil > 2022 Chytil
2023 Goodrow = 2022 Goodrow
2023 Motte = 2022 Motte
2023 Trochek > 2022 Strome
2023 Tarasenko > 2022 Copp
2023 Kane > 2022 Vatrano
2023 Vesey > 2022 Reaves
2023 Blidh/Brodzinski = 2022 Hunt

2023 Fox = 2022 Fox
2023 Lindgren < 2022 Lindgren
2023 Trouba > 2022 Trouba
2023 Miller > 2022 Miller
2023 Schneider = 2022 Schneider
2023 Mikkola > 2022 Braun
2023 Harpur > 2022 Hajek

2023 Shesterkin < 2022 Shesterkin
2023 Halak = 2022 Georgiev

2023 Mr Proper = 2022 Don Rickles

Kids progression and better acquisitions make for a better team
Kreiders season is by no means bad, but far from last years all star play
The Big intangible will be Igor’s play.
If he can rekindle his magic, been pretty good as of late.,The team can go very far.
But now we see what happens when reality meets theory, in the playoffs where nothing else matters excepts for “what have you done for me lately?”

I'd say aside from the injury 2023 lindgren has been significantly better than 2022 lindgren.
Saying Geo and halak are equal is a huge compliment to halak.
But overall mostly agree.

 

[Raspewtin]

I'd say aside from the injury 2023 lindgren has been significantly better than 2022 lindgren.
Saying Geo and halak are equal is a huge compliment to halak.
But overall mostly agree.

yeah, this 100%

Lindgren was lowkey bad last year in the RS.

 

[IDvsEGO]

I don't know. Who?


Ha! Though Chytil started on NYR as an 18YO, and Sick Jimmy was 22...

Exactly. Compare age 22+23 seasons, and its
140gp 30g 37A 67pts for chytil
159gp 32g 22a 55PTS for vesey

Chytil outscores him in less games significantly, and almost out goals him in 19 less games.
And they averaged almost the exact same amount of ice time

And on further look. Chytil actually does have more ES goals.

 

[GoAwayPanarin]

yeah, this 100%

Lindgren was lowkey bad last year in the RS.

Not even low key, he was dreadful. If he weren't the tough and gritty type he would have been roasted on here.

His playoff run redeemed his play from the RS.

 

[EdJovanovski]

Compare NYR PO rosters in Regular seasons 2023 vs 2022​

2023 Panarin = 2022 Panarin
2023 Zibanejad = 2022 Zibanejad
2023 Kreider < 2022 Kreider
2023 Lafrenière > 2022 Lafrenière
2023 Kakko > 2022 Kakko
2023 Chytil > 2022 Chytil
2023 Goodrow = 2022 Goodrow
2023 Motte = 2022 Motte
2023 Trochek > 2022 Strome
2023 Tarasenko > 2022 Copp
2023 Kane > 2022 Vatrano
2023 Vesey > 2022 Reaves
2023 Blidh/Brodzinski = 2022 Hunt

2023 Fox = 2022 Fox
2023 Lindgren < 2022 Lindgren
2023 Trouba > 2022 Trouba
2023 Miller > 2022 Miller
2023 Schneider = 2022 Schneider
2023 Mikkola > 2022 Braun
2023 Harpur > 2022 Hajek

2023 Shesterkin < 2022 Shesterkin
2023 Halak = 2022 Georgiev

2023 Mr Proper = 2022 Don Rickles

Kids progression and better acquisitions make for a better team
Kreiders season is by no means bad, but far from last years all star play
The Big intangible will be Igor’s play.
If he can rekindle his magic, been pretty good as of late.,The team can go very far.
But now we see what happens when reality meets theory, in the playoffs where nothing else matters excepts for “what have you done for me lately?”

Fox should DEFINITELY be red

 

[Rangerfan4life90]

Fox should DEFINITELY be red

Nah, not at all. He was just as good as last year honestly minus not having Lindgren for a while this season.

 

[duhmetreE]

Trouba has been better as of late but he was better in 2022.

Panarin is way better in 2023.

Zibs has been way better in 2023 imo.

Regular Season means little to nothing at the end of the day. You could be Scott Brosius in the regular season but if you're pulling magic out of your ass in the postseason, that's what you'd be remembered for.