- Aug 5, 2010
- 13,849
- 9,482
the prior year ottawa had the worst record and also dropped to 4th but traded away the pick...
there is no perfect solution to the draft lottery because there is no way to separate the teams tanking on purpose and the teams that are legit bad...if anything the lottery did EXACTLY what it was intended to do and didn't reward the red wings for tanking and not even trying to field a competitive team.
the new way will last 1 year before people complain about that...if the team with the worst record gets the pick people will say its encouraging tanking. if someone else gets it they will say its not fair...the only time anyone likes the lottery is when their team wins, then its just fine.
This is exactly right.
The existing system works in the sense of preventing teams from benefitting from purposely tanking. Now you want to limit better teams from getting too lucky via lottery? Then set up some sort of limitation on frequency of moving into top-3. Let's say you can't move up more than once every 2-3 years. Additionally, to prevent Edmonton situation set an overall limitation where a team cannot select in top-3 more than 3 times in 5 years.