Oh I know it's not a concern, I just wanted to point it out because it's... impressive, in a bad way.
I agree with your points. Though Shattenkirk will be hard to move unless he's part of some package and we have something not super desirable coming back as well. On the flip side, even if he is declining I do think he could have a bounce back season as he adapts and heals up and it's not terrible to have a guy who played his whole career as a top tier level player of said similar style to ADA and Fox. Maybe ADA did or is still learning from him. Fox certainly could. Don't think we'd get any less for him at the TD, and potentially a decent amount more if he's used correctly and is healthy... a lot of ifs, but that's all we can do at this point. Wonder aloud. Regardless, we won't get a lot and will certainly have to retain for anything decent.
I 100% agree and want someone dissimilar on the right. If Fox pans out and ADA continues then I would certainly love a right side of those two with someone bigger and more defensive. Agreed. We've got all our bigger defensive guys on the left until Miller (offense), and all our smaller offensive guys on the right. Though Skjei on the left is an all around guy who would be perfect playing less and having less expected of him. He's a good 2nd pairing with the correct righty, perhaps said bigger defensive guy we want =)
Staal and Smith have their values and uses, but not at those prices and not all three at once (including Shattenkirk here). So it's basically rookies with aging vets that should be bottom pairing guys or 7th on rotation that can play bigger minutes when needed here and there and mentor in the new class. Just need to find the right pairings, see who sticks out of camp and who isn't ready, and what deals (if any) make sense for us. Another buyout right now (or next season) is annoying but may be required.
I'd love to see a versatile mix of defense that can adapt to different teams strategies and be shifted around in terms of pairings and minutes played, depending. Quick, agile, puck-moving, with some guys who can play physically and crease clear. I guess I just summed up every team's desire. We won't have a top 10 defense any time soon but we don't really need to. We just need to evolve the right pieces and acquire what's missing to make it something good, or at least a lot better than it currently is (was).
Shame Skjei isn't (prime) McDonagh 2.0 like we thought he'd be. If we had that, our solid top pairing lefty, all of this would be a lot easier to plan.