Pretty much how I see it too. But some of it really is that the team just plays better for the other guys. It's not entirely true, as you're pointing out, the rotation and the teams we play against factor in--but it's not not true either. Personally, I just hope Henrik, if he does get the nod while Shesterkin is out, can perform as well as he has. And I really hope the team can galvanize around him and support him. No matter where you feel he ranks among our three goalies, it's just not true that the guy isn't still an NHL caliber goalie, and it'd be a bit despicable if the team didn't give him a great performance and try to win one for this guy.
Yeah, that's the thing. Even if people think Georgiev is better than Lundqvist, Lundqvist isn't some total sieve either. It's why I don't understand why people think he should retire. If you want to move on from him, that's one thing, but him to retire?
He's put up better traditional number this year than a bunch of other starters like Holtby, Freddy Anderson, John Gibson, Mrazek, Bobrovsky, Rinne, Matt Murray (Holtby is an .897sv% on the season lol) and his advanced numbers are pretty good as well. He may not be what he once was but he's definitely still an NHL goalie. Other guys are in the same area within a point or two (Fleury, Binnington, Price). I mean I think it's pretty safe to say all of our goalies including Hank would be putting up better numbers than Fluery, Holtby, Rinne, Murray or Binnington if they were playing on teams that good. Fleury is a .908 behind a Vegas team that is top 5 at limiting quality against and everyone thinks he's a amazing, Binnington is an All stay with a .909 behind one of the best teams in the leauge. Holtby is an .897 behind a top 3 team. But somehow Lundqvist should retire? It's just dumb.
I actually agree with you about the team playing worse in front of Hank at least in the recent memory. They'd have a couple good games in front of Georgiev and then lay a stinker when hank came in. Calgary and St. Louis games come to mind as you pointed out.
I want him to play well whenever he is called on too but I worry about it bc even at his prime he was a guy who didn't ever play well after long layoffs. So it's more likely he comes in and is shaky and then it becomes more of we can't use him bc we're trying to make the playoffs and he's too shaky bc he hasn't played enough lately, but him not playing enough lately is an issue that kind of was started by DQ in the first place so it it is just a self perpetuating cycle. Don't get me wrong, I wanted Igor to keep getting starts and want him to be the starter, but with Igor missing two separate stretches to injury DQ had chances to give Hank a game and he didn't. Give him one game in that back to back set igor missed with the ankle and now instead of being 4 weeks removed from his last start he's only 10 days. Idk this is why a 3 goalie situation doesn't work.