ROEN
Writes for Habsworld
I decided to go back to writing this year about the Habs, here is my full article, but feel free to follow me on substack, will be posting as much as possible ! Would love some feedback as I haven't written in decades.
Yet, history has a funny way of slapping hubris right out of those who dare to presume. While some saw potential stars in that prospect lineup, what ensued was less of a starry constellation and more of a dimming bulb. Whether through a fan's rose-tinted glasses or a GM's hopeful blueprint, the Habs’ 2010s prospects hardly made a splash.
And why? It wasn’t just about misjudging talent. The Montreal cocoon, supposedly built to nurture these young players away from the harsh lights of scrutiny, turned out to be filled with chinks. Instead of offering respite, it often crumbled under pressure, leaving its young charges vulnerable to everything but hockey.
Flash forward a decade. Is the scene any different now? There's a youthful wind blowing through the Habs, embodied in the Caufield-Suzuki camaraderie. The front office's embrace of more player-centric approaches—thanks to the likes of Chantal Machabée, Rob Ramage, and Francis Bouillon—hints at change. But history tends to echo. One only needs to remember Mike Ribeiro's candid conversation with Tony Marinaro about the overwhelming weight of Montreal's media landscape.
In yesteryears, Trevor Timmins often placed his bets on the US collegiate ranks. A strategic move, some said, to keep the kids away from the limelight. But how many of those prospects truly shone in the NHL? This collegiate bet might've saved them from the media circus, but it arguably robbed the Habs of cultural unity. Instead of being taken under the wings of mentors like Josh Gorges or Brendan Gallagher, young talents were often left adrift, leading to tragic tales more often than fairytales.
So, as the Canadiens gear up for another training camp, the pressing question is: What kind of locker room awaits these young players? Will it be a laid-back country club or a tight-knit family? Given the burgeoning potential, one can only hope it’s the latter. But if there's one thing history and Red Fisher have taught us: In Montreal, hope should always be laced with a touch of skepticism.
Prospects Aplenty: But Can the Habs Break the Cycle?
A lineup bursting with young talent stirs excitement. Yet, Montreal's past asks us to tread with cautious optimism.
On a hot summer’s day in 2011, Pierre Gauthier, the Canadiens’ GM at the time, must've believed he was sitting pretty. The Habs' prospect pool, bolstered after a deep playoff push, was humming with names – many mere whispers, a few a bit louder. To an outsider, names like Nathan Beaulieu and Louis Leblanc might've sounded like the future. Gauthier must’ve thought so too.Yet, history has a funny way of slapping hubris right out of those who dare to presume. While some saw potential stars in that prospect lineup, what ensued was less of a starry constellation and more of a dimming bulb. Whether through a fan's rose-tinted glasses or a GM's hopeful blueprint, the Habs’ 2010s prospects hardly made a splash.
And why? It wasn’t just about misjudging talent. The Montreal cocoon, supposedly built to nurture these young players away from the harsh lights of scrutiny, turned out to be filled with chinks. Instead of offering respite, it often crumbled under pressure, leaving its young charges vulnerable to everything but hockey.
Flash forward a decade. Is the scene any different now? There's a youthful wind blowing through the Habs, embodied in the Caufield-Suzuki camaraderie. The front office's embrace of more player-centric approaches—thanks to the likes of Chantal Machabée, Rob Ramage, and Francis Bouillon—hints at change. But history tends to echo. One only needs to remember Mike Ribeiro's candid conversation with Tony Marinaro about the overwhelming weight of Montreal's media landscape.
In yesteryears, Trevor Timmins often placed his bets on the US collegiate ranks. A strategic move, some said, to keep the kids away from the limelight. But how many of those prospects truly shone in the NHL? This collegiate bet might've saved them from the media circus, but it arguably robbed the Habs of cultural unity. Instead of being taken under the wings of mentors like Josh Gorges or Brendan Gallagher, young talents were often left adrift, leading to tragic tales more often than fairytales.
So, as the Canadiens gear up for another training camp, the pressing question is: What kind of locker room awaits these young players? Will it be a laid-back country club or a tight-knit family? Given the burgeoning potential, one can only hope it’s the latter. But if there's one thing history and Red Fisher have taught us: In Montreal, hope should always be laced with a touch of skepticism.