Tribute Penguin Player Rankings: #18

[ChaosAgent]

1. Crosby (70%)
2. Geno (82.5%)
3. Letang (considered a formality, 17.5% of the #2 poll)
4. Guentzel (85%)
5. Dumoulin (73%)
6. Rust (50%)
7. Kapanen (58%)
8. Carter (71%)
9. Marino (44%)
10. Blueger (38%)
11. Zucker (68%)
12. Matheson (55%)
13. Jarry (50%)
14. McGinn (winner of run-off)
15. Pettersson (loser of run-off)
16. ZAR (44%)
17. DeSmythe (59%)

Click to read more...

 

[Andy99]

I hate to say it, because we’re really scrapping the bottom of the barrel, but it’s ERod closely followed by Ruh….do we really have to dig this low and dredge up the sewer?…it smells bad and it’s all shit anyway…I vote for stopping this exercise at the Penguins 18th best player lol

 

[dogthateats]

I had a tough choice between Heinen and ERod. I went with Heinen since he has played on a crappy Anaheim team most recently and had good numbers in Boston. I like ERod though (when used in the right role)

 

[ChaosAgent]

I hate to say it, because we’re really scrapping the bottom of the barrel, but it’s ERod closely followed by Ruh….do we really have to dig this low and dredge up the sewer?…it smells bad and it’s all shit anyway…I vote for stopping this exercise at the Penguins 18th best player lol

I like seeing the best of the worst.

But we could alternatively just take the results of this poll and make the top 6 #18-#23 to get to the end.

 

[ChaosAgent]

Finished this up. I'm not going to keep going.

Final Ranks:
1. Crosby (70%)
2. Geno (82.5%)
3. Letang (considered a formality, 17.5% of the #2 poll)
4. Guentzel (85%)
5. Dumoulin (73%)
6. Rust (50%)
7. Kapanen (58%)
8. Carter (71%)
9. Marino (44%)
10. Blueger (38%)
11. Zucker (68%)
12. Matheson (55%)
13. Jarry (50%)
14. McGinn (winner of run-off)
15. Pettersson (loser of run-off)
16. ZAR (44%)
17. DeSmythe (59%)
18. Rodrigues (39% of #18 poll)
19. Heinen (28% of above)
20. POJ (17% of above)
21. Riikola (1 vote of above; ranked higher for @The Old Master)
22. Friedman - I like him but not as much as TOM likes Riikola.

Here's a new chart

 

[The Old Master]

Finished this up. I'm not going to keep going.

Final Ranks:
1. Crosby (70%)
2. Geno (82.5%)
3. Letang (considered a formality, 17.5% of the #2 poll)
4. Guentzel (85%)
5. Dumoulin (73%)
6. Rust (50%)
7. Kapanen (58%)
8. Carter (71%)
9. Marino (44%)
10. Blueger (38%)
11. Zucker (68%)
12. Matheson (55%)
13. Jarry (50%)
14. McGinn (winner of run-off)
15. Pettersson (loser of run-off)
16. ZAR (44%)
17. DeSmythe (59%)
18. Rodrigues (39% of #18 poll)
19. Heinen (28% of above)
20. POJ (17% of above)
21. Riikola (1 vote of above; ranked higher for @The Old Master)
22. Friedman - I like him but not as much as TOM likes Riikola.

Here's a new chart

View attachment 467792

much thanks