Rumor: Nylander like Matthews unextended. Nothing to see here.

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
You can't massively overpay him compared to every other comp again sorry.

Mitch is STILL above market value.

Ship his ass out of town before paying him 10 it'll just make the others rob us. Doing so will just double down on the absolutely ass contracts with the insane trade protection that were handed out

Let others reset the market not us
That's the thing though...we don't reset the market...we just pay more than anyone else and they refuse to pay these garbage deals we gave out. We are literally on a different salary cap than other contenders because we constantly over pay our top guys. And before I hear the "I would rather overpay Mitch than a 3rd liner" spiel...We can't use that as an excuse because Jim Benning decided to do it multiple times. Good GM's limit their mistakes...bad ones don't.
 
There’s talk that Matthews has a contract agreement with the Leafs, but the announcement is being delayed until the Nylander situation is resolved. I’m not sure I understand why that is though. :huh:
 
Fortunately for the Leafs, the technology for Nylander to communicate with Matthews hasn't been invented yet.
Well we know they don't talk over dinner. :laugh:

 
Throughout the cap era...

11-12% forwards signing contracts as UFAs or extensions as pending UFAs have averaged 0.95 points per game and 0.73 primary points per game through their 3 most recent seasons. They are, on average, 30 years old in the first season of their contract, and 34 years old in the final season of their contract.

10-11% forwards signing contracts as UFAs or extensions as pending UFAs have averaged 0.86 points per game and 0.65 primary points per game through their 3 most recent seasons. They are, on average 30 years old in the first season of their contract, and 35 years old in the final season of their contract.

Through his 3 most recent seasons, Nylander has put up 0.98 points per game and 0.79 primary points per game. He will be 28 in the first season of his contract, and if he signs a max 8 year deal, he will be 35 years old in the final season of his contract.

That's just a rough overview, and there's more to contracts obviously, but I found it interesting.
 
Personally I would have traded Marner long time ago. His game will never translate well in playoffs. The guys plays like a wuss and makes too many dumbheaded mistakes that lead to goal against especially with the "fancy BS"

But of course that ship has sailed with July 1st and the NTC/NMC now kicked in . Shanahan dropped the ball big time the moment he picked dubas as a gm after doing the right things i.e. scorched earth, and rebuild route.

Would have preferred Leafs get 4 first round picks and marner get an offersheet than what transpired.

What a wasted opportunity

Last 3 playoff at 5v5

Goal against
Marner 1,33 goal against/60
Matthews 1,52 goal against/60
Nylander 3,19 goal against/60

You didn't took the right guy to speak about dumbass pass in defensive mistake
 
Last 3 playoff at 5v5

Goal against
Marner 1,33 goal against/60
Matthews 1,52 goal against/60
Nylander 3,19 goal against/60

You didn't took the right guy to speak about dumbass pass in defensive mistake

here us Tavares; goal against/60; how much of Nylander's GA/60 is because of Nylander versus Tavares?

1689276478448.png



Here is GF% for 5 on 5 hockey in playoffs:

Tavares
1689276631466.png


Matthews
1689276682488.png


Marner
1689276706310.png


Nylander
1689276739739.png


Interesting to note that Nylander's GF% gets screwed when he started playing with Tavares.

Tavares has been a JOKE 5 on 5 for his entire career in terms of GF%. Thats on coaching; and the dumbass ass GM who did not leave enough cap for quality depth to compensate for this fiasco.

Team building in the cap environment; especially competitive team building is of paramount importance. Given your position regarding Nylander's "new contract" you should start pointing fingers at previous GM and the moronic coach and not at posters like me who point out the obvious -> NO CAP LEFT FOR QUALITY DEPTH BECAUSE THE CORE 4 TOOK LION'S SHARE OF THE CAP AND DO NOT SHOW UP IN THE PLAYOFFS!!!
 
I don’t think that’s the right way for g doing “comparables” comparison.

Willy can seek that ridiculous AAV on another team. Treliving should be working a trade here. No more Dubas era BS. It is about Toronto Maple Leafs not handful of players that don’t put the team in the back but want to squeeze out every penny
You don't think that the correct way of doing a comparable analysis is to compare the player to the most like players in the NHL? I think we'll all need a moment to let that sink in.

(You also can't just trade him. I mean, you can try, but either the team he's going to needs to know that he will sign there or they have to be willing to take a chance they can convince him. If you don't have that, you won't get value.)
 
here us Tavares; goal against/60; how much of Nylander's GA/60 is because of Nylander versus Tavares?

View attachment 728672


Here is GF% for 5 on 5 hockey in playoffs:

Tavares
View attachment 728673

Matthews
View attachment 728674

Marner
View attachment 728675

Nylander
View attachment 728676

Interesting to note that Nylander's GF% gets screwed when he started playing with Tavares.

Tavares has been a JOKE 5 on 5 for his entire career in terms of GF%. Thats on coaching; and the dumbass ass GM who did not leave enough cap for quality depth to compensate for this fiasco.

Team building in the cap environment; especially competitive team building is of paramount importance. Given your position regarding Nylander's "new contract" you should start pointing fingers at previous GM and the moronic coach and not at posters like me who point out the obvious -> NO CAP LEFT FOR QUALITY DEPTH BECAUSE THE CORE 4 TOOK LION'S SHARE OF THE CAP AND DO NOT SHOW UP IN THE PLAYOFFS!!!

Tavares goal against at 5v5 last 3 playoff is at 2,65 vs 3,19 for nylander
 
here us Tavares; goal against/60; how much of Nylander's GA/60 is because of Nylander versus Tavares?

View attachment 728672


Here is GF% for 5 on 5 hockey in playoffs:

Tavares
View attachment 728673

Matthews
View attachment 728674

Marner
View attachment 728675

Nylander
View attachment 728676

Interesting to note that Nylander's GF% gets screwed when he started playing with Tavares.

Tavares has been a JOKE 5 on 5 for his entire career in terms of GF%. Thats on coaching; and the dumbass ass GM who did not leave enough cap for quality depth to compensate for this fiasco.

Team building in the cap environment; especially competitive team building is of paramount importance. Given your position regarding Nylander's "new contract" you should start pointing fingers at previous GM and the moronic coach and not at posters like me who point out the obvious -> NO CAP LEFT FOR QUALITY DEPTH BECAUSE THE CORE 4 TOOK LION'S SHARE OF THE CAP AND DO NOT SHOW UP IN THE PLAYOFFS!!!
WHY ARE YOU SO MAD AT NYLANDER'S CURRENT CONTRACT? IT'S BEEN A GD STEAL.

PS WHY ARE WE YELLING?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: andora
Tavares didn’t play in the habs series as he was injured

for someone that wants to use data doesn’t understand how to contextually use information.

sure bro
I know he didn't played against habs and i only used the +/- 3 he played...

Nylander only against habs was at 3,05 goal against/60 min
 
Then why do you want to give Nylander 9+ AAV?
I would not go more than 9.5. of it was up to me I'd go let him choose 8.88 or 8.666. But I'm a nobody. Does he deserve more based on otehr stars? Maybe, I mentioned before I'd rather Willi at 9mil than marner at 13 mil. And I'm not a marner hater. Have his jersey... I actually have both Matthews and marner jerseys (black Friday sales, none of this full price shit). I also have a tavares islanders jersey I got from consolidated salvage for like 50 bucks....
Maybe I should stop buying players jerseys.... Nameless from now on (not that I need more leaf Jerseys).

Ok rambling done. Back to steam whistle beer and bbqing dinner for fam before I ditch em for band practice.

P.s I'm not driving incase anyone is concerned.. making my bass player drive me
 
I would not go more than 9.5. of it was up to me I'd go let him choose 8.88 or 8.666. But I'm a nobody. Does he deserve more based on otehr stars? Maybe, I mentioned before I'd rather Willi at 9mil than marner at 13 mil. And I'm not a marner hater. Have his jersey... I actually have both Matthews and marner jerseys (black Friday sales, none of this full price shit). I also have a tavares islanders jersey I got from consolidated salvage for like 50 bucks....
Maybe I should stop buying players jerseys.... Nameless from now on (not that I need more leaf Jerseys).

Ok rambling done. Back to steam whistle beer and bbqing dinner for fam before I ditch em for band practice.

P.s I'm not driving incase anyone is concerned.. making my bass player drive me

I don't know man

9.5 x 8 years is approx 76 million dollar package for Nylander. If we walk him to the UFA; any team that is willing to offer that to Willy will have a 10.9 approx AAV on a 7 yr deal (max Willy can sign as a UFA with another team in terms of years).

I really don't think anybody in the NHL is going to offer Willy anything more than a 9 AAV at max on a 7 yr deal in the UFA market.

As for Marner; he is already overpaid IMO for what he brings; giving Marner anything more than 11.5 on his next deal for a long term deal is going to be insanity and going to piss me off. I'd rather have Nylander at 9 too than Marner at 12+ AAV that is just absolute madness for a winger who goes into a shell in playoffs

Enjoy the beers and BBQ man. There was a tornado warning in ON today; hopefully it has passed where you live

I never want to give more than 8,5M to nylander...

I 100% for trading him for a top 4 D

On that we can agree. No more than 8.5 to 8.8 for Nylander on a long term deal i.e. 8 years; if not he is outta here for a package for the Leafs which leafs can turn into 4D either by trading with a team that gives us that Top4 D or we can use the assets from the trade to trade those assets for a top 4 D.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arzak and Metroid
I don't know man

9.5 x 8 years is approx 76 million dollar package for Nylander. If we walk him to the UFA; any team that is willing to offer that to Willy will have a 10.9 approx AAV on a 7 yr deal (max Willy can sign as a UFA with another team in terms of years).

I really don't think anybody in the NHL is going to offer Willy anything more than a 9 AAV at max on a 7 yr deal in the UFA market.

As for Marner; he is already overpaid IMO for what he brings; giving Marner anything more than 11.5 on his next deal for a long term deal is going to be insanity and going to piss me off. I'd rather have Nylander at 9 too than Marner at 12+ AAV that is just absolute madness for a winger who goes into a shell in playoffs

Enjoy the beers and BBQ man. There was a tornado warning in ON today; hopefully it has passed where you live



On that we can agree. No more than 8.5 to 8.8 for Nylander on a long term deal i.e. 8 years; if not he is outta here for a package for the Leafs which leafs can turn into 4D either by trading with a team that gives us that Top4 D or we can use the assets from the trade to trade those assets for a top 4 D.
Thanks!
Ya I'm in 'sauga, so far just clouds haha.

At this point all we can do is clench and hope for the best lol then we can either celebrate or rant.

Def is frustrating tho... Never do I remember signing stars being such a pain in the ass
 
  • Like
Reactions: PromisedLand
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad