Proposal: NYI-OTT

[NYI365]

For curiosity's sake, I wanted to gauge the interest in a potential off-season move between NYI and OTT. NYI need some kind of drastic change, especially if they continue to bottom out this season.

I submit the following proposal only if OTT fails to make the playoffs this year and Brady follows his brother's footsteps and wants out of Canada. I am rooting for the Sens though to make it this year, have always liked Ottawa as an NYI fan.

To Ottawa:

Mat Barzal
Noah Dobson

To NYI:

Brady Tkachuk
Thomas Chabot

The logic here is NYI get a premier winger to go alongside Horvat more in tune with the physical NYI identity than Barzal, and Chabot a solid LD to replace Dobson.

OTT would gain a 70 point RD to pair alongside Sanderson for the future and Barzal can slot in at C or RW alongside Stutzle for the future.

Thoughts from a value perspective if both team's go for change in the off-season? No disrespect meant if Brady is not moving.

Click to read more...

 

[NyQuil]

Dobson is certainly nice piece but Ottawa drafted Yakemchuk to be that guy in the future.

Interesting trade idea though!

 

[Baksfamous112]

NYI doesn’t touch this.

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

NYI doesn’t touch this.

Nor does Ottawa

 

[seabass45]

NYI doesn’t touch this.

You might be surprised!

 

[Glorydays22]

Isles don't do this. If and a very small chance they decide to move both Brazal and Dobson. They will DEFINITELY trade them separately to get more valve (youngsters and picks.)

 

[Akrapovince]

NYI view Barzal and Dobson the same way that Ottawa views Stützle and Sanderson.

Surprised no Islanders fans have came in here offering Pulock and Horvat as a counter for Tim and Sandy.

 

[GCK]

Interesting. As a Sens fan I have zero interest but it’s an interesting proposal. When I saw NYI-OTT proposal I figured something around Pinto and Dobson.

 

[SpezDispenser]

NYI doesn’t touch this.

Honestly, I don't think Ottawa does either. It's good value, but Tkachuk is too valuable to us.

 

[Akrapovince]

Interesting. As a Sens fan I have zero interest but it’s an interesting proposal. When I saw NYI-OTT proposal I figured something around Pinto and Dobson.

If we could get a 70 point RHD for Pinto it would have already been done.

 

[Nac Mac Feegle]

I love Dobson, but that is way too much value for Ottawa to give up. Not a bad proposal on paper, though.

 

[CanadienShark]

Sweet deal for Ottawa.

 

[ThreeLeftSkates]

You might be surprised!

Lou would not do that in a million years.

 

[impaaaaaact]

If we could get a 70 point RHD for Pinto it would have already been done.

What would you add to Pinto for Dobson?

 

[Golden_Jet]

Ottawa would pass

 

[Akrapovince]

What would you add to Pinto for Dobson?

NYI doesn’t take a standard blue chip prospect, roster player, first round pick for a player of Dobson’s calibre and team contract control.

For NYI, the conversation starts and ends with Tim Stützle. That is just the reality.

If Dobson was a pending UFA with 1.5 years left, maybe a first round pick, Pinto, and a blue chip prospect (Yak?) might work, but no reason for NYI to ask for anyone except Stützle.

1RHD >= 1C

Similar age, similar control, and similar impact.

 

[NyQuil]

NYI doesn’t take a standard blue chip prospect, roster player, first round pick for a player of Dobson’s calibre and team contract control.

For NYI, the conversation starts and ends with Tim Stützle. That is just the reality.

If Dobson was a pending UFA with 1.5 years left, maybe a first round pick, Pinto, and a blue chip prospect (Yak?) might work, but no reason for NYI to ask for anyone except Stützle.

1RHD >= 1C

Similar age, similar control, and similar impact.

I would not trade Stutzle for Dobson.

I can understand NYI wanting him, but I think Stutzle has more value than Dobson.

He's 13th in PPG in the league at the moment, he still has 6 more years under a very cost effective contract at $8.35M, and he's 22 years old.

Dobson is up for a contract at the end of this year, and is 2 years older.

 

[KevinRedkey]

Would love to swap Chabot for Romanov in some sort of deal, but it ain't happening. Dobson seems very unlikley to be traded.

 

[seabass45]

NYI view Barzal and Dobson the same way that Ottawa views Stützle and Sanderson.

Surprised no Islanders fans have came in here offering Pulock and Horvat as a counter for Tim and Sandy.

Pulock and Horvat both have full NTCs, although Isles fans here occasionally ignore Pulock’s. But Barzal has a modified NTC and I’ll guess that he would block this move.

Anyway the reason from the Isles side is that they could afford to trade Barzal for a natural wing and Dobson hasn’t had a great start this season and is due for an extension next year.

 

[SNES]

Hard pass from Ottawa. No disrespect to NYI players.