NHL Hockey Hall of Very Good

[FacialAbuse*]

Who belongs in here current or past?

I'll start; Pierre Turgeon, Markus Naslund, Marian Gaborik

Click to read more...

 

[HarryLime]

Patty Marleau

 

[ProspectsSTC]

Shea Weber

 

[SladeWilson23]

Toews

 

[MXD]

Shea Weber

D-Men with Weber's resume are in the HHOF, WITH ONE NOTABLE EXCEPTION, and Shea Weber would be a very odd candidate to start the trend of leaving them out (provided he continues to add games).

EDIT : The notable exception is Carl Brewer. The catch : Weber already has more complete seasons than Brewer.

 

[Whiston532]

Ryan Smyth

 

[matix218]

Toews

 

[uncleben]

Toews

topical. edgy.

Toews

original.

 

[karnige]

Alexander Mogilny

 

[Finlandia WOAT]

Rod Brind'Amour, Keith Primeau, Eric Desjardins, Ulf Samuelsson

 

[hotcabbagesoup]

Patrick Marleau.

 

[chaosrevolver]

Paul Kariya and Patrik Elias

 

[MXD]

Rod Brind'Amour, Keith Primeau, Eric Desjardins, Ulf Samuelsson

Primeau and Samuelsson are Hall of Good material...

 

[RiceCooker]

Bernie Nicholls

 

[TheTotalPackage]

Curtis Joseph
Chris Osgood
Brind'Amour

 

[Plural]

My favorite addition to the Hockey Hall of Very Good is Esa Tikkanen.

 

[Plural]

Paul Kariya and Patrik Elias

Both are candidates to make it in. In fact, I'd say that Kariya has a surprisingly good chance to go in with Selanne.

 

[SladeWilson23]

Paul Kariya and Patrik Elias

Elias should make it to the HOF, and Kariya has a strong case as well.

 

[malkshake]

Toews.

 

[Amazing Kreiderman]

Alexei Kovalev
Mike Richter
Sergei Zubov
Sergei Gonchar
Tony Amonte
Theo Fleury
Adam Graves

 

[sharkhawk]

I'll go with guys I consider just below HOF level, or debatable.

Larmer
Doug Wilson
Roenick
Nicholls
Tkachuk


I would vote for the first three for HOF if I had a vote, but they were the heart of my team when I had my season tickets, so I can see how they're boderline. But all of them would be first ballot in my HOVG.

 

[Nalens Oga]

Mummery, Harry 1923 - 17
Prodger, Goldie 1925 - 19
Adams, Jack 1927 - 17
Cleghorn, Odie 1928 - 18
Boucher, Billy 1928 - 21
Roach, John Ross 1935 - 21
Smith, Alex 1935 - 24
Chabot, Lorne 1937 - 26
Shields, Al 1938 - 27
Thompson, Paul 1939 - 26
Northcott, Lawrence 'Baldy' 1939 - 28
Wentworth, Melvin 'Cy' 1940 - 27
Dillon, Cecil 1940 - 30
Gagnon, Josh "Johnny" 1940 - 30
Mantha, Georges 1941 - 28
Kerr, Dave 1941 - 30
Wiseman, Eddie 1942 - 32
Gottselig, Johnny 1945 - 28
Jackson, Art 1945 - 34
Heller, Ott 1946 - 31
Cain, Herb 1946 - 33
Carr, Lorne 1946 - 33
Watson, Phil 1948 - 35
Crawford, Jack 1950 - 37
Stanowski, Wally 1951 - 39
Barilko, Bill 1951 - 46
Stewart, Gaye 1953 - 42
Conacher, Jim 1953 - 45
Goldham, Bob 1956 - 41
Thomson, Jimmy/James 1958 - 45
Peirson, Johnny 1958 - 46
Mortson, Gus 1959 - 46
Reibel, Earl "Dutch" 1959 - 53
Sullivan, Red 1961 - 49
Evans, Jack 1963 - 48
Stasiuk, Vic 1963 - 49
Fontinato, Lou 1963 - 54
Litzenberger, Ed 1964 - 52
Toppazzini, Jerry 1964 - 52
Wharram, Kenny 1969 - 51
Henry, Camille 1970 - 53
Vasko, Elmer "Moose" 1970 - 56
Arbour, Al 1971 - 53
Talbot, Jean-Guy 1971 - 54
Goyette, Phil 1972 - 57
Green, Ted 1972 - 60
Hillman, Larry 1973 - 54
Tremblay, Jean-Claude 1972 - 59
Stewart, Ron 1973 - 52
Baun, Bob 1973 - 56
Backstrom, Ralph 1973 - 56
Henderson Paul 1973 - 62
Prentice, Dean 1974 - 52
Mohns, Doug 1975 - 53
Shack, Eddie 1975 - 58
Harris, Ted 1975 - 63
Rousseau, Bobby 1975 - 60
Bergman, Gary 1976 - 64
Redmond, Mickey 1976 - 67
Nevin, Bob 1976 - 57
Hadfield, Vic 1977 - 61
Marotte, Gilles 1977 - 65
Van Impe, Ed 1977 - 66
Plager, Barclay 1977 - 67
Smith, Dallas 1978 - 59
Berenson, Gordon 'Red' 1978 - 61
Roberts, Jimmy 1978 - 63
Hodge, Ken 1978 - 64
Hull, Dennis 1978 - 64
Stanfield, Fred 1978 - 64
Sanderson, Derek 1978 - 65
Martin, Pit 1979 - 61
Westfall Ed 1979 - 61
Seiling, Rod 1979 - 62
Neilson, Jim 1979 - 62
McKenny, Jim 1979 - 65
Parise, JP 1979 - 65
Walton, Mike 1979 - 65
Brewer, Carl 1980 - 57
Cheevers, Gerry 1980 - 61
Lacroix, Andre 1980 - 67
Hextall, Dennis 1980 - 68
Apps Jr., Syl 1980 - 70
Tallon, Dale 1980 - 70
Guevremont, Jocelyn 1980 - 71
Harper, Terry 1981 - 62
Ellis, Ron 1981 - 63
Mahovlich, Pete 1981 - 65
Tkaczuk, Walt 1981 - 67
Burrows, Dave 1981 - 71
Kearns, Dennis 1981 - 71
Pronovost, Jean 1982 - 68
Redmond, Dick 1982 - 69
Murdoch, Bob 1982 - 70
Robert, Rene 1982 - 70
Stackhouse, Ron 1982 - 70
Martin, Rick 1982 - 71
Vickers, Steve 1982 - 72
Vail, Eric 1982 - 73
Rautakallio, Pekka 1982 - 79
Cashman, Wayne 1983 - 64
Vadnais, Carol 1983 - 66
Unger, Garry 1983 - 67
Leach, Reggie 1983 - 70
Turnbull, Ian 1983 - 73
Sargent, Gary 1983 - 75
Nilsson, Ulf 1983 - 78
MacLeish, Rick 1984 - 70
Goring, "Butch" Robert 1985 - 69
Boldirev, Ivan 1985 - 71
Kehoe, Rick 1985 - 71
O'Reilly, Terry 1985 - 71
Korab, Jerry 1985 - 70
Nystrom, Bob 1986 - 72
Lysiak, Tom 1986 - 73
Persson, Stefan 1986 - 77
Rogers, Mike 1986 - 79
Stastny, Marian 1986 - 81
Bubla, Jiri 1986 - 82
Lindbergh, Pelle 1985 - 81
Russell, Phil 1987 - 72
McNab, Peter 1987 - 73
Resch, Glenn "Chico" 1987 - 73
Gare, Danny 1987 - 74
Nilsson, Kent 1987 - 77
Gradin, Thomas 1987 - 78
Siltanen, Risto 1987 - 79
Lewis, Dave 1988 - 73
Middleton, Rick 1988 - 74
Larouche, Pierre 1988 - 74
Paiement, Wilf 1988 - 74
Simmer, Charlie 1988 - 74
McEwen, Mike 1988 - 76
Sutter, Brian 1988 - 76
Bridgman, Mel 1989 - 75
Maruk, Dennis 1989 - 75
Duguay, Ron 1989 - 77
Gustafsson, Bengt-Ake 1989 - 79
Hartsburg, Craig 1989 - 79
Stastny, Anton 1989 - 80
Jonsson, Tomas 1989 - 81
Loob, Hakan 1989 - 83
Greschner, Ron 1990 - 74
Murray, Bob 1990 - 75
Larson, Reed 1990 - 76
Beck, Barry 1990 - 77
O'Connell, Mike 1990 - 77
Picard, Robert 1990 - 77
Reinhart, Paul 1990 - 79
Ruotsalainen, Reijo 1990 - 81
Krutov, Vladimir 1990 - 89
Snepsts, Harold 1991 - 74
Green, Rick 1991 - 76
Smyl, Stan 1991 - 78
Linseman, Ken 1991 - 78
MacLean, Paul 1991 - 80
Marois, Mario 1992 - 77
Vaive, Rick 1992 - 78
Tonelli, John 1992 - 78
Pederson, Barry 1992 - 80
Bullard, Mike 1992 - 80
Sinisalo, Ilkka 1992 - 81
Sundstrom, Patrik 1992 - 82
Carlyle, Randy 1993 - 76
Wilson, Doug 1993 - 77
Smith, Bobby 1993 - 78
Ogrodnick, John 1993 - 79
Kerr, Tim 1993 - 80
Mullen, Brian 1993 - 82
Erixon, Jan 1993 - 83
Taylor, Dave 1994 - 77
Foligno, Mike 1994 - 79
Christian, Dave 1994 - 79
Propp, Brian 1994 - 79
Ramage Rob 1994 - 79
Crossman Doug 1994 - 80
Brown, Keith 1995 - 79
Larmer, Steve 1995 - 80
Steen, Thomas 1995 - 81
Naslund, Mats 1995 - 82
Kisio, Kelly 1995 - 82
Carson, Jimmy 1996 - 86
Kasatonov, Alexei 1996 - 89
McCrimmon, Brad 1997 - 78
Ramsey, Mike 1997 - 79
Broten, Neal 1997 - 80
Beaupre, Don 1997 - 80
Flatley, Patrick 1997 - 83
Leeman, Gary 1997 - 83
Quinn, Dan 1997 - 83
Ridley, Mike 1997 - 85
Konstantinov, Vladimir 1997 - 91
Lowe, Kevin 1998 - 79
Moog, Andy 1998 - 80
Sutter, Brent 1998 - 80
Driver, Bruce 1998 - 83
Iafrate, Al 1998 - 84
Bradley, Brian 1998 - 85
Brown, Jeff 1998 - 85
Samuelsson, Kjell 1998 - 85
Carpenter, Bob 1999 - 71
Babych, Dave 1999 - 80
Hunter, Dale 1999 - 80
Nicholls, Bernie 1999 - 81
Bellows, Brian 1999 - 82
Ludwig, Craig 1999 - 82
Lidster, Doug 1999 - 83
Gagner, Dave 1999 - 84
Sandstrom, Tomas 1999 - 84
Tikkanen, Esa 1999 - 85
Beukeboom, Jeff 1999 - 86
Carkner, Terry 1999 - 86
Chiasson, Steve 1999 - 86
Hextall, Ron 1999-86
Janney, Craig 1999 - 87
Tinordi, Mark 1999 - 87
Carbonneau, Guy 2000 - 80
Courtnall, Geoff 2000 - 83
McSorley, Marty 2000 - 83
Rouse, Bob 2000 - 83
Ellett, Dave 2000 - 84
Samuelsson, Ulf 2000 - 84
Bodger, Doug 2000 - 84
Clark, Wendel 2000 - 85
Ranford, Bill 2000 - 85
Galley, Garry 2001 - 84
Svoboda, Petr 2001 - 84
Hatcher, Kevin 2001 - 85
McLean, Kirk 2001 - 85
Gusarov, Alexei 2001 - 90
Mironov, Dmitri 2001 - 91
Verbeek, Pat 2002 - 82
Vernon, Mike 2002 - 82
MacLean, John 2002 - 83
Patrick, James 2002 - 83
Ferraro, Ray 2002 - 84
Tocchet, Rick 2002 - 84
Vanbiesbrouck, John 2002 - 84
Richer, Stephane 2002 - 84
Suter, Gary 2002 - 85
Duchesne Steve 2002 - 86
Manson, Dave 2002 - 86
Kamensky, Valeri 2002 - 91
Barrasso, Tom 2003 - 83
Daneyko, Ken 2003 - 83
Cote, Sylvain 2003 - 84
Dineen, Kevin 2003 - 84
Gill, Todd 2003 - 84
Muller, Kirk 2003 - 84
Olausson, Fredrik 2003 - 86
Krupp, Uwe 2003 - 86
Graves, Adam 2003 - 87
Fleury, Theoren 2003 - 88
Lumme, Jyrki 2003 - 88
Richter, Mike 2003 - 89
Yushkevich, Dmitry 2003 - 92
Deadmarsh, Adam 2003 - 94
Svehla, Robert 2003 - 94
Thomas, Steve 2004 - 84
Damphousse, Vincent 2004 - 86
Ronning, Cliff 2004 - 86
Johansson, Calle 2004 - 87
Audette, Donald 2004 - 90
Irbe, Arturs 2004 - 91
Potvin, Felix 2004 - 91
Renberg, Mikael 2004 - 93
Mironov, Boris 2004 - 93
Bure, Valeri 2004 - 94
Jonsson, Kenny 2004 - 94
Salo, Tommy 2004 - 94
Ragnarsson, Marcus 2004 - 95
Andreychuk, Dave 2006 - 82
Young Scott 2006 - 87
Desjardins, Eric 2006 - 88
Weinrich, Eric 2006 - 88
Cassels, Andrew 2006 - 89
Mogilny, Alexander 2006 - 89
Odelein, Lyle 2006 - 89
Primeau, Keith 2006 - 90
Malakhov Vladimir 2006 - 92
Zhamnov, Alexei 2006 - 92
Allison, Jason 2006 - 93
Daze, Eric 2006 - 94
Palffy, Zigmund 2006 - 93
Mellanby, Scott 2007 - 85
Burke, Sean 2007 - 87
Turgeon, Pierre 2007 - 87
Bondra, Peter 2007 - 90
LeClair, John 2007 - 90
Nedved, Petr 2007 - 90
Ricci, Mike 2007 - 90
Amonte, Tony 2007 - 91
Kasparaitis, Darius 2007 - 92
Yashin, Alexei 2007 - 93
Friesen, Jeff 2007 - 94
Tverodvsky, Oleg 2007 - 95
Gelinas, Martin 2008 - 88
Linden, Trevor 2008 - 88
Sanderson, Geoff 2008 - 90
Hatcher, Derian 2008 - 91
Rucinsky, Martin 2008 - 91
Stumpel, Jozef 2008 - 91
Klemm, Jon 2008 - 91
Murray, Glen 2008 - 92
Ozolinsh, Sandis 2008 - 92
Straka, Martin 2008 - 92
Modry, Jaroslav 2008 - 93
Norstrom, Mattias 2008 - 93
Thibault, Jocelyn 2008 - 93
Miller, Aaron 2008 - 93
Kapanen, Sami 2008 - 95
Berard, Bryan 2008 - 96
Nagy, Ladislav 2008 - 99
Wesley, Glen 2008 – 87
Zhitnik, Alexei 2008 – 92
Lemieux, Claude 2009 - 83
Roberts, Gary 2009 - 86
Numminen, Teppo 2009 - 88
Roenick, Jeremy 2009 - 88
Joseph, Curtis 2009 - 89
Kolzig , Olaf 2009 - 89
Holik, Bobby 2009 - 90
Hedican, Brett 2009 - 91
Nylander, Michael 2009 - 92
Zubov, Sergei 2009 - 92
Gratton, Chris 2009 - 93
Naslund, Markus 2009 - 93
Peca, Michael 2009 - 93
Kozlov, Viktor 2009 - 94
Zednik, Richard 2009 - 95
Axelsson, PJ 2009 - 97
Schneider, Mathieu 2010 - 87
Brind’Amour, Rod 2010 - 89
Nolan, Owen 2010 - 90
Guerin, Bill 2010 - 91
Sydor, Darryl 2010 - 91
Tkachuk, Keith 2010 - 91
Lang, Robert 2010 - 92
Demitra, Pavol 2010 - 93
Kariya, Paul 2010 - 95
Kozlov, Slava 2010 - 95
Lehtinen, Jere 2010 - 95
Satan, Miroslav 2010 - 95
Afinogenov, Maxim 2010 - 99
Johnsson, Kim 2010 - 99
Recchi, Mark 2011 - 88
Foote, Adam 2011 - 91
Weight, Doug 2011 - 91
Osgood, Chris 2011 - 93
Stillman, Cory 2011 - 94
McCabe, Bryan 2011 - 95
Modin, Fredrik 2011 - 96
Samsonov, Sergei 2011 - 97
Ohlund, Mattias 2011 - 97
Savard, Marc 2011 - 97
Drury, Chris 2011 - 98
Rafalski, Brian 2011 - 99
Turco, Marty 2012 - 00
Arnott, Jason 2012 - 93
Brunette, Andrew 2012 - 95
Sykora, Petr 2012 - 95
Rolston, Brian 2012 - 95
Holmstrom, Tomas 2012 - 96
Roloson, Dwayne 2012 - 96
Kubina, Pavel 2012 - 97
Morrison, Brendan 2012 - 97
Spacek, Jaroslav 2012 - 98
Madden, John 2012 - 98
McDonald, Andy 2013 - 00
Kiprusoff, Mika 2013 - 00
Kovalchuk, Ilya 2013 - 01
Pitkanen, Joni 2013 - 03
Kovalev, Alexei 2013 - 92
Hamrlik, Roman 2013 - 92
Aucoin, Adrian 2013 - 94
Langenbrunner, Jamie 2013 - 94
Sullivan, Steve 2013 - 95
Theodore, Jose 2013 - 95
Prospal, Vinny 2013 - 96
Redden, Wade 2013 - 96
Knuble, Mike 2013 - 96
Vokoun, Tomas 2013 - 96
Souray, Sheldon 2013 - 97
Hejduk, Milan 2013 - 98
Kuba, Filip 2013 - 98
Kaberle, Tomas 2013 - 98
Thomas, Tim 2014 - 02
Horton, Nathan 2014 - 03
Whitney, Ray 2014 - 91
Jovanovski, Ed 2014 - 95
Smyth, Ryan 2014 - 95
Alfredsson, Daniel 2014 - 95
Koivu, Saku 2014 - 95
Khabibulin, Nikolai 2014 - 95
Bertuzzi, Todd 2014 - 95
Giguere, Jean-Sebastien 2014 - 96
Morris, Derek 2014 - 97
Salo, Sami 2014 - 98
Visnovsky, Lubomir 2015 - 00
Cole, Erik 2015 - 01
Heatley, Dany 2015 - 01
Bryzgalov, Ilya 2015 - 01
Semin, Alexander 2015 - 03
Gagne, Simone 2015 - 07
Hiller, Jonas 2015 - 07
Gonchar, Sergei 2015 - 94
Elias, Patrik 2015 - 95
Briere, Daniel 2015 - 97
Jokinen, Olli 2015 - 97
Timonen, Kimmo 2015 - 98
Brewer, Eric 2015 - 98
Nabokov, Evgeni 2015 - 99
Regehr, Robyn 2015 - 99
Morrow, Brenden 2015 - 99
Robidas, Stephane 2015 - 99
Richards, Brad 2016 - 00
Havlat, Martin 2016 - 00
Jackman, Barret 2016 - 01
Ehrhoff, Christian 2016 - 03
Michalek, Milan 2016 - 03
Boyes, Brad 2016 - 05
Richards, Mike 2016 - 05
Backstrom, Niklas 2016 - 06
Zubrus, Dainius 2016 - 96
Boyle, Dan 2016 - 98
Lecavelier, Vincent 2016 - 98
Phillips, Chris 2016 - 98
Gomez, Scott 2016 - 99
Mitchell, Willie 2016 - 99
Tanguay, Alex 2016 - 99

 

[authentic]

Evgeni Malkin.

 

[Plastic Joseph]

Vinny Lecavalier, although his talent was beyond HOF worthy.

 

[MXD]

Wait, did somebody just suggested TERRY CARKNER?