NHL 16 player overalls predictions thread

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/

izzy

go
Apr 29, 2012
86,845
18,801
Nova Scotia
:canes

Nobody has done the great canes... So here I am.
My Opinions on what they'd be.
(In alphabetized order)
Brett Bellemore 75
Zach Boychuk 77
Patrick Dwyer(if he resigns) 80
Justin Faulk 80
Nathan Gerbe 81
Ron Hainsey 79
Jack Hillen 78/79
Michal Jordan 75
Eddie Lack 83
John-Michael Liles 81
Elias Lindholm 80
Brad Malone 73/74
Jay Mcclement 86
Ryan Murphy 74
Riley Nash 74
Andrej Nestrasil 72/73
Victor Rask 75/76
Rasmus Rissanen 71/72
Jeff Skinner 89
Eric Staal 90
Jordan Staal 87
Chris Terry 75
Cam Ward 88/89
James Wisniewski 85

Some players the ratings i have people might think different. These are the main players that i think fit in that category.


Eddie Lack: In my opinion, 83 is a little high for most backups but in this case i think Lack will be a Starter but be backup to Ward as Ward will be an Elite. Lack has put up pretty good numbers with Vancouver as their starter and I think he will do just as well in net for the canes. Since he is a stellar goalie he can backup well if Ward goes down. THIS IS THE PROBLEM WITH THE CANES: When Ward went down last year nobody was to backup him. Khudobin wasn't that well and we couldn't have our offense do well enough to come back from a 4-0 deficit every night he was in net. Also, with Lack working with EA on the new goalie moves ingame i feel Lack would get a little spike in the game.

Jay McClement: I think he would be a 86 due to this, in 14 he was 80 and 15 he was 82. He should make a spike up to 86 even though he had 21 points with the canes(7 Goals 14 Assists) but he played every game for the canes and they've rewarded him with a pretty decent extension. He has been a nice player to use when you need somebody to get a quick goal and things along those lines.

Those have been my ratings for the Carolina Hurricanes. #TheStormIsComing

Liles 81

Faulk 80
 

Habsfan2731

Registered User
Jan 2, 2014
4,621
1
Toronto
My prediction for Montreal:

C:
Tomas Plekanec - 86
David Desharnais - 84
Lars Eller - 84
Torrey Mitchell - 79

LW:
Max Pacioretty - 89
Alex Galchenyuk - 85
Jacob de la Rose - 75
Michael Bournival - 78
Brian Flynn - 75

RW:
Brendan Gallagher - 85
Alexander Semin - 82
Devante Smith-Pelly - 80
Zack Kassian - 81
Dale Weise - 79
Christian Thomas - 75

D:
PK Subban - 89
Andrei Markov - 87
Jeff Petry - 86
Nathan Beaulieu - 83
Alexei Emelin - 82
Tom Gilbert - 81
Greg Pateryn - 74
Jarred Tinordi - 74
Mark Barberio - 77

G:
Carey Price - 95
Dustin Tokarski - 76
 

Erik Alfredsson

Beast Mode Cowboy!
Jan 14, 2012
13,369
5,579
Ottawa:

MacArthur(84)-Turris(87)-Stone(85)
Hoffman(83)-Zibanejad(86)-Ryan(87)
Michalek(82)-Pageau(83)-Lazar(81)
Puempel(77)-Smith(80)-Chiasson(78)

Methot(86)-Karlsson(91)
Weircioch(83)-Ceci(84)
Borowecki(81)-Cowen(80)

Anderson(87)
Hammond(84)
 

Igor Shestyorkin

#26, the sickest of 'em all.
Apr 17, 2015
11,090
842
Moscow, RUS
Toronto will be way overrated.

JVR(88) - Kadri(86) - Panik(79)
Lupul(82) - Bozak(82) - PAP(81)
Matthias(80) - Holland(78) - Winnink(82)
Komarov(80) - Spaling(81) - Arcobello(80)

Rielly(85) - Phaneuf(84)
Gardiner(84) - Polak(81)
Marincin(78) - Robidas(73)

Bernier(85)
Reimer(84)

are those fair ratings? lol
 

bigdog16

Registered User
Nov 7, 2013
4,589
4,576
USA
JVR(88) - Kadri(86) - Panik(79)
Lupul(82) - Bozak(82) - PAP(81)
Matthias(80) - Holland(78) - Winnink(82)
Komarov(80) - Spaling(81) - Arcobello(80)

Rielly(85) - Phaneuf(84)
Gardiner(84) - Polak(81)
Marincin(78) - Robidas(73)

Bernier(85)
Reimer(84)

are those fair ratings? lol

Haha no. Not one player in their bottom 6 forwards for the exception of maybe Winnik should be 80+
 

Vinnyc5

Registered User
Jul 21, 2014
1
0
Blackhawks

Blackhawks:

A.Panarin(83) J.Toews(95) M.Hossa(90)

P.Kane(92) A.Anisimov(85) M.Dano(84)

K.Versteeg(82) M.Kruger(84) A.Shaw(85)

R.Garbutt(82) A.Dejardins(80) T. Teravinein(85)




D.Keith(94) B.Seabrook(90)

N.Hjalmarsson(88) T.Daley(86)

T.Van Riemsdyk(80) M.Rosival(80)



C.Crawford(90)
S.Darling(82)




Extra Players: Ville Pokka(78-80) Ryan Hartman(80) B.Bickell(80) Mark McNeill(80) Garett Ross(78) P.Dauntlat(76) Joakim Nordstrom(79)
 

Beezeral

Registered User
Mar 1, 2010
10,028
5,223
Blackhawks:

A.Panarin(83) J.Toews(95) M.Hossa(90)

P.Kane(92) A.Anisimov(85) M.Dano(84)

K.Versteeg(82) M.Kruger(84) A.Shaw(85)

R.Garbutt(82) A.Dejardins(80) T. Teravinein(85)




D.Keith(94) B.Seabrook(90)

N.Hjalmarsson(88) T.Daley(86)

T.Van Riemsdyk(80) M.Rosival(80)



C.Crawford(90)
S.Darling(82)




Extra Players: Ville Pokka(78-80) Ryan Hartman(80) B.Bickell(80) Mark McNeill(80) Garett Ross(78) P.Dauntlat(76) Joakim Nordstrom(79)
Yea. You are pretty far off. Crawford will not be top 5 for goalies, TT won't be in the upper 20% at 85 ovr. Also not a single guy in the 70s on the 18 man roster? No chance
 

Beezeral

Registered User
Mar 1, 2010
10,028
5,223
Toronto will be way overrated.

called it.

From the Be a GM video just posted by EA

JVR (88)-Bozak (86)-Lupul (86)
PAP(82)-Kadri (86)-Winnik (84)
Matthias (84)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (83)Panik(81)

Others seen
Rielly (87)
Phaneuf (86)
Robidas (81)
Bernier (85)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (69)

every year EA, every year.
 

Wooren

no longer perennial 4th place losers
May 17, 2015
2,439
1,475
Prague
Blackhawks:

A.Panarin(83) J.Toews(95) M.Hossa(90)

P.Kane(92) A.Anisimov(85) M.Dano(84)

K.Versteeg(82) M.Kruger(84) A.Shaw(85)

R.Garbutt(82) A.Dejardins(80) T. Teravinein(85)




D.Keith(94) B.Seabrook(90)

N.Hjalmarsson(88) T.Daley(86)

T.Van Riemsdyk(80) M.Rosival(80)



C.Crawford(90)
S.Darling(82)




Extra Players: Ville Pokka(78-80) Ryan Hartman(80) B.Bickell(80) Mark McNeill(80) Garett Ross(78) P.Dauntlat(76) Joakim Nordstrom(79)
You can't be serious.. :facepalm:

called it.

From the Be a GM video just posted by EA

JVR (88)-Bozak (86)-Lupul (86)
PAP(82)-Kadri (86)-Winnik (84)
Matthias (84)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (83)Panik(81)

Others seen
Rielly (87)
Phaneuf (86)
Robidas (81)
Bernier (85)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (69)

every year EA, every year.

Maybe there's still tweaking to be done. But agree those are way off.
 

Alexander the Gr8

Registered User
May 2, 2013
31,857
13,238
Toronto
Blackhawks:

A.Panarin(83) J.Toews(95) M.Hossa(90)

P.Kane(92) A.Anisimov(85) M.Dano(84)

K.Versteeg(82) M.Kruger(84) A.Shaw(85)

R.Garbutt(82) A.Dejardins(80) T. Teravinein(85)




D.Keith(94) B.Seabrook(90)

N.Hjalmarsson(88) T.Daley(86)

T.Van Riemsdyk(80) M.Rosival(80)



C.Crawford(90)
S.Darling(82)




Extra Players: Ville Pokka(78-80) Ryan Hartman(80) B.Bickell(80) Mark McNeill(80) Garett Ross(78) P.Dauntlat(76) Joakim Nordstrom(79)

Toews and Seabrook at 95 and 90 ?? :amazed:

Also, why do you have Teravainen on the 4th line at RW ? I'm pretty sure he's the #3C.
 

Samuel Culper III

Mr. Woodhull...
Jan 15, 2007
13,144
1,099
Texas
called it.

From the Be a GM video just posted by EA

JVR (88)-Bozak (86)-Lupul (86)
PAP(82)-Kadri (86)-Winnik (84)
Matthias (84)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (83)Panik(81)

Others seen
Rielly (87)
Phaneuf (86)
Robidas (81)
Bernier (85)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (69)

every year EA, every year.

Anyone want to tell me what Morgan Reilly has done to start the game as an 87? Please? If he's an 87, are Erik Karlsson and Duncan Keith 102-105? Because they sure as **** aren't a mere 3-5 points better than Morgan Reilly right now.
 

Igor Shestyorkin

#26, the sickest of 'em all.
Apr 17, 2015
11,090
842
Moscow, RUS
Anyone want to tell me what Morgan Reilly has done to start the game as an 87? Please? If he's an 87, are Erik Karlsson and Duncan Keith 102-105? Because they sure as **** aren't a mere 3-5 points better than Morgan Reilly right now.

This. Morgan Rielly would be better off at an 84-85.
 

Igor Shestyorkin

#26, the sickest of 'em all.
Apr 17, 2015
11,090
842
Moscow, RUS
called it.

From the Be a GM video just posted by EA

JVR (88)-Bozak (86)-Lupul (86)
PAP(82)-Kadri (86)-Winnik (84)
Matthias (84)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (83)Panik(81)

Others seen
Rielly (87)
Phaneuf (86)
Robidas (81)
Bernier (85)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (69)

every year EA, every year.


Well there will be a good amount of editing the rosters and overalls for us NHL 16 buyers.

I also saw Weber(94), Stamkos(93), Doughty(93), Suter(93 and I don't have any idea why he is this high), Keith(93), Datsyuk(93), Zetterberg(92), Kane(92), Perry(92), a lot of the ratings are the same as last year....
 

Beezeral

Registered User
Mar 1, 2010
10,028
5,223
Anyone want to tell me what Morgan Reilly has done to start the game as an 87? Please? If he's an 87, are Erik Karlsson and Duncan Keith 102-105? Because they sure as **** aren't a mere 3-5 points better than Morgan Reilly right now.

I am going to rage when Ekblad is rated below Reilly.
 

The Great Weal

Phil's Pizza
Jan 15, 2015
54,105
68,812
Price 95
Subban 91
Pacioretty 90
Plekanec 87
Markov 87
Petry 85
Galchenyuk 85
Gallagher 85
Semin 84
Eller 84
Beaulieu 83
Emelin 83
Kassian 83
DD 83
Tokarski 82
DSP 82
Weise 81
Mitchell 81
Gilbert 81
DLR 80
Flynn 79
Pateryn 79
Tinordi 79
 

teravaineSAROS

Registered User
Jul 29, 2015
3,875
1,579
called it.

From the Be a GM video just posted by EA

JVR (88)-Bozak (86)-Lupul (86)
PAP(82)-Kadri (86)-Winnik (84)
Matthias (84)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (83)Panik(81)

Others seen
Rielly (87)
Phaneuf (86)
Robidas (81)
Bernier (85)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (69)

every year EA, every year.


It doesn't help if you edit them either. I decreased Toronto's player ratings on NHL 15 (to lower than what they would be so their seasons are realistic) and they're still consistent Stanley Cup contenders and often manage to get the Presidents Trophy within the first three years.
 

Beezeral

Registered User
Mar 1, 2010
10,028
5,223
It doesn't help if you edit them either. I decreased Toronto's player ratings on NHL 15 (to lower than what they would be so their seasons are realistic) and they're still consistent Stanley Cup contenders and often manage to get the Presidents Trophy within the first three years.

That's what happens when their entire first two lines have "elite" potential
 

Picaroon

Registered User
Apr 6, 2008
3,210
1,441
New Brunswick
Price 95
Subban 91
Pacioretty 90
Plekanec 87
Markov 87
Petry 85
Galchenyuk 85
Gallagher 85
Semin 84
Eller 84
Beaulieu 83
Emelin 83
Kassian 83
DD 83
Tokarski 82
DSP 82
Weise 81
Mitchell 81
Gilbert 81
DLR 80
Flynn 79
Pateryn 79
Tinordi 79

I think you are over rating quite a bit.

Subban 91
Pacioretty 88
Plekanec 85
Markov 85
Petry 84
Galchenyuk 83
Gallagher 84
Semin 80
Eller 82
Beaulieu 79
Emelin 81
Kassian 80
DD 80
Tokarski 78
DSP 78
Weise 79
Mitchell 79
Gilbert 80
DLR 77
Flynn 75
Pateryn 77
Tinordi 75

That is what I would say.
 

NylanderBros

Registered User
Jun 22, 2014
409
206
Sudbury, Ont
called it.

From the Be a GM video just posted by EA

JVR (88)-Bozak (86)-Lupul (86)
PAP(82)-Kadri (86)-Winnik (84)
Matthias (84)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (83)Panik(81)

Others seen
Rielly (87)
Phaneuf (86)
Robidas (81)
Bernier (85)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (69)

every year EA, every year.

Should be..

JVR (86)-Bozak (82)-Lupul (84)
PAP(81)-Kadri (85)-Winnik (82)
Matthias (82)-Arcobello (79)-Komarov (83)
Holland(80)-Spalding (77)Panik(80)

Others seen
Rielly (85)
Phaneuf (85)
Robidas (80)
Bernier (84)
Frattin (78)
Nylander (78)
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad