Nathan MacKinnon, on par with the best in business?

[Sasso09]

Still. Based on this season I take Mack over McDavid.
Over all..... a coin toss.

Outside of the Hawks Mackinnon and Kaprizov are my favorite players, Mack a man amongst boys with elite talent, you have to love him.

That being said, McDavid has no rivals

He's HIM