Proposal: MTL - BUF
- Thread starter alasania94
- Start date
pth2
Registered User
- Jan 7, 2018
- 3,497
- 2,774
There is reason to believe some teams offered up to a late first for Xhekaj, so this is like giving a 5th and a 25th overall for a not-that-impressive smallish winger.
I'd pass, as a Habs fan.
I'd pass, as a Habs fan.
calling him a "not-that-impressive smallish winger" tells me you've never watched him play.
1. He's a gamer that's always involved in the play and a top notch goal scorer already at 22 years old.
2. He's 5'11 - 195 lbs - stocky. and there is NOTHING small about his game. Actually has a really high amount of grit and flair for the dramatic for a top 6 winger.
Interesting idea. I don't know if Buffalo would be open to it since they need guys to be start hitting their stride - which Peterka and his 17 ESG thus far is certainly showing toward - rather than trying to get even more futures. The pick isn't all that interesting, it's just perpetually waiting for tomorrow.
I like Xhekaj, but not for Peterka.
I like Xhekaj, but not for Peterka.
The idea was Buffalo acquiring Xhekaj and using the 2024 1st (6-9th overall) as a trade chip to acquire another player as well as part of another package i.e. 2024 1st + Savoie for Guentzel
so they trade Peterka and Savoie and receive Xhekaj and Guentzel
Eh, I'd rather keep Peterka. If you want to talk about something like Rosen or Savoie for Xhekaj and a pick, I'm sure that would be more interesting. Like I said, JJ's just hitting his stride and they need more of that, not less.
There is levels to this game and peterka isn’t even close to a top 5 ish pick level.
I don’t think Xhekaj is going anywhere especially not for Rosen or Savoie
toddkaz
Registered User
- Nov 25, 2022
- 6,479
- 3,943
Come on man, thats a hell no. Do you think Buffalo is going to just rebuild forever?
I would never trade Peterka for picks. Peterka still hasn't reached his ceiling.
Also wasn't Xhekaj a healthy scratch?
Don't know if the difference between peterka and Xhekaj is a top 10 pick.
I do however think the Habs could definitely use a pretty skilled pest with a high motor since Gally is pretty much dead.
I do however think the Habs could definitely use a pretty skilled pest with a high motor since Gally is pretty much dead.
toddkaz
Registered User
- Nov 25, 2022
- 6,479
- 3,943
Then I would think there is no deal to be had. Buffalo doesn't need to trade a productive young player still with a year on his ELC for a magic bean, even a very good magic bean, and their other likely moved prospects aren't intriguing to Montreal to make that sort of move.
Gallagher is not a bad comparison for Peterka in a certain way, except he's way more refined in the offensive parts of the game. I can easily see him putting up 35/40 goals 35 ish assists regularly in 1-2 years time.
I just remember Peterka single handedly destroying Utica's hopes and dreams.
BLNY
Registered User
Peterka's having a nice season. He fits the mould of what Hughes likes to do in trade, so I understand the premise.
It's not easy to gauge wifi's value, but it's certainly considerable within the Canadiens organization. Enough so that I don't think they'd trade him with a lottery first for Peterka.
It's not easy to gauge wifi's value, but it's certainly considerable within the Canadiens organization. Enough so that I don't think they'd trade him with a lottery first for Peterka.
Great, because we will pass too. I can't wait to see the Habs get 1st for Xhekaj. Sure. So Peterka for a 7th overall and a depth D man. Sorry, JJ has already shown he's a stud. Kid is on pace for 30 goals and 56 points and he's 22 with endless team control. Let's trade him for more magic beans.
DiglettDangles
Registered User
I don't know what is most messed up about this thread, the OP or that some people are actually entertaining it
Last edited:
DickSmehlik
Registered User
SannywithoutCompy
Registered User
- Dec 22, 2020
- 2,524
- 4,711
Peterka is great but you don't trade a likely top 10 pick without protection pre lottery lmao
I like Peterka a lot, but there's no way I see the Habs value him at a unprotected lottery 1st + Xhekaj, especially to a division rival.
Flames 1st + Strubble (who has largely outplayed X this year & is 9mo younger) or Harris... That might get KH to the table. Though as Sabres fans have pointed out, there's little reason for the Sabres to move him for picks/futures, so I don't think there's a deal here to be had
Flames 1st + Strubble (who has largely outplayed X this year & is 9mo younger) or Harris... That might get KH to the table. Though as Sabres fans have pointed out, there's little reason for the Sabres to move him for picks/futures, so I don't think there's a deal here to be had
No deal for both teams. I don't see why Buf would want to trade Peterka as I don't see why MTL would trade their 1rst round pick in a rebuild.
Trade make no sens
Trade make no sens
Don't see why either team does this, Peterka is starting to his stride and Buffalo needs to start climbing out of the basement, trading him for Xhekaj and another 1st round pick doesn't do that. Montreal doesn't do this because they are still in a rebuild and likely value Xhekaj and a high 1st round pick higher than Peterka.
Ad
Latest posts
-
-
Prospect Info: Caps Top Prospects General Discussion Thread - 2024- Latest: FourQuarters
-
-
